Editor’s note: This story contains discussion of child sexual abuse material.
When news broke that a Wisconsin man would not be prosecuted for possessing AI-generated images of sexual abuse, the backlash was swift.
In an “unsettling ruling,” Fox News reported, a federal appeals court in Chicago was being “forced” by decades-old Supreme Court precedent “to protect the in-home possession of AI-generated child sexual abuse material.”
Download the Straight Arrow app today to get the stories that matter free from manipulation, bias or agenda.
Point phone camera here
NBC News reported that AI-generated images of child sexual abuse may be protected by the First Amendment “in some cases.” And the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association said the court ruling advanced “the normalization of abuse and explicit images of children.”
But the August ruling by the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in the case of Steven Anderegg was much narrower than many initial reactions suggested, experts told Straight Arrow. Anderegg — whom federal prosecutors accused in 2024 of using AI to generate “thousands of realistic images of prepubescent minors” — still faces charges that could send him to prison for as much as 30 years.
But experts say his case highlights how artificial intelligence may have outpaced a decades-old Supreme Court precedent and how far it may push discussions over the limits of the First Amendment.
But experts say his case highlights how artificial intelligence is complicating a decades-old Supreme Court precedent and .
In its ruling, the appeals court didn’t say all AI-generated material depicting child sexual abuse is legal. Instead, it addressed a specific constitutional question about whether people can possess obscene materials.
The court said the First Amendment protects the “purely private possession” of obscene materials inside their homes “even when that material is a depiction of imaginary children,” said Riana Pfefferkorn, a policy fellow at Stanford University, where she studies the intersection of AI, law and child safety.
Pfefferkorn said the case raises new legal questions about technology use and free speech — particularly about the depictions of minors who don’t physically exist.
“Even when it comes to realistic-looking depictions of virtual children, the Supreme Court has repeatedly said the distinction in terms of whether something is constitutionally protected or not is: was there a real child involved in the production of that material or not?” Pfefferkorn told Straight Arrow.
How much privacy do people have at home?
In 2024, a federal grand jury charged Anderegg, then 42, with producing, distributing and possessing images depicting child sexual abuse. Authorities said he shared the AI-generated images with a minor.
But the trial court dropped the possession charge, citing a landmark Supreme Court opinion from 1969, Stanley v. Georgia, in which the justices found that the First Amendment permits people to possess obscene content in their homes. That ruling struck down a state anti-obscenity law.
Twenty-one years later, however, in Osborne v. Ohio, the Supreme Court said the government could prohibit people from possessing child sexual abuse material — often known as child pornography — because it had a compelling interest in protecting children from exploitation.
Just last week, a South Dakota man was sentenced to five years in federal prison after he was convicted for altering images of children he knew with AI-generated nude bodies.
But what happens when the children depicted in this material don’t exist in the physical world?
In the 2002 case Ashcroft v. Free Speech Coalition, the Supreme Court struck down efforts to apply the same penalties to virtual depictions of child nudity as to sexual abuse material depicting real children.
“The sexual abuse of a child is a most serious crime and an act repugnant to the moral instincts of a decent people,” Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote in the majority opinion.
But Congress went too far, Kennedy wrote, in equating virtual images with real ones, despite arguments from supporters that computer-generated pornography could motivate pedophiles to molest children.
Do AI depictions harm real children?
The Ashcroft decision was central to the recent appeals court ruling in the Anderegg case.
“The court didn’t even seem happy about having to say, ‘Hey, we have binding Supreme Court precedent on this question, and we don’t like this material either, but we have to follow the Supreme Court on this issue,” Pfefferkorn said.
The widespread adoption of AI further complicates efforts to prevent child sexual abuse, said Kate Ruane, who directs the Free Expression Project at the nonprofit Center for Democracy and Technology. In the Anderegg case, the government argued that AI-generated material can create real-world harm to actual children.
“Generative AI has changed the landscape by just making it a lot easier to create child sexual abuse material that doesn’t depict a real child,” Ruane told Straight Arrow. Advances in the technology, she said, also could make it more difficult for police to distinguish between AI-created children and real children who are in danger and need immediate help.
Lennon Torres with the Heat Initiative, a nonprofit devoted to preventing tech-enabled child abuse, said the Supreme Court needs to revisit the issue — and recognize that even virtual depictions of child sexual abuse have real-world harms.
“This type of technology essentially puts every child at risk,” Torres told Straight Arrow. Even when AI-generated images are not deepfakes of real people, Torres noted, the tools are trained on images of actual children.
“The reason that technology is able to do that is because it has seen and uses the imagery of real children truly and horribly being raped in real life,” Torres said. “We forget that there are real people behind this.”
Round out your reading
- Shielded by DHS, immigration agents’ identities exposed in massive data breach.
- Strokes are rising among younger adults. But why? And what happens afterward?
- Democrats’ report links Trump to Epstein abuse, alleges DOJ cover-up.
- Rare legal maneuver could doom DOJ’s latest case against Comey.
- Inside the Russian propaganda group injecting false sexual assault allegations into contentious Senate races.