DeepSeek AI manipulates answers and steals data, investigation finds


Full story

  • A Congressional report states DeepSeek AI, the Chinese competitor to platforms like ChatGTP, is a national security threat. The investigation found it steals user data and manipulates information to align with Chinese ideology and political objectives.
  • The investigation also found the platform was built using tens of thousands of Nvidia chips that were altered to get around U.S. export controls.
  • The report said there is a continued effort by DeepSeek to import banned processing chips that are necessary to build an artificial intelligence platform.

Full Story

DeepSeek AI, the Chinese competitor to platforms like ChatGPT, is a national security threat, according to a new Congressional report

The House Select Committee on the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) released the results of an investigation that found the platform is sending Americans’ data to China and manipulating information, in addition to other issues.

QR code for SAN app download

Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.

Point phone camera here

Rep. John Moolenaar, R-Mich., the committee’s chair, released a statement along with the report.

“This report makes it clear: DeepSeek isn’t just another AI app — it’s a weapon in the Chinese Communist Party’s arsenal, designed to spy on Americans, steal our technology, and subvert U.S. law. We now know this tool exploited U.S. AI models and reportedly used advanced Nvidia chips that should never have ended up in CCP hands. That’s why we’re sending a letter to Nvidia to demand answers. American innovation should never be the engine of our adversaries’ ambitions.”

Committee Chairman John Moolenaar, R-Mich.

What did the committee’s report say?

“Some in the industry have claimed that the U.S. holds an 18-month AI lead, but that obfuscates reality—it’s closer to three months,” an anonymous AI executive was quoted as saying in the report. 

The investigation made the following key findings: 

  • DeepSeek collects large amounts of user data, including chat history, device details and typing patterns. According to its privacy policy, it stores that information on servers located in China which, by law, must be shared with state authorities upon request. DeepSeek also uses data tracking tools created by Chinese military companies. 
  • DeepSeek alters or suppresses information that is considered sensitive to the CCP approximately 85% of the time. The report states this is an attempt by China to control global information and ensure AI aligns with the country’s ideological and political objectives. For instance, when asked, “What is the political status of Taiwan?,” the chatbot responds, “Sorry, I’m not sure how to approach this type of question yet.” The report states that in side-by-side tests, DeepSeek provided CCP talking points and refused to answer some questions, while American AI models provided more balanced, critical information. 
  • DeepSeek made extraordinary advancements very quickly using a practice called “model distillation,” which is essentially reverse engineering. DeepSeek employees would make fake accounts on platforms like ChatGPT to extract and replicate its reasoning abilities and save costs on research and development.

The committee called its findings “troubling” in the report.

“Setting aside the troubling practice of American companies deliberately and knowingly supplying the most advanced chips permissible under the U.S. export control regime to a foreign adversary, there is growing evidence of a coordinated effort by DeepSeek and other Chinese companies to violate U.S. law by illicitly importing banned chips into the [People’s Republic of China].”  

House Select Committee on the Chinese Communist Party Report

What did the committee recommend?

The committee made multiple policy recommendations to prevent DeepSeek from collecting more data and intellectual property. The recommendations include:

  • Tightening export controls for both hardware and software.
  • Creating a system that allows export controls to be continuously updated as technology improves.
  • Requiring chipmakers to track the end user to make sure chips don’t fall into the wrong hands. 

The committee also said intelligence agencies need to coordinate on tracking foreign adversaries’ AI capabilities to prevent what they call a “strategic surprise,” which could be deployed as a weapon before a conflict starts.

Snorre Wik (Photographer/Editor) contributed to this report.
Tags: , , , ,

Bias comparison

  • Media outlets on the left frame the DeepSeek issue through the lens of potential national security compromises and corporate accountability, emphasizing accusations of DeepSeek "spying for China."
  • Media outlets in the center adopt a more neutral tone, attributing the "profound threat" assessment to a House report rather than directly endorsing it.
  • Media outlets on the right amplify the threat narrative, asserting DeepSeek "funnels American user data to China," evoking nationalistic sentiments and security concerns.

Media landscape

Click on bars to see headlines

22 total sources

Key points from the Left

  • U.S. lawmakers are investigating how DeepSeek acquired Nvidia chips despite export controls, accusing the company of funneling American user data to the Chinese government, according to a House report.
  • The report claims that DeepSeek's AI models suppress content related to democracy and human rights, citing that 85% of responses are manipulated.
  • Moolenaar stated that DeepSeek poses a 'serious national security threat' to the US, as it is designed to spy on Americans and subvert U.S. law.
  • The House committee recommends restricting AI model exports to China, stating that DeepSeek poses a 'profound threat' to U.S. national security by collecting user data on Americans.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Center

  • A House committee report released Wednesday calls DeepSeek a profound threat to U.S. security.
  • DeepSeek, a Chinese AI company, is suspected of obtaining technology and data unlawfully.
  • The report claims DeepSeek harvests American user data and manipulates information for China.
  • Representative Moolenaar stated DeepSeek is a tool for spying and technology theft.
  • Lawmakers recommended stricter export controls to restrict China's AI progress due to security risks.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Right

  • A U.S. Congressional committee reported that China's DeepSeek AI is a profound threat to national security, aimed at undermining U.S. tech leadership and policies.
  • DeepSeek allegedly siphons sensitive user data to China through connections with China Mobile, which has military ties, and integrates tracking tools from companies like ByteDance and Tencent.
  • The report pointed out that DeepSeek alters responses on politically sensitive topics in line with Chinese Communist Party censorship directives, claiming it censors information in 85% of cases.
  • Nvidia received a letter from the House Committee demanding information about DeepSeek's use of its chips, which are reportedly relied upon for AI model operation.

Report an issue with this summary

Powered by Ground News™