Body handed over by Hamas is not that of a hostage: Israeli military


This recording was made using enhanced software.

Summary

Remains are not hostage

Israeli officials say one of the bodies Hamas handed over on Tuesday is not that of a hostage.

Four more bodies

Hamas handed over four more bodies on Tuesday as part of the ceasefire deal calling for the return of all living and dead hostages.

Additional hostages still missing

Hamas failed to hand over the remains of all hostages by the ceasefire deal deadline of 72 hours after signing.


Full story

Israeli military officials say one of the four bodies Hamas handed over Tuesday was not that of a hostage taken on Oct. 7, 2023. Hamas handed over the remains as part of a ceasefire deal in the two-year-long war. 

The Israel Defense Forces said that “following the completion of examinations at the National Institute of Forensic Medicine, the fourth body handed over to Israel by Hamas does not match any of the hostages”.

QR code for SAN app download

Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.

Point phone camera here

Officials did not publicly identify the remains, but said that “Hamas is required to make all necessary efforts to return the deceased hostages.”

In an update early Wednesday, the Israeli military also identified the three other remains handed over on Tuesday. They were identified as Staff Sgt. Tamir Nimrodi, Uriel Baruch and Eitan Levi. 

Ceasefire deal’s first major test

The news comes just two days after Israel and Hamas signed a peace deal, which President Donald Trump helped broker. It also comes as the fragile ceasefire faces its first major test, as Israel slows aid to Gaza over the slow release of the remaining 28 deceased hostages. 

Israel argues the slow release of hostages’ bodies violates the ceasefire plan. It told the United Nations it will respond to the violation by blocking half the aid admitted into Gaza. 

The deal stipulated that all hostages would be handed over within 72 hours after the agreement was signed. That period expired Tuesday.

However, the plan also notes that should Hamas be unable to hand over all remaining hostages within that timeframe, it should share information about the remaining hostages and “exert maximum effort” to carry out the handover as soon as possible.

As of Wednesday, Hamas has handed over a total of eight remains. It also released all 20 living hostages on Monday. 

Hamas returns to Gaza

Since the signing, Hamas has returned to the streets of Gaza in a show of force. The group has reportedly clashed with armed groups and publicly executed people. 

Hamas said it is attempting to restore law and order in areas where Israeli troops have withdrawn. Meanwhile, Trump’s plan calls for Hamas to disarm and let an internationally supervised body take over in Gaza. However, that body has not yet been formed. 

“We have told them we want disarm and they will disarm,” Trump said. “And if they don’t disarm, we will disarm them. And it’ll happen quickly and perhaps violently.”

Alan Judd (Content Editor) contributed to this report.
Tags: , ,

SAN provides
Unbiased. Straight Facts.

Don’t just take our word for it.


Certified balanced reporting

According to media bias experts at AllSides

AllSides Certified Balanced May 2025

Transparent and credible

Awarded a perfect reliability rating from NewsGuard

100/100

Welcome back to trustworthy journalism.

Find out more

Why this story matters

The misidentification of a body returned to Israel as part of a ceasefire agreement highlights challenges in the implementation of hostage exchanges, straining the fragile truce and complicating humanitarian aid efforts in Gaza.

Hostage exchange challenges

The erroneous return of a non-hostage body underscores difficulties faced by both Israel and Hamas in identifying and recovering the remaining hostages, affecting families and confidence in the ceasefire mechanism.

Ceasefire tensions

Breakdowns in agreement such as this incident threaten the stability of the recently brokered ceasefire, as both parties cite violations and accuse each other of not fully honoring their commitments.

Humanitarian aid delays

According to multiple sources, disputes over the return of hostages' remains have led Israel to restrict the flow of humanitarian aid into Gaza, exacerbating the humanitarian crisis for civilians.

Get the big picture

Synthesized coverage insights across 132 media outlets

Community reaction

Families of hostages have publicly expressed sorrow and concern over the mistaken body return and the slow pace of retrieving all the deceased. In Israel communities have lined streets to honor returning hostages or their remains.

Global impact

The hostage-body exchange has direct international ramifications, impacting U.S. diplomatic involvement and leading to global attention on humanitarian and security issues in Gaza. Reductions in aid potentially affect regional stability and international humanitarian efforts.

Oppo research

Israeli officials and nationalist politicians criticize Hamas for failing to fulfill the ceasefire terms and call for increased pressure or sanctions in response to delays and mistakes in returning hostages' bodies.

SAN provides
Unbiased. Straight Facts.

Don’t just take our word for it.


Certified balanced reporting

According to media bias experts at AllSides

AllSides Certified Balanced May 2025

Transparent and credible

Awarded a perfect reliability rating from NewsGuard

100/100

Welcome back to trustworthy journalism.

Find out more

Bias comparison

  • Media outlets on the left emphasize "fragile ceasefire" tensions and the "agony" of previous similar incidents, while also noting Hamas's accusations of Israeli "violating" the deal.
  • Media outlets in the center neutrally attribute claims, using phrases like "Israel accuses" to present information without endorsing it.
  • Media outlets on the right frame the returned non-hostage body as a "serious breach" and "major violation" by a "terror group," often implying "intentional deception" with unconfirmed reports of an IDF uniform.

Media landscape

Click on bars to see headlines

236 total sources

Key points from the Left

  • The Israeli military announced that one body returned by Hamas does not belong to a hostage, intensifying tensions over a fragile ceasefire deal.
  • Hamas handed over four bodies on Tuesday, but Israel awaits the return of bodies for 28 deceased hostages as per the ceasefire agreement.
  • Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu demanded Hamas fulfill the ceasefire deal regarding the return of hostages' bodies, insisting efforts will continue until all are recovered.
  • Testing showed one body was misidentified as a Palestinian woman during a previous ceasefire, prompting further scrutiny.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Center

  • The IDF announced Wednesday that three of four bodies handed over by Hamas were identified as Israeli hostages, while forensic tests found the fourth is a Palestinian from Gaza.
  • Hamas handed over remains in phases, releasing four on Monday and four more late on Tuesday to ease pressure on the fragile ceasefire under the U.S.-proposed ceasefire deadline that expired Monday.
  • Forensic experts verified the identities of Tamir Nimrodi, 18, Uriel Baruch, 35, and Eitan Levy, 53, while vehicles transporting the remains arrived at the National Center for Forensic Medicine in Tel Aviv.
  • Families of the hostages expressed dismay that so few of the 28 deceased hostages have been returned, while Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu demanded Hamas fulfill ceasefire terms and Israel's defence minister Israel Katz warned forces would target anyone approaching deployment lines.
  • Hamas and the Red Cross said Gaza's destruction and Israeli control complicate recoveries, while Hamas says it is working to return bodies and 21 hostages remain held.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Right

  • One of the four bodies returned by Hamas was determined not to be a hostage, but likely a Palestinian, according to an Israeli security official and examinations at the National Institute of Forensic Medicine.
  • The three other bodies returned have been identified as soldiers Uriel Baruch, Tamir Nimrodi, and Eitan Levy.
  • Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu demanded that Hamas fulfill its obligation to return all deceased hostages' bodies as per the ceasefire deal.
  • Families of those identified expressed outrage over the return of a body that did not belong to any Israeli hostage, marking a violation of the ceasefire agreement.

Report an issue with this summary

Other (sources without bias rating):

Powered by Ground News™

Daily Newsletter

Start your day with fact-based news

Start your day with fact-based news

Learn more about our emails. Unsubscribe anytime.

By entering your email, you agree to the Terms and Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.