Comey says it’s ‘crazy to think’ controversial Trump post ‘was a threat’


This recording was made using enhanced software.

Summary

First interview

In his first television interview since posting an Instagram picture some within the Trump administration believed promoted violence against the president, former FBI Director James Comey told MSNBC’s Nicole Wallace it was a “totally innocent” post.

Critics

Some within the Trump administration and Trump allies in Congress called for Comey to be arrested following the Instagram post showing seashells in a formation appearing to reveal the numbers “8647.”

Interpretation

Some within Trump’s cabinet viewed the number “86,” which is defined in the dictionary as “to get rid” of something, as calling for the assassination of Trump, who is also the 47th president.


Full story

Ex-FBI Director James Comey spoke out for the first time on television since being accused of leveling a threat against President Donald Trump through an Instagram post during the week of May 11. Comey shared a picture of seashells that appeared to display the numbers “8647.” Some within Trump’s inner-circle accused Comey of calling for the killing of the president by displaying the number “86,” which the Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines as “to get rid” of something and the number “47,” referencing Trump as the 47th president of the United States.

What did Comey say?

During an interview with MSNBC’s Nicole Wallace on Monday, May 19, Comey said his post was not a threat against the president, rather something he and his wife found “clever” and that they found the use of “86” referred to a common restaurant term used to inform staff when a food item is no longer available or to “leave a place.”

“We stood over it and I said, ‘I think it’s some kind of political message,’ and she said ‘86, when I was a server’ — she did a lot of work in restaurants — ‘meant to remove an item from the menu when you ran out of ingredients,’” Comey told Wallace.

“And I said, ‘Well, to me, as a kid, it always meant to leave a place, to ditch a place.’” Comey added, “I said, ‘That’s really clever.’ So then she said, ‘You should take a picture of that.’ And I did, and posted it to my Instagram account and thought nothing more of it.”

What was Comey’s initial response to the negative reaction?

Comey said he was surprised when he saw the reaction to his post. “I heard through her people that people were saying it was some sort of a call for assassination, which is crazy,” he said. “But I took it down. Even if I think it’s crazy, I don’t want to be associated with violence of any kind.”

Comey said his social media post was “totally innocent,” but regretted “the distraction and controversy around it.”

Comey met with the Secret Service

The ex-FBI director went on to explain how he believes he’s become a target of the Trump administration through audits and acknowledged he talked with the Secret Service about the post.

“I got a call from the Secret Service that night asking if I would speak to them about it,” Comey said. “Of course, I admire the Secret Service. They’re pros. I spoke with them on the phone. Then they asked the next day, when I got home, would I be willing to come in and meet them in person at the Washington field office, which again, I did, and they were pros again.”

As Straight Arrow News recently reported, following Comey’s post on Friday, May 16, some within the Trump administration accused Comey of promoting violence against the president. Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard also said that Comey “should be in jail” over the picture. Some Republicans also called for Comey to be arrested and his house raided over the post.

Comey responded to his critics’ comments, particularly Gabbard, after Wallace played a clip of the director’s call for the ex-head of the FBI’s arrest. 

“I hope people know enough about that particular person that they understand where it’s coming from,” said Comey. “It says something more depressing about the leadership of our current administration. And I just shrug because that’s ridiculous.”

Comey’s tense relationship with President Trump

Comey was fired by Trump back in 2017, after his first administration determined he failed to thoroughly investigate former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s use of a private email server for classified information, though Trump later said it was also tied to the Russia probe.

Comey has since become a critic of President Trump and released a book shortly after his termination, criticizing Trump’s leadership during his first term in office. Comey also endorsed Trump’s opponent in the 2024 presidential election, former Vice President Kamala Harris.

Jason Morrell (Morning Managing Editor), Mathew Grisham (Digital Producer), and Emma Stoltzfus (Video Editor) contributed to this report.
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Why this story matters

The controversy surrounding James Comey's social media post and its interpretation illustrates broader tensions over the responsibilities of public figures in sensitive political climates.

Public figure responsibility

The expectation that former officials like Comey act with heightened caution in their public statements underscores the scrutiny and consequences faced by those with past or present government roles.

Get the big picture

Synthesized coverage insights across 50 media outlets

Quote bank

Key quotes include Comey stating, “It’s been a bit of a distraction, honestly.” Donald Trump is quoted as saying, “A child knows what that meant… that meant assassination.” Comey also told MSNBC, “I don’t want to be associated with violence of any kind.”

Bias comparison

  • Media outlets on the left framed the Instagram post controversy chiefly as an overblown political attack, emphasizing Comey’s portrayal of the photo as an “innocent Instagram shot” and his description of the uproar as “a bit of a distraction," thereby highlighting his frustration and downplaying violent intent.
  • Media outlets in the center grounded the story with deeper linguistic context by detailing the slang meanings of “86” and providing fuller quotes from Trump, enabling a more nuanced understanding of the accusations.
  • Media outlets on the right adopted a mocking and skeptical tone — branding Comey with derisive nicknames like “Seashell of a Man” and placing “distraction” in scare quotes — to question his credibility and underscore alleged veiled threats toward Trump, reflecting a narrative of distrust.

Media landscape

Click on bars to see headlines

73 total sources

Key points from the Left

  • James Comey described the incident as a "distraction" and emphasized his wish to avoid any association with violence, stating he took the post down afterward.
  • Comey confirmed he spoke with the Secret Service after the image caught the attention of Donald Trump and other officials.
  • Donald Trump stated in an interview that Comey "knew exactly what that meant" and implied it indicated assassination, as reported on Fox News.
  • Comey found shells arranged in the sand that some interpreted as numbers "86 and 47," causing a backlash, as he explained in a statement.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Center

  • Former FBI director James Comey explained on Monday how a shell photo he posted last week led to Secret Service scrutiny in Washington.
  • The photo, taken after a beach walk with his wife Patrice, showed shells arranged to resemble numbers including "86" and possibly "47," which sparked allegations.
  • Trump and others interpreted the image as a call for the president's assassination, prompting the Secret Service to call and later interview Comey in person.
  • Comey said, "It's been a bit of a distraction, honestly," and confirmed he removed the image to avoid any association with violence.

Report an issue with this summary

Powered by Ground News™