IDF will block Thunberg’s Gaza aid ship using ‘any means necessary’: Katz


This recording was made using enhanced software.

Summary

'Any means necessary'

A humanitarian aid ship being piloted by the Freedom Flotilla Coalition, a group of 12 pro-Palestinian activists, was due to arrive on Gaza’s shores Sunday. However, Israel’s defense minister has said the IDF will “take any means necessary” to ensure that it doesn’t.

High-profile activists

Among the group are high-profile names including climate activist Greta Thunberg, “Game of Thrones” actor Liam Cunningham, and French-Palestinian European Parliament member Rima Hassan.

Second attempt

This is the coalition’s second attempt at sailing an aid ship into Gaza; its first attempt in May ended after two drones reportedly crashed into their ship, damaging the front.


Full story

One week into its voyage, and on the day that it was meant to reach Gaza’s shores, an aid ship piloted by 12 activists, including climate campaigner Greta Thunberg, has been warned not to go any further. In a post on X Sunday, June 8, Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz wrote that he has “instructed the (Israel Defense Forces) to act so that the ‘Madleen’ hate flotilla does not reach the shores of Gaza – and to take any means necessary to that end.”

Raising international awareness

The Madleen, which departed from Sicily Sunday, June 1, is being operated by the Freedom Flotilla Coalition. Among its passengers are Thunberg, “Game of Thrones” actor Liam Cunningham, and Rima Hassan, a French-Palestinian member of the European Parliament who has been barred from entering Israel due to her pro-Palestinian messaging.

The crew said their goal is to raise “international awareness” over the ongoing hunger and humanitarian crisis in Gaza. At a press conference before they departed last week, Thunberg said, “We are doing this because, no matter what odds we are against, we have to keep trying.”

She added, “Because the moment we stop trying is when we lose our humanity. And no matter how dangerous this mission is, it’s not even near as dangerous as the silence of the entire world in the face of the live-streamed genocide.”

Israel vows to stop the ship

However, Katz has vowed not to let that happen. “Israel will act against any attempt to break the blockade or aid terrorist organizations – at sea, in the air and on land,” the IDF head said via X on Sunday.

Katz has claimed that the IDF is blocking the flotilla so that weapons don’t reach Hamas militants, saying, “The State of Israel will not allow anyone to break the naval blockade on Gaza, whose primary purpose is to prevent the transfer of weapons to Hamas.”

However, the coalition has stated that its cargo is “symbolic,” consisting of items such as baby formula and rice, Reuters reports. As of Sunday, the ship was still roughly 160 nautical miles off the coast of Gaza.

This is the Freedom Flotilla Coalition’s second attempt to break Israel’s naval blockade and bring humanitarian assistance into Gaza. In May, the activist group said its vessel was struck by a pair of drones while sailing near Malta. The group blamed Israel for the attack, which did not officially respond to the accusations.

Israel’s blockade plunges Gaza into famine-like conditions

After breaking a ceasefire agreement in March, Israel imposed a total blockade of all humanitarian assistance entering Gaza, effectively plunging much of the territory’s population into famine-like conditions. The region has been under a partial blockade since 2007, when Hamas assumed control of military operations in Gaza.

Israel ostensibly lifted its total blockade in May, though the flow of food and other necessities into the region has faced numerous setbacks.

The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), an Israeli- and U.S.-backed group charged with distributing food to Gaza’s population of roughly 2 million people, has since paused those efforts, following numerous reports that Palestinians were being killed near its distribution sites. The GHF and IDF deny those reports, though eyewitnesses, medics, international aid organizations and others say the Israeli military is responsible.

The United Nations has warned of a growing risk of famine in Gaza as conditions worsen for the civilian population. The U.N.’s Food and Agriculture Organization said that as of May, Gaza’s residents are eating 67% of what a human body needs to survive.

“We are breaking the siege of Gaza by sea, but that’s part of a broader strategy of mobilizations that will also attempt to break the siege by land,” said Freedom Flotilla member Thiago Avila.

Tags: , , , , , ,

Why this story matters

The dispute over an aid boat carrying activists including Greta Thunberg, and Israel’s stated intent to prevent its entry to Gaza, highlights ongoing tensions surrounding humanitarian access, military blockades and international activism in the context of the ongoing Israel-Gaza conflict.

Humanitarian aid and blockade

The efforts by international activists to deliver aid to Gaza and Israel’s policy to enforce its naval blockade underscore the ongoing debate over humanitarian needs versus security concerns in the region.

International activism and political response

The involvement of high-profile activists and political figures in challenging the blockade brings increased global visibility and generates responses from governments, emphasizing the role of international solidarity and protest movements.

Conflict impact and civilian welfare

Reports from multiple sources on the humanitarian crisis and civilian casualties in Gaza illustrate the significant toll of the conflict and the dependence of the population on external aid amidst continued hostilities.

Get the big picture

Synthesized coverage insights across 132 media outlets

Debunking

Allegations regarding intentions or affiliations of the activists are primarily made by government officials or opinion writers but are not independently corroborated. Claims that past flotilla vessels were attacked by Israeli drones are made by organizing groups but have not been officially confirmed by Israeli authorities, who have not commented directly on the incidents mentioned.

Do the math

Reported numbers indicate over 54,000 Palestinians killed since October 2023, about 90% of Gaza’s population displaced, and over 2 million residents dependent on aid. The October 2023 Hamas attack resulted in 1,200 Israeli deaths and 251 hostages. The Madleen carries a symbolic aid payload, including food, medicine and water filters, but cannot meet the entire territory’s needs.

History lesson

Past flotilla attempts, such as the 2010 Mavi Marmara incident, resulted in deadly Israeli raids and significant international condemnation. The blockade’s enforcement routinely prompts similar standoffs, and flotilla efforts, though sometimes resulting in aid delivery, generally face interception, detention of activists, or forceful redirection by Israeli authorities.

Bias comparison

  • Media outlets on the left frame Israel’s naval blockade as an illegal siege causing genocide and starvation in Gaza, emphasizing the plight of civilians and portraying activists on the flotilla, including Greta Thunberg, as heroic challengers of oppression.
  • Not enough coverage from media outlets in the center to provide a bias comparison.
  • Media outlets on the right depict the blockade as a justified, necessary security measure against Hamas, labeling flotilla participants as "extreme left-wing activists" and “Hamas propaganda mouthpieces,” employing charged rhetoric like “whatever it takes” to underscore Israeli resolve.

Media landscape

Click on bars to see headlines

244 total sources

Key points from the Left

  • Israel's Defense Minister Israel Katz warned that the country will not allow the Madleen, carrying Greta Thunberg and other activists, to reach Gaza despite the humanitarian mission.
  • The Madleen aims to deliver humanitarian aid to Gaza and raise awareness about the humanitarian crisis, which faces significant difficulties due to a long-standing blockade.
  • The Freedom Flotilla Coalition accused Israel of preparing to attack the Madleen again, raising concerns for the safety of those onboard.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Center

  • The Madleen, a U.K.-flagged aid boat carrying 12 activists including Greta Thunberg, departed Sicily on June 1, heading to Gaza to deliver humanitarian supplies.
  • The journey occurs against the backdrop of Israel’s longstanding naval blockade of Gaza, which has been in place since Hamas took control in 2007 and was intensified following the militant group's assault on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, a development that sparked an extended conflict.
  • During the trip, the Madleen faced multiple drone surveillances believed linked to EU border agency Frontex, and activists reported attempts to intimidate the crew amid reports of no casualties.
  • Israel Defense Minister Israel Katz warned activists they would be unsuccessful in reaching Gaza, emphasizing that the naval blockade is enforced to stop weapons from getting to Hamas and condemning the demonstrators.
  • The flotilla’s effort highlights international concern over Gaza’s humanitarian crisis, with activists aiming to break the blockade while Israel vows to stop any such attempts by sea, air or land.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Right

  • Israel's Defense Minister Israel Katz has instructed the IDF to prevent the Madleen flotilla, led by Greta Thunberg, from reaching Gaza by any means necessary to uphold the naval blockade.
  • Katz has described the activists aboard the Madleen as promoting terrorism and labeled Thunberg and her companions as "anti-Semitic propaganda spokespeople."
  • Rima Hassan, a member of the European Parliament, declared that their action is legal and stated, "We won't turn back."
  • The activists aboard the Madleen aim to deliver aid and raise awareness of the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, hoping to reach its waters soon.

Report an issue with this summary

Other (sources without bias rating):

Powered by Ground News™

Timeline

  • The firm has ended its contract with the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) and placed a senior partner involved in the project on leave.
    Amir Levy/Getty Images
    International
    Jun 4

    US consulting firm withdraws from Gaza humanitarian aid effort

    In its first week, the U.S.-Israeli-backed effort aimed at delivering aid in Gaza has run into obstacles. The Boston Consulting Group (BCG), a U.S.-based management consulting firm hired to help develop the humanitarian aid project in Gaza, has withdrawn, a spokesperson for the company told The Washington Post. The BCG spokesperson stated that the firm…

  • Israel announced Sunday that it will allow a limited amount of humanitarian aid into the Gaza Strip, after a three-month blockade.
    AP Photo/Mahmoud Essa, File
    International
    May 18

    Israel announces ‘limited’ end to 3-month humanitarian aid blockade in Gaza

    Following nearly three months of a humanitarian aid blockade that exacerbated widespread starvation across the Gaza Strip, Israel announced Sunday, May 18, that it would allow a limited amount of humanitarian aid into the region. Israel has blocked all humanitarian aid from entering the beleaguered territory since March 2. According to The Associated Press, Israeli…

  • Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas demanded that Hamas release all hostages and cede control of Gaza to his Palestinian Authority.
    Khames Alrefi/Anadolu via Getty Images
    International
    Apr 23

    ‘You sons of dogs’: Palestinian President Abbas calls on Hamas to free hostages

    Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas called on Hamas Wednesday, April 23, to release all remaining hostages and relinquish control of Gaza to the Palestinian Authority. Abbas argued that as long as Hamas continues to hold hostages, it provides Israel with “excuses” to continue its military operations in Gaza. What did Abbas say? In his statement, President…

  • Hamas is facing a financial crisis as Israel’s continued blockade on Gaza disrupts the militant group’s access to revenue and weakens its internal operations, according to a report first published by the Wall Street Journal. Officials from Arab, Israeli, and Western sources say Israel’s restrictions have significantly reduced Hamas’s ability to profit from aid and commercial goods, cutting off a key revenue stream.
    EYAD BABA/AFP via Getty Images
    International
    Apr 17

    Hamas running out of cash as Gaza starves under blockade

    Hamas is facing a financial crisis as Israel’s continued blockade on Gaza disrupts the militant group’s access to revenue and weakens its internal operations, according to a report first published by The Wall Street Journal. Officials from Arab, Israeli and Western sources say Israel’s restrictions have significantly reduced the group’s ability to profit from aid…

  • The Biden administration announced on Tuesday, Nov. 12, there will be no significant policy shift toward Israel.
    AP Images
    International
    Nov 13

    Biden administration says no policy shift toward Israel due to humanitarian aid

    With President-elect Donald Trump and President Joe Biden meeting in Washington on Wednesday, Nov. 13, there has been a lot of talk about the peaceful transition of power. In addition, the two leaders will discuss foreign policy. Those conversations come as the Biden administration announced on Tuesday, Nov. 12, there will be no significant policy…

  • The U.S. ambassador to the U.N. says the U.S. is monitoring Israel’s ground offensive in northern Gaza to prevent a “policy of starvation.”
    Reuters
    International
    Oct 17

    US warns Israel against ‘policy of starvation’ in Gaza

    The United States says it will closely monitor Israel’s actions during its ground offensive in northern Gaza to ensure there is no “policy of starvation” in the region. Just days after the Biden administration sent a letter to Israeli officials demanding an improvement in the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu convened…

  • A new report shows President Biden was warned building a temporary pier to bring humanitarian aid to Gaza was a bad idea but when forward with it anyway.
    AP Images
    International
    Aug 28

    Biden authorized Gaza aid pier despite warnings: Report

    President Joe Biden ordered a temporary pier be constructed to bring humanitarian aid to Gaza earlier this year – even though experts said it wasn’t a good idea, according to a government watchdog. Staffers warned the president that the pier would face significant challenges. A new report from the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID)…

  • Deliveries of much-needed humanitarian aid to Gaza via a U.S.-built temporary pier have been suspended after the pier was damaged by rough seas.
    Reuters
    International
    May 29

    Aid deliveries in Gaza suspended after US-built pier damaged

    Deliveries of much-needed humanitarian aid to Gaza via a U.S.-built temporary pier have been suspended after the pier was damaged by rough seas. On Tuesday, May 28, a Pentagon spokesperson announced this latest setback to the $320 million pier, which has only been fully operational for less than two weeks, on Tuesday, May 28.  “Unfortunately, we had a…

  • The UN stated that aid delivery from the U.S-built pier along the Gazan coast has been halted amid a handful of truck interceptions.
    AP Images
    International
    May 21

    Amid worsening crisis, aid delivery being halted by UN from Gaza pier

    Amid disruptions to aid delivery, the United Nations is planning new routes to deliver aid from a U.S.-built pier off of the Gazan coast, according to a Gaza spokesperson. The halt to deliveries comes after crowds of Palestinians desperate for food intercepted trucks, causing operations to be suspended for a third day on Tuesday, May…

  • The first shipment of humanitarian aid for civilians in Gaza to use the United States’ newly built pier made its way into the territory.
    Reuters
    Business
    May 17

    Humanitarian aid begins entering Gaza via US-built pier

    The first shipment of humanitarian aid made its way across the United States’ newly built pier in Gaza, and at least four people are killed after severe storms hit the Houston area. These stories and more highlight The Morning Rundown for Friday, May 17, 2024. Humanitarian aid begins entering Gaza via US-built pier Humanitarian aid…

  • The U.S. military has anchored a temporary floating pier in Gaza to facilitate the entry of humanitarian aid.
    Reuters
    International
    May 16

    US-built pier for humanitarian aid anchored in Gaza

    The U.S. military said it has anchored a temporary floating pier to a beach in Gaza on Thursday, May 16, which will allow more humanitarian aid to enter the war-torn region. The Pentagon reported that as part of this initiative, a ship has been anchored in the Mediterranean Sea to start offloading supplies, noting that…

  • U.S. troops begin constructing Gaza aid pier to deliver humanitarian aid amidst security concerns following recent attacks by Gaza militants.
    Getty Images
    International
    Apr 26

    US troops begin building pier Gaza aid just days after mortar attack

    United States troops started the construction of a temporary pier off the coast of Gaza to deliver humanitarian aid to Palestinians residing in the enclave. The project started days after Gaza militants fired mortar shells toward the construction site. President Joe Biden announced the decision to establish the maritime pier during his State of the…

  • Despite ongoing tensions, Israel is agreeing to provide security for the U.S. during pier construction near Gaza.
    AP Images
    International
    Mar 27

    Report: Israel agrees to provide security for US in Gaza pier construction

    On Thursday, March 7, President Joe Biden announced during his State of the Union address that the U.S. military would be building a temporary pier off the coast of Gaza to help in the delivery of humanitarian aid. Now, despite being at odds over a cease-fire, Israel is agreeing to provide a “security bubble” for…

  • An aid drop killed five people and injured 10 other individuals in Gaza on March 8, as it fell to the ground after a parachute malfunction.
    AP Images
    International
    Mar 8

    5 killed by aid drop amid worsening humanitarian crisis in Gaza

    In Gaza, five individuals reportedly lost their lives and 10 others sustained injuries during a humanitarian aid airdrop incident on Friday, March 8. The malfunction of at least one parachute caused the event, which occurred around 11:30 a.m. local time in the Al-Shati refugee camp. Among the casualties were two boys, with the injured individuals…

  • Israel's military released footage of aid trucks entering Gaza from Egypt, delivering diesel and cooking gas through the Rafah crossing.
    Israel Defense Forces
    International
    Nov 27

    Hundreds of humanitarian aid trucks head to Gaza

    Israel’s military released footage of aid trucks entering Gaza from Egypt, delivering diesel and cooking gas through the Rafah crossing. COGAT announced the dispatch of an additional 200 humanitarian aid trucks to international organizations in Gaza, part of a cease-fire involving hostage and prisoner exchanges. Israel and Hamas extended the cease-fire for two more days,…

Timeline

  • The firm has ended its contract with the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) and placed a senior partner involved in the project on leave.
    Amir Levy/Getty Images
    International
    Jun 4

    US consulting firm withdraws from Gaza humanitarian aid effort

    In its first week, the U.S.-Israeli-backed effort aimed at delivering aid in Gaza has run into obstacles. The Boston Consulting Group (BCG), a U.S.-based management consulting firm hired to help develop the humanitarian aid project in Gaza, has withdrawn, a spokesperson for the company told The Washington Post. The BCG spokesperson stated that the firm…

  • Israel announced Sunday that it will allow a limited amount of humanitarian aid into the Gaza Strip, after a three-month blockade.
    AP Photo/Mahmoud Essa, File
    International
    May 18

    Israel announces ‘limited’ end to 3-month humanitarian aid blockade in Gaza

    Following nearly three months of a humanitarian aid blockade that exacerbated widespread starvation across the Gaza Strip, Israel announced Sunday, May 18, that it would allow a limited amount of humanitarian aid into the region. Israel has blocked all humanitarian aid from entering the beleaguered territory since March 2. According to The Associated Press, Israeli…

  • Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas demanded that Hamas release all hostages and cede control of Gaza to his Palestinian Authority.
    Khames Alrefi/Anadolu via Getty Images
    International
    Apr 23

    ‘You sons of dogs’: Palestinian President Abbas calls on Hamas to free hostages

    Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas called on Hamas Wednesday, April 23, to release all remaining hostages and relinquish control of Gaza to the Palestinian Authority. Abbas argued that as long as Hamas continues to hold hostages, it provides Israel with “excuses” to continue its military operations in Gaza. What did Abbas say? In his statement, President…

  • Hamas is facing a financial crisis as Israel’s continued blockade on Gaza disrupts the militant group’s access to revenue and weakens its internal operations, according to a report first published by the Wall Street Journal. Officials from Arab, Israeli, and Western sources say Israel’s restrictions have significantly reduced Hamas’s ability to profit from aid and commercial goods, cutting off a key revenue stream.
    EYAD BABA/AFP via Getty Images
    International
    Apr 17

    Hamas running out of cash as Gaza starves under blockade

    Hamas is facing a financial crisis as Israel’s continued blockade on Gaza disrupts the militant group’s access to revenue and weakens its internal operations, according to a report first published by The Wall Street Journal. Officials from Arab, Israeli and Western sources say Israel’s restrictions have significantly reduced the group’s ability to profit from aid…

  • The Biden administration announced on Tuesday, Nov. 12, there will be no significant policy shift toward Israel.
    AP Images
    International
    Nov 13

    Biden administration says no policy shift toward Israel due to humanitarian aid

    With President-elect Donald Trump and President Joe Biden meeting in Washington on Wednesday, Nov. 13, there has been a lot of talk about the peaceful transition of power. In addition, the two leaders will discuss foreign policy. Those conversations come as the Biden administration announced on Tuesday, Nov. 12, there will be no significant policy…

  • The U.S. ambassador to the U.N. says the U.S. is monitoring Israel’s ground offensive in northern Gaza to prevent a “policy of starvation.”
    Reuters
    International
    Oct 17

    US warns Israel against ‘policy of starvation’ in Gaza

    The United States says it will closely monitor Israel’s actions during its ground offensive in northern Gaza to ensure there is no “policy of starvation” in the region. Just days after the Biden administration sent a letter to Israeli officials demanding an improvement in the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu convened…

  • A new report shows President Biden was warned building a temporary pier to bring humanitarian aid to Gaza was a bad idea but when forward with it anyway.
    AP Images
    International
    Aug 28

    Biden authorized Gaza aid pier despite warnings: Report

    President Joe Biden ordered a temporary pier be constructed to bring humanitarian aid to Gaza earlier this year – even though experts said it wasn’t a good idea, according to a government watchdog. Staffers warned the president that the pier would face significant challenges. A new report from the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID)…

  • Deliveries of much-needed humanitarian aid to Gaza via a U.S.-built temporary pier have been suspended after the pier was damaged by rough seas.
    Reuters
    International
    May 29

    Aid deliveries in Gaza suspended after US-built pier damaged

    Deliveries of much-needed humanitarian aid to Gaza via a U.S.-built temporary pier have been suspended after the pier was damaged by rough seas. On Tuesday, May 28, a Pentagon spokesperson announced this latest setback to the $320 million pier, which has only been fully operational for less than two weeks, on Tuesday, May 28.  “Unfortunately, we had a…

  • The UN stated that aid delivery from the U.S-built pier along the Gazan coast has been halted amid a handful of truck interceptions.
    AP Images
    International
    May 21

    Amid worsening crisis, aid delivery being halted by UN from Gaza pier

    Amid disruptions to aid delivery, the United Nations is planning new routes to deliver aid from a U.S.-built pier off of the Gazan coast, according to a Gaza spokesperson. The halt to deliveries comes after crowds of Palestinians desperate for food intercepted trucks, causing operations to be suspended for a third day on Tuesday, May…

  • The first shipment of humanitarian aid for civilians in Gaza to use the United States’ newly built pier made its way into the territory.
    Reuters
    Business
    May 17

    Humanitarian aid begins entering Gaza via US-built pier

    The first shipment of humanitarian aid made its way across the United States’ newly built pier in Gaza, and at least four people are killed after severe storms hit the Houston area. These stories and more highlight The Morning Rundown for Friday, May 17, 2024. Humanitarian aid begins entering Gaza via US-built pier Humanitarian aid…

  • The U.S. military has anchored a temporary floating pier in Gaza to facilitate the entry of humanitarian aid.
    Reuters
    International
    May 16

    US-built pier for humanitarian aid anchored in Gaza

    The U.S. military said it has anchored a temporary floating pier to a beach in Gaza on Thursday, May 16, which will allow more humanitarian aid to enter the war-torn region. The Pentagon reported that as part of this initiative, a ship has been anchored in the Mediterranean Sea to start offloading supplies, noting that…

  • U.S. troops begin constructing Gaza aid pier to deliver humanitarian aid amidst security concerns following recent attacks by Gaza militants.
    Getty Images
    International
    Apr 26

    US troops begin building pier Gaza aid just days after mortar attack

    United States troops started the construction of a temporary pier off the coast of Gaza to deliver humanitarian aid to Palestinians residing in the enclave. The project started days after Gaza militants fired mortar shells toward the construction site. President Joe Biden announced the decision to establish the maritime pier during his State of the…

  • Despite ongoing tensions, Israel is agreeing to provide security for the U.S. during pier construction near Gaza.
    AP Images
    International
    Mar 27

    Report: Israel agrees to provide security for US in Gaza pier construction

    On Thursday, March 7, President Joe Biden announced during his State of the Union address that the U.S. military would be building a temporary pier off the coast of Gaza to help in the delivery of humanitarian aid. Now, despite being at odds over a cease-fire, Israel is agreeing to provide a “security bubble” for…

  • An aid drop killed five people and injured 10 other individuals in Gaza on March 8, as it fell to the ground after a parachute malfunction.
    AP Images
    International
    Mar 8

    5 killed by aid drop amid worsening humanitarian crisis in Gaza

    In Gaza, five individuals reportedly lost their lives and 10 others sustained injuries during a humanitarian aid airdrop incident on Friday, March 8. The malfunction of at least one parachute caused the event, which occurred around 11:30 a.m. local time in the Al-Shati refugee camp. Among the casualties were two boys, with the injured individuals…

  • Israel's military released footage of aid trucks entering Gaza from Egypt, delivering diesel and cooking gas through the Rafah crossing.
    Israel Defense Forces
    International
    Nov 27

    Hundreds of humanitarian aid trucks head to Gaza

    Israel’s military released footage of aid trucks entering Gaza from Egypt, delivering diesel and cooking gas through the Rafah crossing. COGAT announced the dispatch of an additional 200 humanitarian aid trucks to international organizations in Gaza, part of a cease-fire involving hostage and prisoner exchanges. Israel and Hamas extended the cease-fire for two more days,…