- Congress advanced a Republican-led budget framework that targets $1.5 trillion in cuts over a decade. While Medicaid and Medicare are not named in the resolution, the committee tasked with achieving $880 billion in cuts oversees programs dominated by Medicaid spending.
- Democrats argue that the math makes cutting Medicaid inevitable. Republicans insist that benefits will remain untouched and say fraud reduction will be the key to savings.
- Final details of the budget are still being negotiated, and Medicaid’s future remains uncertain until the reconciliation bill is released.
Full Story
The debate over Medicaid funding has reignited as House and Senate Republicans push ahead with a budget plan backed by President Donald Trump — referred to by supporters as the “Big Beautiful Bill.”
Trump and his allies have long called for sweeping cuts to federal spending. Now, with a new budget framework targeting $1.5 trillion in reductions over the next decade — while also extending the Trump-era tax cuts — the question returns: Will the spending cuts include Medicaid?
Partisan headlines paint opposing pictures
That question, which affects one in five Americans, has provoked starkly different answers across the media landscape.
Left-leaning outlets such as MSNBC and The Associated Press have published headlines like:
- “‘Largest Medicaid cut in American history’: Leader Jeffries issues warning about budget.”
- “Republicans consider cuts and work requirements for Medicaid, jeopardizing care for millions.”
Meanwhile, right-leaning outlets including Fox News and The Federalist report:
- “Dems weaponize Medicaid anxiety in bid to take down Trump-backed federal funding plan.”
- “Republicans, don’t buy Democrats’ lies about Medicaid ‘cuts.’”
Where the budget process stands
Congress is working to pass a comprehensive budget for fiscal year 2025, with funding levels projected for the next several years. Currently, the government is being funded through a continuing resolution that maintains 2024 spending levels.
The budget proposal — referred to as Trump’s “Big Beautiful Bill” —includes spending reductions and priorities such as extending tax cuts, bolstering border security, and increasing defense funding.
The House passed its version of the budget in February, which proposed $1.5 trillion in spending cuts over the next decade. In early April, the Senate passed an amended version that significantly reduced those cuts to $4 billion.
The House was initially set to vote on the Senate’s version on April 9 but delayed after 12 Republicans opposed the reduction. On April 10, the House passed the Senate’s version after securing a commitment to restore the $1.5 trillion target.
Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.
Point phone camera here
Next, House and Senate committees will draft the specific reconciliation bill — which Republicans hope to pass and send to Trump’s desk by Memorial Day.
Medicaid not named, but implications raise concerns
The budget blueprint does not explicitly mention Medicaid or Medicare. However, it assigns the House Energy and Commerce Committee to cut the deficit by at least $880 billion over 10 years. That committee oversees Medicaid and Medicare programs.
According to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office, Medicaid accounts for 93% — or $8.2 trillion — of the $8.8 trillion in spending under the committee’s jurisdiction. Without cuts to Medicaid or Medicare, the committee controls only $581 billion in spending — short of the $880 billion reduction goal.
Democrats argue this data signals inevitable Medicaid cuts.
“It’s going to be devastating for families across this country. There is no way that they can get to the cuts they want without deep, deep cuts to the Medicaid program.”
Rep. Katherine Clark, D-Mass., told MSNBC
“Nobody wants these savage cuts to Medicaid. It will decimate health care for so many people.”
Sen. Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., told MSNBC
GOP says benefits are safe, allege fraud and waste
Republican leaders, including President Trump, deny any intention to cut Medicaid benefits. Instead, they argue savings will come from reducing fraud, waste and abuse within the system.
According to the nonpartisan Government Accountability Office (GAO), improper payments in fiscal year 2024 totaled $54.3 billion for Medicare and $31 billion for Medicaid — a combined $85.3 billion.
Reaching $880 billion in cuts over 10 years would require $88 billion annually, nearly matching the current estimate of improper payments. House Speaker Mike Johnson has cited these figures in support of the GOP’s strategy.
“Medicaid, for example, which is what Democrats are frankly lying to the American people about; no one has talked about cutting one benefit in Medicaid. The estimate is $51 billion a year in Medicaid is lost to fraud, that’s unconscionable.”
House Speaker Mike Johnson R-La., told Fox News
“I have said it so many times. This will not be – read my lips – we’re not going to touch it. We are going to look for fraud.”
President Donald Trump, while taking questions from reporters
Is there actually any fraud?
However, the GAO states that improper payments include a range of issues — not just fraud — such as incorrect amounts, lack of documentation or payments that should not have been made at all.
“The vast majority of improper payments occurred in situations where a reviewer could not determine if a payment was proper because of insufficient documentation,” the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services wrote.
That doesn’t necessarily mean that there is any fraud associated with those cases.
Final details still unknown as lawmakers write the proposal
Despite GOP assurances, lawmakers continue to face questions about whether Medicaid or other public benefit programs will face reductions. As the reconciliation bill is still being drafted, no final language has been released.
The rhetoric from lawmakers mirrors the partisan interpretations seen in news coverage. While left-leaning media outlets claim Medicaid cuts are coming, right-leaning ones argue they are not.
In reality, much remains unknown. The key word appearing across outlets of all stripes is “could” — as in:
- ABC News: “It could bring significant cuts to Medicaid.”
- CBS News: “Medicaid cuts could be included in the budget plan.”
- Fox News: “The deal could force cuts on Medicaid.”
Whether those cuts actually materialize will depend on the final bill — which is still weeks away from being unveiled.
