170 aid groups want US-based Gaza food program closed over ‘routine’ killings


This recording was made using enhanced software.

Summary

The request

Nearly 200 humanitarian aid organizations are calling on the U.S. and Israel-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation to be ousted from Gaza, citing “routine” killings at their distribution sites.

Defense

GHF denies its sites are unsafe and argues most of the deaths have occurred outside aid distribution sites.

Israel's response

Israel admits that some troops fired warning shots near distribution sites and has said it is investigating some incidents, but has also accused Hamas of killing civilians at these sites and blaming the IDF.


Full story

Around 170 charities and humanitarian aid groups want the U.S. and Israel-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) out of the enclave. In a joint statement published Monday, June 30, they accuse Israeli and other armed forces of “routinely” opening fire on Gazans seeking aid. 

What are the groups involved?

The call came from some of the world’s largest humanitarian organizations, including Oxfam, Amnesty International and Save the Children. They claim more than 500 Palestinians have been killed and nearly 4,000 hurt in less than four weeks while trying to access or distribute food in Gaza.

QR code for SAN app download

Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.

Point phone camera here

The organizations also argue the GHF’s lack of a plan and inadequate food supply is causing 2 million hungry people to traverse through dangerous areas, including active combat zones, to reach sites with a heavy military presence, where they are forced to “fight” for sparse food supplies in “chaotic enclosures.”

“These areas have become sites of repeated massacres in blatant disregard for international humanitarian law,” the joint statement read.

‘Death traps’

The Hamas-controlled Gaza Health Ministry called GHF distribution centers “death traps” in a statement on Tuesday, July 1. The organization reported 583 people had died since GHF first began operations in Gaza in May after a three-month blockade by Israel on humanitarian aid.

There were hundreds of aid distribution sites run by various organizations before the blockade, but now they have been replaced with just four distribution centers run by the GHF, according to the coalition of organizations.

Following GHF’s takeover of aid operations, there have been almost daily reports of Israeli forces firing at those seeking aid, which the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) refutes. The United Nations has also criticized GHF’s distribution plan, with Secretary-General Antonio Guterres on Friday arguing it is “inherently unsafe.”

GHF denies accusations

GHF denied Guterres’ accusation and told NBC News on Tuesday, July 1, it is “providing millions of meals each day directly to the Palestinian people who deserve and need aid.”

“Instead of bickering and throwing insults from the sidelines, we would welcome other humanitarian groups to join us and feed the people in Gaza,” the group added.

As of Tuesday, GHF said it has delivered more than 54 million meals, including 2 million meals on Tuesday alone.

Israel said it chose GHF because it can protect against aid distribution being diverted by Hamas, but announced on Monday that it would “examine” reports of people being injured at distribution centers and install fencing and signage to improve the environment.

The Israel Foreign Ministry on Tuesday accused Hamas militants of shooting at those seeking aid at humanitarian sites and wrongly blaming the IDF in an attempt to “disrupt aid efforts and keep the people of Gaza away from much needed aid.”

However, the Israeli military has acknowledged being involved in a number of incidents at food distribution sites. They have said troops fired warning shots or fired at people who threatened troops. GHF and the IDF said these attacks occurred outside of humanitarian sites.

At least 74 killed on Monday

Israeli forces continue operations in Gaza, including airstrikes and gunfire on Monday that killed dozens of people, according to officials

One airstrike at a seaside cafe in Gaza City killed at least 41 people, according to hospital officials. The establishment was a place where people, including journalists, often went to charge phones or get a secure internet connection. The cafe had been one of the few places that remained open since the start of the war in October 2023. 

Meanwhile, 11 people were killed by Israeli forces as they tried to get food in southern Gaza, according to the Hamas-controlled Gaza Health Ministry. Israel said it’s investigating the alleged attacks.

Jack Henry (Video Editor) and Ally Heath (Senior Digital Producer) contributed to this report.
Tags: , , , , ,

Why this story matters

Humanitarian organizations' criticism of the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation's operations highlights urgent concerns about aid distribution safety and effectiveness amid the ongoing conflict in Gaza.

Humanitarian aid access

Access to humanitarian aid in Gaza is being challenged by organizational disputes and alleged dangers at distribution sites, which affects the ability to provide relief to people in need.

Civilian safety

Reports of civilians being harmed at aid distribution points raise serious concerns about the protection of noncombatants during armed conflict.

Accountability and oversight

Disagreements over responsibility for violence at aid sites and the effectiveness of the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation underscore the need for transparent oversight and accountability in delivering humanitarian assistance.

Bias comparison

  • Media outlets on the left frame the Israeli- and U.S.-backed Gaza aid mechanism as "controversial," emphasizing tragic Palestinian deaths under Israeli airstrikes and portraying the aid group as complicit in violence, evoking a tone of condemnation and urgency.
  • Media outlets in the center adopt a more measured tone, presenting humanitarian concerns and official denials, offering less emotive rhetoric.
  • Media outlets on the right highlight the militarization and legal condemnation of the aid system, using emotive language like "abomination" and framing Palestinians as caught between "starvation or gunfire," underscoring structural blame on Israeli policies and emphasizing international legal actions absent in left coverage.

Media landscape

Click on bars to see headlines

89 total sources

Key points from the Left

  • Dozens of international charities, including Oxfam and Save the Children, called for an Israeli and U.S.-backed aid mechanism for Gaza to disband due to violence against Palestinians seeking aid.
  • At least seven Palestinians were killed seeking aid in Gaza between late Monday and early Tuesday, amid ongoing violence.
  • Israeli airstrikes reportedly killed at least 74 people in Gaza earlier Monday, including 30 at a cafe and 23 during food aid attempts, according to witnesses and health officials.
  • More than 56,000 Palestinians have died in the ongoing war, as reported by Gaza's Health Ministry.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Center

  • A joint statement from 130 charities states the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation is violating humanitarian norms, forcing two million people into overcrowded and militarized zones facing daily gunfire.
  • Reports indicate that Israeli forces have killed people seeking aid at GHF sites, according to medics, eyewitnesses, and the Hamas-run Health Ministry.
  • UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres described the aid situation as inherently unsafe amid severe hunger conditions.
  • Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu rejected allegations from reports indicating IDF soldiers were ordered to shoot at unarmed civilians near aid sites, calling them malicious falsehoods.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Right

  • More than 130 charities, including Oxfam, Save the Children, and Amnesty International, called for the end of a U.S.- and Israeli-backed aid system for Gaza, citing chaos and deadly attacks on aid seekers.
  • At least seven Palestinians were killed while seeking aid in Gaza, following an airstrike that killed 74 people earlier that day, as reported by health officials.
  • A coalition of over 170 organizations condemned Israel's military-controlled aid distribution system, claiming it forces civilians to choose between starvation and gunfire.
  • The Israeli military has faced accusations of war crimes, as more than 56,000 Palestinians have reportedly been killed since October 2023, according to Gaza's Health Ministry.

Report an issue with this summary

Other (sources without bias rating):

Powered by Ground News™