Hey everybody, Peter Zeihan here coming to you from Birmingham, Alabama. Today we’re gonna talk about a couple of major elections that have happened recently. I mean, we’ve already covered Mexico, but I want to do South African India now. The conventional wisdom in most places is actually correct on this one. In India, the government of the BJP, which is Prime Minister Modi, suffered a significant setback polling as recently as a week ago, or a week before the elections indicated that they were on track to get a two thirds majority, which would have allowed the Modi government to amend the Constitution without restriction. And instead, they came in at under 50%. And so they actually have to form a coalition government. So they’re still in charge, Modi still the Prime Minister, but it has been a significant hit to his prestige. And lots of people are talking about how this is a savior, Indian seizing control of their own democracy and preventing an autocracy from happening because Modi has become more and more authoritarian as he’s been Prime Minister. All of that is correct. I would argue that Modi’s reputation for being an economic Whiz has proven wrong. And he has mismanaged a lot of the government finances and a lot of economic policies turning towards populism and that was rejected to a certain degree. But rather than poopoo Modi or the BJP in general, I think what’s something that is far more important is what’s happening under the hood. This is a country that has lots of issues and infrastructure and education and quality. But they just ran an election where a billion people voted, and the government didn’t win in the way it had hoped. And it’s okay. The trust in the political system is high. The Indians may have their faults, but wow, do they know how to count votes, they ran a clean election, the government has accepted it, Modi has accepted it. That’s something that we could probably learn a little bit from. The other country, of course, is South Africa. There, you’ve got the ANC, which fought against the apartheid system back in the 70s, and 80s. That has basically run the government ever since usually with a supermajority, and they too, have now gotten the smallest share of their vote in a very long time, if not ever again, below 50%, they also will have to form a coalition. Here, the problem is a little bit more intractable, because there aren’t a lot of people to draw from. You’ve got a group called the Democratic Alliance that is basically like a pro business libertarian group that is primarily ethnically white, you’ve got the economic freedom fighters who would find Latin American socialist to be to conservatives. And then you have a new group that has formed by the former president of the country, jacob zuma, basically read his cult of personality and zoom was arguably one of the most corrupt people in human history, who’s trying to make a comeback. So whoever the ANC has to form a coalition with it’s going to be awkward. But again, here, the ANC, which is known for corruption has just run an election in which they lost, and no one has an issue with it because it was free and fair. One of the things we forget about the United States is we actually do run the most free most fair elections in the world. Don’t believe me believe a guy by the name of Chris Coons, who was Donald Trump’s appointed election integrity adviser who said the day of the election four years ago, that it was the cleanest election in American history. Now, Koons was, of course, fired within an hour for making that statement. But he hasn’t recounted and of all of the challenges we have seen to the American electoral system in the last three years. Of all the court cases, not one shred of evidence has yet to be produced indicating that anything had gone wrong. The day of running elections isn’t hard, believing in them, that’s a little bit more difficult.
Related
Peter Zeihan
Geopolitical Strategist
Election results in India and South Africa show voters have faith
Jun 10
Peter Zeihan
Geopolitical Strategist
By Straight Arrow News
Recent major elections in India and South Africa had some surprising outcomes, with both ruling parties suffering significant setbacks. In India, for the first time since Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist party came to power in 2014, it did not secure a majority of the vote on its own. This means Modi will need the support of other parties to form a coalition. In South Africa, the African National Congress (ANC) lost its parliamentary majority and will also need coalition partners to form a government.
Watch the above video as Straight Arrow News contributor Peter Zeihan explains recent election results in India and South Africa. Zeihan argues that in both cases, unlike in America, voters show high levels of trust in government.
Be the first to know when Peter Zeihan publishes a new commentary! Download the Straight Arrow News app and enable push notifications today!
Excerpted from Peter’s June 10 “Zeihan on Geopolitics” newsletter:
We’ve got a few more elections to talk about today, and who knows, maybe the U.S. might even learn something from South Africa and India.
Over in India, Prime Minister Modi’s BJP party didn’t quite get the majority vote they expected, so that necessitates a coalition government. Many are even citing this as a good thing for India, as to limit Modi’s increasingly authoritarian rule. The crazy thing is that this election was clean, well-run, and everyone has accepted the results.
In South Africa, the party who has been ruling since the anti-apartheid era — the ANC — also fell short at the polls. So, they’ll also need to form a coalition, although the other parties rounding out the coalition aren’t exactly first round draft picks. Despite the ANC’s corruption, the election was still accepted as free and fair.
Here are my takeaways from today.
#1: India and South Africa will be forming coalition governments.
#2: The people of India and South Africa have more faith in their electoral processes than Americans do in theirs… yikes.
Hey everybody, Peter Zeihan here coming to you from Birmingham, Alabama. Today we’re gonna talk about a couple of major elections that have happened recently. I mean, we’ve already covered Mexico, but I want to do South African India now. The conventional wisdom in most places is actually correct on this one. In India, the government of the BJP, which is Prime Minister Modi, suffered a significant setback polling as recently as a week ago, or a week before the elections indicated that they were on track to get a two thirds majority, which would have allowed the Modi government to amend the Constitution without restriction. And instead, they came in at under 50%. And so they actually have to form a coalition government. So they’re still in charge, Modi still the Prime Minister, but it has been a significant hit to his prestige. And lots of people are talking about how this is a savior, Indian seizing control of their own democracy and preventing an autocracy from happening because Modi has become more and more authoritarian as he’s been Prime Minister. All of that is correct. I would argue that Modi’s reputation for being an economic Whiz has proven wrong. And he has mismanaged a lot of the government finances and a lot of economic policies turning towards populism and that was rejected to a certain degree. But rather than poopoo Modi or the BJP in general, I think what’s something that is far more important is what’s happening under the hood. This is a country that has lots of issues and infrastructure and education and quality. But they just ran an election where a billion people voted, and the government didn’t win in the way it had hoped. And it’s okay. The trust in the political system is high. The Indians may have their faults, but wow, do they know how to count votes, they ran a clean election, the government has accepted it, Modi has accepted it. That’s something that we could probably learn a little bit from. The other country, of course, is South Africa. There, you’ve got the ANC, which fought against the apartheid system back in the 70s, and 80s. That has basically run the government ever since usually with a supermajority, and they too, have now gotten the smallest share of their vote in a very long time, if not ever again, below 50%, they also will have to form a coalition. Here, the problem is a little bit more intractable, because there aren’t a lot of people to draw from. You’ve got a group called the Democratic Alliance that is basically like a pro business libertarian group that is primarily ethnically white, you’ve got the economic freedom fighters who would find Latin American socialist to be to conservatives. And then you have a new group that has formed by the former president of the country, jacob zuma, basically read his cult of personality and zoom was arguably one of the most corrupt people in human history, who’s trying to make a comeback. So whoever the ANC has to form a coalition with it’s going to be awkward. But again, here, the ANC, which is known for corruption has just run an election in which they lost, and no one has an issue with it because it was free and fair. One of the things we forget about the United States is we actually do run the most free most fair elections in the world. Don’t believe me believe a guy by the name of Chris Coons, who was Donald Trump’s appointed election integrity adviser who said the day of the election four years ago, that it was the cleanest election in American history. Now, Koons was, of course, fired within an hour for making that statement. But he hasn’t recounted and of all of the challenges we have seen to the American electoral system in the last three years. Of all the court cases, not one shred of evidence has yet to be produced indicating that anything had gone wrong. The day of running elections isn’t hard, believing in them, that’s a little bit more difficult.
Related
Securing energy for the EU is hard, not impossible
Russia is a top global exporter of natural gas to the European Union, but Russian exports have come under increasing sanctions following Putin’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. European markets have also worked overtime to secure other energy sources since then. And while some nations like Libya could theoretically export more energy, they’re…
15 hrs ago
Putin’s defense pact with North Korea not the brightest move
On June 19, Putin concluded a two-day trip to North Korea with the signing of a new comprehensive partnership pact that pledges mutual defense in the event of a war. The deal is seen as a threat to South Korea, which is subsequently reviewing the possibility of supplying weapons to Ukraine. Watch the above video as…
Yesterday
Ukraine delivers killing blow to Russian space operations
Recent Ukrainian counterattacks have targeted Russian air defense systems in anticipation of Ukraine receiving F-16 fighter jets later this summer. These attacks have also hit military, naval, logistics hubs and communications centers, most recently the NIP-16 Space Tracking and Deep Space Communications Center. Watch the above video as Straight Arrow News contributor Peter Zeihan argues…
Tuesday
Micro-state San Marino a hub for Russian activity
San Marino, a tiny micro-state, is causing concern for its much larger neighbor, Italy, due to its friendly relations with Russia. According to the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), social and political trends in the world’s fifth-smallest country closely mirror those of Italy. However, Italy is a founding member of NATO and supports Ukraine against Russia.…
Monday
Why Putin’s visit to Vietnam should not alarm Americans
Russian President Vladimir Putin’s June 20 visit to Hanoi, Vietnam has triggered some alarm bells in the West, where some observers worried that Vietnam may be drifting away from the U.S. orbit and more towards Russia. The Vietnamese and Americans fought a long war half a century ago, but have since repaired their relationship and…
Friday
Underreported stories from each side
Russia considering downgrading relations with the West, the Kremlin says
20 sources | 19% from the left
Envato
List of threatened species grows by 1,000, but conservation efforts bring hope for some animals
31 sources | 6% from the right
AP Images
Latest Stories
Members of Congress want to people to stop buying ‘fast fashion’
Watch 3:00
9 hrs ago
CDC studying Michigan farm workers’ blood to fight H5N1 virus
Watch 1:25
10 hrs ago
Walgreens to close ‘significant’ number of stores as profits fall
Watch 1:22
10 hrs ago
Candidates, media are already fact-checking ahead of debate
Watch 2:57
10 hrs ago
Man arrested for flipping trooper the bird awarded $175K in settlement
Watch 1:54
11 hrs ago
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
What kind of leader America needs
14 hrs ago
Matthew Continetti
The modern-day Republican woman has terrifying role models
15 hrs ago
Jordan Reid
US should eliminate taxes on server tips
Yesterday
Newt Gingrich
Louisiana’s Ten Commandments law proves Gov. Landry is corrupt
Yesterday
Adrienne Lawrence