Probe continues after blaze destroys SC judge’s home


This recording was made using enhanced software.

Summary

House fire

A fire destroyed the waterfront home of South Carolina Judge Diane Goodstein on Edisto Island. Three individuals were hospitalized after jumping from the elevated first floor to escape the blaze.

Fire investigation

Investigators reported they found no evidence to suggest the fire was intentionally started and observed no signs of an explosion. These findings come despite widespread online speculation about a possible attack. The cause of the fire remains under investigation.

Judge's recent ruling

Judge Diane Goodstein recently issued a ruling temporarily blocking South Carolina from handing over its voter database to the Department of Justice. The database includes personal information of millions of voters. The South Carolina Supreme Court later reversed Judge Goodstein's decision.


Full story

A South Carolina judge who recently ruled against the Department of Justice (DOJ) is back in the news after her home burned down. The blaze erupted Saturday on Edisto Island, destroying Judge Diane Goodstein’s waterfront home. Authorities said three individuals were hospitalized after jumping from the elevated first floor.

Rescuers reached them by kayak because of the marshy terrain.

QR code for SAN app download

Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.

Point phone camera here

Officials have not released their identities. However, Goodstein was not home at the time of the fire, according to ABC News. ABC also reports that Goodstein’s husband and son were among the victims forced to jump from the first floor.

Investigators stated that they found no evidence to suggest that the fire was intentionally started. They added that there are no signs of an explosion, despite widespread online speculation about a potential attack.

Judge’s connection to President Trump

Goodstein is the judge who last month temporarily blocked South Carolina from handing over its voter database to the DOJ.

The database includes millions of voter files that include personal names. addresses, driver’s license numbers and Social Security numbers. The administration requested the files after Trump signed an executive order in March prohibiting non-citizens from registering to vote.

The state supreme court later reversed that decision.

Response to the fire

The high court requested privacy, saying: “We respectfully suggest that common decency be followed by all in respecting the privacy of the Goodstein family during this difficult time.”

South Carolina Gov. Henry McMaster echoed that message. He wrote that there’s no evidence someone set the fire intentionally, and he urged people not to spread unverified information.

The cause of the fire remains under investigation.

All three injured individuals are receiving treatment at the Medical University of South Carolina in Charleston.

Jason K. Morrell (Morning Managing Editor), Emma Stoltzfus (Video Editor), and Matt Bishop (Digital Producer) contributed to this report.
Tags: , , , , ,

SAN provides
Unbiased. Straight Facts.

Don’t just take our word for it.


Certified balanced reporting

According to media bias experts at AllSides

AllSides Certified Balanced May 2025

Transparent and credible

Awarded a perfect reliability rating from NewsGuard

100/100

Welcome back to trustworthy journalism.

Find out more

Why this story matters

A fire that destroyed the South Carolina home of Circuit Court Judge Diane Goodstein, which left three people hospitalized and followed widely reported threats against her, highlights concerns about the safety of judiciary figures amid ongoing political tensions and controversy over voting rights.

Judicial security

The incident raises concerns about the safety and protection of judges, especially those involved in high-profile or politically sensitive cases, as noted by reports of prior threats against Judge Goodstein.

Voting rights and privacy

Judge Goodstein's recent decision to block the release of voter data to the federal government, and the subsequent legal and political reactions, underscore ongoing debates over the privacy of voter information and federal versus state authority.

Political polarization

Responses to the fire, including accusations and political commentary from various figures, illustrate how judicial decisions can become focal points for broader partisan tensions and public discourse on the legitimacy of the courts.

SAN provides
Unbiased. Straight Facts.

Don’t just take our word for it.


Certified balanced reporting

According to media bias experts at AllSides

AllSides Certified Balanced May 2025

Transparent and credible

Awarded a perfect reliability rating from NewsGuard

100/100

Welcome back to trustworthy journalism.

Find out more

Bias comparison

  • Media outlets on the left frame the fire at Judge Goodstein's $1.5 million beachfront home as a potential act of right-wing retaliation, emphasizing her ruling against the DOJ's voter data request for 3 million registrants as a trigger for threats and a "startling rise in political violence" fueled by Trump rhetoric, while portraying Stephen Miller's response as a "melt down" evading condemnation.
  • Media outlets in the center de-emphasize these politicized angles, sticking to injury details like three hospitalizations from the explosion.
  • Media outlets on the right counter by highlighting Democratic "slings" of "right-wing arson claims" as "vile" and "libelous madness," defending the administration's "election integrity" efforts.

Media landscape

Click on bars to see headlines

143 total sources

Key points from the Left

  • A fire destroyed the home of South Carolina Circuit Court Judge Diane Goodstein on Oct. 6, 2025, while she was not present, and three family members suffered serious injuries.
  • Three family members, including former state senator Arnold Goodstein, were hospitalized due to serious injuries related to the fire.
  • The South Carolina Law Enforcement Division is investigating whether the fire resulted from arson, as Goodstein had received multiple death threats related to her judicial decisions.
  • A spokesperson for the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division stated that the cause of the fire is currently under investigation, with no conclusion on whether it was an accident or arson.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Center

  • A South Carolina judge's home was destroyed in a fire on Saturday, injuring her husband, a former Democratic state senator, who had to be rescued after jumping from the house.
  • The cause of the fire is under investigation by state authorities, with arson among the possible angles being reviewed.
  • Judge Goodstein, who recently blocked the release of voter data, had reportedly received threats in the weeks preceding the fire, though authorities have not confirmed any direct link.

Report an issue with this summary

Key points from the Right

  • A fire destroyed the Edisto Beach home of Circuit Court Judge Diana Goodstein and former South Carolina Senator Arnold Goodstein, leaving three people hospitalized on Saturday.
  • Arnold Goodstein and two others were rescued from a marshy area by neighbors and paramedics, with one person airlifted to a hospital.
  • Stephen Miller criticized Democratic Rep. Daniel Goldman for blaming the fire on the political right, which Goldman alleged was an act of arson.
  • South Carolina Supreme Court Chief Justice John Kittredge confirmed that Judge Goodstein was not in the house during the fire, as she was walking on the beach.

Report an issue with this summary

Other (sources without bias rating):

Powered by Ground News™

Daily Newsletter

Start your day with fact-based news

Start your day with fact-based news

Learn more about our emails. Unsubscribe anytime.

By entering your email, you agree to the Terms and Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.