[UNKNOWN SPEAKERS]
“President trump has just announced on social media that the U.S. has just completed three successful attacks on three nuclear sites in iran.”
“news from the president of the united states that there has been an attack inside iran.”
[KARAH RUCKER]
IT’S BEEN A WEEK SINCE THE U.S. BOMBED IRAN’S NUCLEAR FACILITIES.
AND FROM DAY ONE –
MEDIA COVERAGE SET THE TONE –
FROM LEFT NETWORKS – A SOBERING ONE.
[UNKNOWN SPEAKER]
“Since 1979 the u.s. Military has not engaged directly with iran. But donald trump has done so tonight. Donald trump has ordered u.s. Military bombing raids on iran. We are now in war with iran.”
“Delivering the most sober possible message to the american people. Who have been largely opposed to and afraid of a potential u.s. War with iran for generations. Donald trump has now started it.”
[KARAH RUCKER]
AND NETWORKS ON THE RIGHT – A TONE OF TRIUMPH.
[UNKNOWN SPEAKER]
“no president has been able to deal a blow like this to the number one state sponsor of terror.”
“the trump doctrine is very unique…he has proven you can successfully take out threats in the world without getting involved in forever wars.”
[KARAH RUCKER]
IT’S THE BIGGEST NEWS STORY SINCE TRUMP’S ELECTION.
THIS IS WHEN THE MEDIA SHOULD BE PROVIDING A VALUABLE SERVICE.
A MAJOR WORLD EVENT HAPPENS AND THE PUBLIC’S LOOKING FOR STRAIGHTFORWARD ANSWERS.
BUT AS YOU’RE ABOUT TO SEE –
PARTISAN OUTLETS GAVE TWO DIFFERENT VERSIONS OF EVENTS – TO FIT A POLITICAL NARRATIVE.
WELCOME TO BIAS BREAKDOWN.
FOLLOWING THE STRIKE ON IRAN’S NUCLEAR SITES –
NEWS OUTLETS ON THE LEFT SAID–
THE U.S. WAS “ENTERING WAR” WITH IRAN.
UNDER THIS LENS –
MUCH OF THE NOISE FROM LEFT-LEANING OUTLETS FOCUSED ON THE LEGALITY OF TRUMP’S STRIKES.
WAS HE ALLOWED TO MAKE SUCH A DECISION WITHOUT CONGRESSIONAL APPROVAL?
AND IF NOT, IS IT AN IMPEACHABLE OFFENSE?
[UNKNOWN SPEAKER]
“congress didn’t authorize this. No president on their own has the ability on their own to start a war. Sending american aircraft over another country dropping bombs, that’s risking starting a war.”
[KARAH RUCKER]
RIGHT-LEANING MEDIA – AVOIDED CLAIMS THAT THE U.S. WAS GETTING INTO A WAR
INSTEAD – MUCH OF THE COVERAGE INSTEAD HIGHLIGHTED THE SUCCESS OF THE MISSION.
[UNKNOWN SPEAKER]
“These strikes against the nuclear facilities were absolutely successful it was an amazing operation.”
[KARAH RUCKER]
LET’S TALK ABOUT **WHY THIS STORY TOOK TWO DIFFERENT DIRECTIONS.
THE BIGGEST DIVIDING LINE IN EARLY COVERAGE COMES DOWN TO HOW TRUMP’S STRIKES WERE INTERPRETED.
WAS BOMBING IRAN’S NUCLEAR SITES A DECLARATION OF WAR?
SOME SAY THE PRESIDENT OVERSTEPPED BY ACTING WITHOUT CONGRESSIONAL APPROVAL – OTHERS SAY HE EXERCISED **LAWFUL AUTHORITY AS PRESIDENTS HAVE DONE IN THE PAST.
BUT THE MEDIA INSERTED ITSELF INTO THAT DEBATE – AND CHOSE SIDES.
[UNKNOWN SPEAKER]
“I remained absolutely convinced that this was unjustified. There was more time for diplomacy.”
“We had something truly bad ass happen, and the media, in its desperation to make trump look bad, figured out a way to just poo poo the whole thing to the masses.”
[KARAH RUCKER]
THE LEFT ALSO QUESTIONED THE **EFFECTIVENESS OF THE STRIKES.
[UNKNOWN SPEAKER]
“Trump claimed they were totally completely obliterated. But tonight’s sources say iran’s nuclear program was only set back a few months.”
“this weekend’s strikes on three nuclear facilities set iran’s program back by months and did not obliterate the faiclities as trump claimed.”
[KARAH RUCKER]
BUT RIGHT-LEANING MEDIA PUSHED BACK — DEFENDING THE ADMINISTRATION AGAINST CLAIMS THAT THE STRIKE WASN’T AS EFFECTIVE AS THE PRESIDENT SAID.
[VARIOUS SPEAKERS]
“this unprecedented strike was made against iran knocking out iran’s nuclear sites likely setting back the program for years, decades, or perhaps ever.”
“the decision by trump and what israel did prior to our military going in there, it looks like we’ve set iran back big time.”
[KARAH RUCKER]
YOU SAW THE SAME SENTIMENT IN NEWS HEADLINES –
THE LEFT PROMOTING INTEL REPORTS DOUBTING THE STRIKES’ EFFECTIVENESS – HIGHLIGHTING IRAN WAS ONLY SET BACK **MONTHS.
THE RIGHT POINTING TO INTEL THAT IRAN’S NUKE PROGRAM WAS SET BACK YEARS.
IT’S OUR JOB AS JOURNALISTS TO BRING PEOPLE CLARITY –
BUT WHAT HAPPENED?
FROM THE HEADLINES GRAPHIC WE JUST SHARED ON YOUR SCREEN –
IT DOESN’T GET MORE CONTRASTING AND CONFUSING THAN THAT.
BUT REVISITING A COMMON CONVERSATION WE HAVE HERE ON THIS PODCAST –
CHERRYPICKING DATA, POLLS, STUDIES, AND EXPERTS –
IS A TOOL FOR PUSHING AGENDAS.
IF I WANT TO PERSUADE YOU ON SOMETHING – I CAN SAY “HERE – I’VE GOT THIS EXPERT, THIS POLL, OR ***THIS **INTEL REPORT TO PROVE IT.
AND MAYBE THAT INFORMATION IS FACTUALLY TRUE —
BUT IF I’M ONLY GIVING YOU PART OF THE STORY THAT SUPPORTS MY POINT OF VIEW,
THAT’S DISHONEST.
AND THAT’S NOT WHAT WE DO HERE.
SO LET’S TALK ABOUT SOME OF THE INTELLIGENCE REPORTS OUT THERE AND WHAT WE KNOW **SO FAR.
A LEAKED PRELIMINARY DEFENSE INTELLIGENCE AGENCY ASSESSMENT SUGGESTS THE STRIKES MAY HAVE ONLY DELAYED IRAN’S NUCLEAR PROGRAM BY A FEW MONTHS — WITH DAMAGE MOSTLY LIMITED TO ABOVE GROUND INFRASTRUCTURE.
BUT A CIA REPORT CLAIMS THE STRIKES CAUSED SEVERE LONG-TERM DAMAGE.
ISRAELI INTELLIGENCE ALSO POINTS TO “SIGNIFICANT DAMAGE,” POTENTIALLY SETTING IRAN BACK BY YEARS.
THE INTERNATIONAL ATOMIC ENERGY AGENCY SAYS THE STRIKES DEALT “SEVERE, BUT NOT TOTAL” DAMAGE.
AND EVEN IRAN’S OWN FOREIGN MINISTER ADMITTED TO “EXCESSIVE AND SERIOUS DAMAGE” —
A STARK CONTRAST TO THE SUPREME LEADER’S CLAIM THAT THE STRIKES ACHIEVED NOTHING.
A WASHINGTON POST REPORT OVER THE WEEKEND REVEALED A CALL BY IRANIAN OFFICIALS SAYING THE STRIKE WAS LESS DAMAGING THAN THEY HAD EXPECTED.
THERE’S SEVERAL SOURCES AND ASSESSMENTS WITH SEVERAL DIFFERENT CONCLUSIONS.
WHAT THESE HAVE IN COMMON –
IS THEY ARE PRELIMINARY.
IT’S SOMETHING OUR REPORTER RYAN ROBERTSON PUT THIS WAY –
IT’S SIMPLY GOING TO TAKE TIME TO LEARN MORE ABOUT THE DAMAGE DONE.
[RYAN ROBERTSON]
“The DIA report says based on current findings…it’s going to take time to find out if the plan worked.”
[KARAH RUCKER]
THINGS ARE STILL A BIT BLURRY BEING ONLY A WEEK SINCE THE STRIKES.
DEFENSE SECRETARY PETE HEGESETH SAID IT’LL TAKE A LOT OF LITERAL DIGGING TO DISCOVER THE EXTENT OF THE DAMAGE..
[U.S. SEC. OF DEFENSE PETE HEGSETH]
“All of the evidence of what was just bombed by 12 30,000 pound bombs is buried under a mountain devastated and obliterated. So if you want to make an assessment of what happened at fordow, you better get a big shovel and go really deep.”
[KARAH RUCKER]
REPORTING PUBLIC REACTION TO THE AIRSTRIKES CAN ALSO CREATE CONTRADICTION AND CONFUSION.—
IT’S EASY FOR MEDIA — ON THE RIGHT AND THE LEFT — TO MANIPULATE POLLING AND PUBLIC SENTIMENT TO FIT A NARRATIVE.
A CNN POLL OUT LAST WEEK – SHOWED THE MAJORITY OF AMERICANS – 56 PERCENT – **DISAPPROVED OF THE STRIKES IN IRAN.
BUT AN AXIOS POLL FOUND A MAJORITY OF AMERICANS – 55 PERCENT – **SUPPORTED THE RECENT U.S. AIRSTRIKES.
THE MEDIA HAS MASSIVE POWER TO SHAPE OPINION.
ESPECIALLY IN MOMENTS WHERE PUBLIC INTEREST PEAKS.
THE DAY OF THE AIRSTRIKES – NETWORKS TURNED A SLOW NEWS SATURDAY INTO A RECORD-BREAKING VIEWERSHIP DAY.
FOX NEWS SAW ITS THIRD HIGHEST-RATED SATURDAY IN THE NETWORK’S HISTORY.
AND MILLIONS TUNED IN TO CNN AND MSNBC ON DAYS THAT TYPICALLY SEE NUMBERS NO WHERE CLOSE TO THAT.
PEOPLE WERE PLUGGED IN.
AMERICA WAS PLUGGED IN.
BUT DEPENDING ON WHERE YOU GOT YOUR NEWS, YOU MAY WELL HAVE BEEN INFLICTED WITH A PREFERRED NARRATIVE –
PUTTING TRUMP’S STRIKES IN A POSITIVE OR NEGATIVE LIGHT.
AND THAT’S YOUR BIAS BREAKDOWN.
THANKS FOR WATCHING THIS WEEK’S EPISODE!
REMEMBER YOU CAN FIND OTHER EPISODES EASILY AND READILY AVAILABLE ON THE SAN MOBILE APP OR OUR WEBSITE.
ANOTHER EPISODE WORTH CHECKING OUT —
IT’S FROM A FEW WEEKS BACK, DURING THE EARLY NEGOTIATIONS OVER PRESIDENT TRUMP’S “BIG BEAUTIFUL BILL.”
REPUBLICANS ARE NOW PUSHING TO GET THAT PACKAGE TO HIS DESK BY WEEK’S END.
THE EPISODE BREAKS DOWN HOW THE MEDIA COVERED PROPOSED MEDICAID CUTS —
AND HOW LEFT- AND RIGHT-LEANING OUTLETS FRAMED IT AS EITHER TARGETING BENEFITS OR WASTE.
YOU CAN FIND ALL OF OUR EPISODES ON SPOTIFY, YOUTUBE, OR WHEREVER YOU LISTEN TO PODCASTS.
BIG THANK YOU TO IAN KENNEDY ON OUR EDITS AND ALI CALDWELL ON OUR GRAPHICS.
AND THANK YOU FOR WATCHING.
I HOPE YOU HAVE A WONDERFUL JULY FOURTH WEEKEND –
HAPPY INDEPENDENCE DAY – AND I’LL SEE YA NEXT TIME!