Clancy jury returns for sixth day as second deadlock raises possibility of mistrial


Full story

Jurors in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial will be back deliberating for a sixth day Thursday, with the possibility of a mistrial now looming.

The jury has spent about 30 hours over five days trying to reach a verdict, and jurors have told the judge twice now that they’re deadlocked.

QR code for SAN app download

Download the Straight Arrow app today to get the stories that matter free from manipulation, bias or agenda.™

Point phone camera here

The second time came Wednesday afternoon.

That led Judge William Sullivan to give the jury what’s known as the Tuey-Rodriguez charge, asking jurors to reconsider their positions and make another effort to reach a unanimous verdict.

They deliberated for another hour and a half before being sent home.

“At this point, what I’m going to do is, first off, thank you for your time and commitment to this case,” Sullivan said. “I’m going to ask you to come back tomorrow morning, 9 o’clock, to resume your deliberations.”

If jurors report another deadlock, Sullivan could declare a mistrial.

Judge William Sullivan listens to attorney Kevin Reddington question witness Dr. Kirk Heilbrun during Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial in Plymouth Superior Court, Plymouth, Mass., on Tuesday, Aug. 25, 2026. (Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger via AP, Pool)

What the jury is deliberating

The jury is deciding whether Clancy was criminally responsible when she killed her three young children in 2023.

Clancy doesn’t deny killing them.

Her attorneys say she was suffering from postpartum psychosis and was hearing a voice commanding her to kill her children and herself.

Prosecutors say she was not psychotic and planned the killings.

Jurors can convict Clancy of first-degree murder or lesser charges — second-degree murder or manslaughter — or find her not guilty due to lack of criminal responsibility.

Spectator charged with intimidating the jury

Another development occurred outside the courthouse, where supporters and protesters have gathered throughout the trial.

Dawn Light, 56, was arraigned Wednesday, accused of intimidating jurors after police found photos and videos on her phone that included jurors leaving court.

Dawn Light, charged with witness intimidation, leaves the courthouse after being arraigned during the Lindsay Clancy trial at Plymouth Superior Court in Plymouth, Massachusetts on September 2, 2026. (Photo by JOSEPH PREZIOSO / AFP via Getty Images)

Light pleaded not guilty. Her attorney says she wasn’t trying to film the jury — she was there to see Clancy.

When reporters asked why she was filming, Light said she was there to see Clancy.

“To see Lindsay. To see Lindsay, and I did see her,” Light told reporters. “She was getting picked up by the van; we were parked here. That’s it.”

Round out your reading

Tags: , , , ,

Straight Arrow
Fear No Fact.

Don't just take our word for it.


Center-rated reporting

According to media bias experts at AllSides

AllSides Center-rated reporting May 2026

Transparent and credible

Awarded a perfect reliability rating from NewsGuard

100/100

Welcome back to trustworthy journalism.

Find out more

Why this story matters

A high-profile murder trial involving a postpartum psychosis defense has reached a near-deadlock, raising the prospect of a mistrial and illustrating how jury deliberations in complex criminal cases can stall even after extended effort.

Mistrial remains possible

After two reported deadlocks and roughly 30 hours of deliberation, the judge may declare a mistrial if jurors report another impasse Thursday morning.

Jury intimidation charge filed

A spectator was arraigned on charges of intimidating jurors after police found photos and videos on her phone that included jurors leaving court, according to the article.

Straight Arrow
Fear No Fact.

Don't just take our word for it.


Center-rated reporting

According to media bias experts at AllSides

AllSides Center-rated reporting May 2026

Transparent and credible

Awarded a perfect reliability rating from NewsGuard

100/100

Welcome back to trustworthy journalism.

Find out more

Sources

  1. NBC News

Bias comparison

  • Media outlets on the left frame the deadlock through postpartum psychosis, maternal mental health, and the contested question of criminal responsibility, using terms such as “triple murder” and “triple infanticide” while stressing possible mistrial and retrial.
  • Media outlets in the center de-emphasize partisan framing in favor of legal procedure.
  • Media outlets on the right foreground Clancy’s admission, the children’s deaths, and second-trial anguish, employing charged phrases like “killed,” “Here we go again!” and “hung,” while portraying the judge’s “dynamite charge” as pressure on jurors.

Media landscape

Click on bars to see headlines

164 total sources

Key points from the Left

  • The jury in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial told the judge twice that it cannot reach a verdict after five days of deliberations.
  • The judge instructed the jury again to continue discussing the verdict as required by law.
  • Lindsay Clancy admits to strangling her three children in 2023, but her attorney claims postpartum psychosis caused her actions, while prosecutors argue she was aware of what she was doing.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Center

  • On Tuesday, jurors in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial told Judge William Sullivan they could not reach a unanimous verdict, marking their second deadlock as deliberations resumed Wednesday for a fifth day.
  • Lindsay Clancy, a former labor and delivery nurse, pleaded not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility for strangling her three children, while prosecutors argue she knew what she was doing.
  • Medical experts provided conflicting testimony regarding her psychiatric state at the time of the killings, while jurors reviewed evidence concerning her mental health decline and psychiatric hospitalization.
  • Unanimous verdicts are required by law, so Judge Sullivan instructed the jury to continue deliberating; if they remain deadlocked, he could declare a mistrial and prosecutors would face decisions on retrial or plea negotiations.
  • After court ended Tuesday, attorney Kevin Reddington expressed optimism about the jury's continued work, saying the fact they have not finished is "very, very heartening" and "Obviously, they're working very hard.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Right

  • The jury in Lindsay Clancy's trial has reported being deadlocked twice after five days of deliberations and was sent back with a legal instruction to encourage consensus.
  • Clancy admitted to strangling her three children, while her defense argues she suffered from severe postpartum psychosis during the killings.
  • Prosecutors claim Clancy planned the murders to end her life and disputes the mental illness defense, whereas the defense attributes the tragedy to inadequate mental healthcare.
  • The judge may declare a mistrial if the jury remains deadlocked, and Clancy's lawyer has stated she could not emotionally endure a retrial.

Report an issue with this summary

Other (sources without bias rating):

Powered by Ground News™

Sources

  1. NBC News