Heads up: Canada’s top court approves killing of hundreds of infected ostriches


This recording was made using enhanced software.

Summary

Appeal denied

Canada’s top court has denied an appeal to stop the government-mandated culling of hundreds of ostriches.

Bird flu concerns

Canada’s Food Inspection Agency argues the killings are necessary due to the risk of bird flu.

Criticism

Critics argue the birds should be spared and instead used for studies.


Full story

Canada’s Supreme Court denied an appeal to stop the killing of hundreds of ostriches at a farm in British Columbia, leaving farmers with little hope to prevent it. The Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) ordered the mass culling in late 2024 after two birds contracted avian flu, following an outbreak that caused the deaths of dozens of animals.

The top court’s refusal to hear an appeal deals a blow to Universal Ostrich Farms, which has sought to halt the culling since the CFIA order. 

QR code for SAN app download

Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.

Point phone camera here

The decision legally authorizes the government-ordered culling to go forth. But it’s unclear whether farmers opposed to the move will attempt other avenues to save the birds, including requesting the federal government rescind its order.

An unclear timeline 

Following the Supreme Court ruling Thursday, the CFIA announced it will be “moving forward” with the culling with the aim of preventing the spread of avian flu. 

However, the agency did not reveal an exact timeline for when the birds would be killed. It said it “expects the ostrich farm owners and supporters” to comply with the high court decision.

‘Shame on you’

Katie Pasitney, whose family owns the farm fighting the order, posted a video to Facebook, in which she tearfully declared, “Shame on you, Canada.”

“Please pray for a miracle in the next hour for our family, for these animals outside,” she added.

Some farmers argue that the ostriches should be allowed to live and used for research, since they survived an outbreak within the flock that killed 69 birds. 

As of Thursday, the ostriches remained on the farm, where they have been under CFIA supervision since September, according to the BBC. More than 60 activists reportedly protested at the farm Thursday as the Supreme Court announced its refusal to hear an appeal.

Canada’s food inspection agency says it’s about safety

The CFIA contends that it is necessary to kill the birds because their exposure to the flu presents a risk to humans, livestock and wildlife. 

Officials dispute claims that the remaining birds in the flock have developed immunity to the virus.

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said avian flu rarely spreads to humans. However, it  is monitoring people exposed to infected birds.

Significant international attention to case

The case has captured attention from around the globe, including the Trump administration, which accuses Canadian officials of government overreach.

Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. met with the CFIA’s top brass earlier this year to advocate for using the birds for research instead of killing them.

The administrator for the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Dr. Mehmet Oz, even offered up his Florida ranch as a new home for the birds to prevent their deaths. 

New York billionaire John Catsmaditis has also reportedly disclosed that he is helping finance the farm’s legal fight against the culling order. 

Alan Judd (Content Editor) and Julia Marshall (Morning Digital Producer) contributed to this report.
Tags: , ,

SAN provides
Unbiased. Straight Facts.

Don’t just take our word for it.


Certified balanced reporting

According to media bias experts at AllSides

AllSides Certified Balanced May 2025

Transparent and credible

Awarded a perfect reliability rating from NewsGuard

100/100

Welcome back to trustworthy journalism.

Find out more

Why this story matters

Canada's Supreme Court rejection of an appeal against a government-ordered ostrich cull in British Columbia highlights tensions between animal disease containment policy, agricultural livelihoods and growing public debate around the role of science and government intervention.

Animal disease control

The Canadian Food Inspection Agency's decision to proceed with culling is intended to contain avian influenza and protect public health and the poultry industry, drawing attention to global challenges in managing animal disease outbreaks.

Legal and government authority

The Supreme Court's refusal to hear the appeal underscores the government's legal power in enforcing public health measures, raising questions about the limits of government intervention on private property.

Public and international response

The case attracted international attention and public protests, with figures such as U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. urging alternative solutions and activists questioning the scientific and ethical basis for the cull.

Get the big picture

Synthesized coverage insights across 79 media outlets

Behind the numbers

The articles state approximately 300 to 330 ostriches were to be culled following an avian influenza outbreak. The Canadian Food Inspection Agency references Canada's poultry industry value at $6.8 to $7 billion, and 11,439,000 birds affected in British Columbia as of late October.

History lesson

Mandatory animal culls have historically been used to limit livestock disease outbreaks, as seen with avian flu and foot-and-mouth disease, to protect local food supplies and international trade agreements.

Underreported

The scientific validity and potential value of the ostriches' antibodies, as claimed by the farm owners, remain largely unexamined in detail across reports, as does the process for conducting further independent veterinary testing.

SAN provides
Unbiased. Straight Facts.

Don’t just take our word for it.


Certified balanced reporting

According to media bias experts at AllSides

AllSides Certified Balanced May 2025

Transparent and credible

Awarded a perfect reliability rating from NewsGuard

100/100

Welcome back to trustworthy journalism.

Find out more

Bias comparison

  • Media outlets on the left frame the ostrich cull as a tragic event, using terms like "killed" and "face cull," emphasizing emotional impact with "tears on ostrich farm" and dramatic imagery like "gunshots herald" the operation.
  • Media outlets in the center maintain a neutral, factual tone, detailing the "hundreds" of ostriches and police involvement.
  • Media outlets on the right de-emphasize emotional details, focusing on the procedural "total depopulation" and the court's refusal to hear the appeal, though some label the situation "controversial.

Media landscape

Click on bars to see headlines

79 total sources

Key points from the Left

  • Canada's Supreme Court declined to hear a case about a federal agency's order to cull hundreds of ostriches after a bird flu outbreak.
  • Farm owners in Edgewood argue their ostriches are healthy and should not be culled, citing no signs of illness.
  • US Health Secretary Robert Kennedy Jr. Wrote to the Canadian Food Inspection Agency, urging the reconsideration of the culling order.
  • Dr. Mehmet Oz offered his Florida ranch as a relocation site for the ostriches.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Center

  • On Thursday, the Supreme Court of Canada declined to hear Universal Ostrich Farms' appeal, removing a legal obstacle to culling around 330 ostriches in Edgewood, British Columbia, amid international attention.
  • The Canadian Food Inspection Agency detected highly pathogenic avian influenza and issued a cull mandate last year, proceeding under its stamping out policy after taking government custody of the animals.
  • Universal Ostrich Farms says it is raising birds to study antibody production, a claim the CFIA labelled "unsubstantiated"; US health figure Robert F. Kennedy Jr. And supermarket magnate John Catsimatidis intervened, with Kennedy urging reconsideration and Catsimatidis funding legal aid.
  • Protests erupted at the farm as around 100 supporters gathered and the CFIA warned against hindering operations or flying drones over the site, expecting compliance while it retains custody of the birds, which owners dispute.
  • Experts say culling infected or exposed flocks is standard practice to stop spread, with the CFIA aiming to protect Canada's nearly $7 billion poultry industry amid B.C.'s 11,439,000 birds affected as of October 28.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Right

  • The owners of a farm in western Canada lost a legal battle to save their ostriches after the Supreme Court refused to hear their case.
  • The Canadian Food Inspection Agency will begin "depopulation and disposal measures" to address avian influenza risks.
  • Katie Pastiney, daughter of the farm owners, expressed her emotional plea on Facebook, claiming the ostriches are healthy.
  • John Catsimatidis, a billionaire, suggested the birds could be transferred to the U.S. For testing by the FDA.

Report an issue with this summary

Other (sources without bias rating):

Powered by Ground News™

Daily Newsletter

Start your day with fact-based news

Start your day with fact-based news

Learn more about our emails. Unsubscribe anytime.

By entering your email, you agree to the Terms and Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.