Impeachment hearing features a witness in prison, a Putin mask, an empty chair
Mar 20
By Ray Bogan (Political Correspondent)
Media Landscape
See who else is reporting on this story and which side of the political spectrum they lean. To read other sources, click on the plus signs below.
Learn more about this dataLeft 17%
Center 61%
Right 22%
Bias Distribution
Far
Left
+0
Click to close
Hunter Biden Leaves Republicans Hanging At High-Profile Hearing
Click to see story on HuffPost
‘Hey Comer!’ Dem puts GOP on spot as impeachment effort flails for evidence
Click to see story on Raw Story
Revealed: Texts shed light on anti-Biden witness’ ‘connections to Russia’
Click to see story on Alternet
Even Fox News Is Tired of Republicans’ Bogus Biden Impeachment
Click to see story on The New Republic
Click to close
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Associated Press News
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on abc News
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Coast Reporter
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Star Tribune
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Prince George Citizen
Biden impeachment faces pressure as Republicans divided on level of support
Click to see story on PBS NewsHour
Moskowitz DARES Republicans to Hold Biden Impeachment Vote in Wild Scene: ‘Hey Comer, How Come You Haven’t Called for Impeachment?’
Click to see story on Mediaite
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move. – The Boston Globe
Click to see story on Boston Globe
Click to close
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on KRDO
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on KIFI
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Winnipeg Free Press
Republicans Reject Motion to Impeach Joe Biden
Click to see story on Newsweek
Major News Networks Take A Pass On Full Coverage Of Latest Joe Biden Impeachment Inquiry Hearing
Click to see story on Deadline
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on WPLG
Jay Ambrose: The test Biden can’t pass
Click to see story on Pioneer Press
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KCRA 3
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on WKMG
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Click on Detroit
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on San Diego Union Tribune
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WCVB
House GOP Impeachment Devolves Into Bickering
Click to see story on Political Wire
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WLWT
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WMUR
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WLKY
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WESH
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on Koco News5
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Helena Independent Record
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KETV
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WDSU
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WTAE
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WYFF
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Lincoln Journal Star
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KCCI
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KMBC
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WISN
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WBAL-TV
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WPTZ
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WMTW
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WVTM
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WAPT
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KOAT
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on The Columbian
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WPBF
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WGAL
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WXII
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KSBW
Republicans, Democrats argue over Biden impeachment
Click to see story on The Center Square
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on tribtoday.com
House panel members clash at latest Biden oversight hearing
Click to see story on Roll Call
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WJCL
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KHBS
US House panel holds Biden impeachment hearing, but next steps unclear
Click to see story on KSL
Click to close
Republicans’ second impeachment hearing to showcase Biden family ‘scam’ – Washington Examiner
Click to see story on Washington Examiner
US House panel holds Biden impeachment hearing, but next steps unclear
Click to see story on The Straits Times
Конгрессмен надел маску Путина на слушание по импичменту Байдена
Click to see story on RIA Novosti [🇷🇺-affiliated]
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on MY Northwest
Congressman came to the hearings on the impeachment of Bayden in Putin’s mask
Click to see story on Lenta.RU [🇷🇺-affiliated]
Six questions the Biden impeachment inquiry must still answer
Click to see story on justthenews.com
Click to close
Hunter Biden Hearing Grinds To A Halt After Ranking Democrat Threatens Bobulinski With Subpoena
Click to see story on The Daily Caller
House Republicans Push Forward With Impeachment Hearing Despite Hunter Biden Snub
Click to see story on The Epoch Times
Biden Impeachment: President To Get Invite For Testimony, GOP Chairman Says
Click to see story on The Daily Wire
‘Deeply Concerning’: Democratic Senator Opposes Biden Judicial Nominee Over Anti-Police Ties
Click to see story on Washington Free Beacon
Lackluster Impeachment Hearing With Biden Associates Could Signal Looming End to the Probe
Click to see story on The New York Sun
House Oversight Committee Hearing Examines ‘Joe Biden’s Abuse of Public Office’ › American Greatness
Click to see story on American Greatness
The World and Everything in It: March 20, 2024
Click to see story on wng.org
Will the Biden Impeachment Inquiry Bear Fruit Today?
Click to see story on discernreport.com
Former Hunter Biden associates to testify publicly in next phase of impeachment inquiry
Click to see story on Fox News
Biden Business Associate Devon Archer Refuses to Attend Impeachment Inquiry Hearing
Click to see story on Breitbart
Click to close
Far
Right
+0
Click to close
Untracked Bias
“U.S. Representatives” hold a new hearing on the impeachment of President Biden
Click to see story on الوطن
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Airdrie City View
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on pantheonsite.io
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on mor-tv.com
Click to close
76 other sources covering this story
Total News Sources
76
Leaning Left
12
Center
44
Leaning Right
16
Last Updated
1 month ago
A congressman wearing a Putin mask, an empty chair for Hunter Biden, and a key witness testifying via teleconference from prison: that was the reality at the House Oversight Committee’s impeachment hearing into Joe Biden Wednesday, March 20. The hearing included some made-for-TV moments but no new information.
Republicans continued to push their narrative that Joe Biden and his family made $24 million off his public service.
“The Bidens sell Joe Biden, that is their business,” Chairman James Comer, R-Ky., said. “Joe shows up, shakes a few hands in front of his son and says, ‘Take care of my boy,’ or something similar, and the money flows to the tune of tens of millions of dollars.”
Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.
Point phone camera here
Democrats contend that Republicans have failed to substantiate any wrongdoing throughout their investigation, which has spanned more than a year.
“With any luck, today marks the end of perhaps the most spectacular failure in the history of congressional investigations — the effort to find a high crime or misdemeanor committed by Joe Biden and then to impeach him for it,” Ranking Member Jamie Raskin, D-Md., said.
Democrats brought in a former ally of Donald Trump to testify. Lev Parnas worked with Rudy Giuliani on behalf of the former president in an effort to find evidence of corruption with the Bidens’ dealings in Ukraine.
“In nearly a year traveling the world and interviewing officials in different countries, I found precisely zero evidence of the Bidens’ corruption in Ukraine,” Parnas told the committee.
Republicans brought in two witnesses who were former business partners of Hunter Biden.
Jason Galanis, who worked with Hunter Biden on acquisition projects, testified from prison.
“The entire value-add of Hunter Biden to our business was his family name and his access to his father, Vice President Joe Biden,” Galanis said.
The other witness, Tony Bobulinski, worked with Hunter Biden on a project involving a Chinese Energy company. He said Joe Biden was the brand sold by Hunter Biden to those seeking to gain access and influence with the United States government.
“Joe Biden was more than a participant in and beneficiary of his family’s business; he was an active, aware enabler who met with business associates such as myself to further the business, despite being buffered by a complex scheme to maintain plausible deniability,” Bobulinski said.
Unbiased news.
Directly to your inbox. Free!
Learn more about our emails. Unsubscribe anytime.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
Bobulinski first came forward with these accusations in October 2020 when Trump invited him to be his guest at a presidential debate. He has repeated many of the same accusations since that time, leading to questions about the inquiry’s next steps.
Straight Arrow News asked Rep. Eric Burlison, R-Mo., where Republicans plan to take it from here.
“What’s hopefully is going to be added is that you guys actually will cover it,” Burlison said. “Because if you ask most Americans they don’t, they don’t know the story. [Hunter] was doing business with some of the most corrupt individuals in the world.”
Rep. Raskin said Republicans appear to be preparing to write criminal referrals, rather than moving toward an impeachment vote. Those referrals would urge the Justice Department to investigate specific crimes but they would not be binding.
[RAY BOGAN]
A Congressman wearing a Putin Mask, an empty chair for Hunter Biden, and a key witness testifying via teleconference from prison, that was the reality at the House Oversight Committee’s impeachment hearing into Joe Biden Wednesday. The hearing included some made for TV moments, but no new information.
Republicans continued to push their narrative that Joe Biden and his family made $24 million off his public service.
[James Comer, R-Ky.]
“The Biden’s sell Joe Biden, that is their business,” Chairman James Comer, R-Ky., said. “Joe shows up, shakes a few hands in front of his son and says, ‘take care of my boy’, or something similar, and the money flows to the tune of tens of millions of dollars.”
[RAY BOGAN]
Democrats say Republicans have not been able to prove any wrongdoing during their more than yearlong investigation.
[Jamie Raskin, D-Md.]
“With any luck, today marks the end of perhaps the most spectacular failure in the history of congressional investigations – the effort to find a high crime or misdemeanor committed by Joe Biden and then to impeach him for it,” Ranking Member Jamie Raskin, D-Md., said.
[RAY BOGAN]
Democrats brought in a former ally of Donald Trump to testify. Lev Parnas worked with Rudy Giuliani on behalf of the former president in an effort to find evidence of corruption with the Biden’s dealings in Ukraine.
[Lev Parnas]
“In nearly a year traveling the world and interviewing officials in different countries I found precisely zero evidence of the Biden’s corruption in Ukraine,” Parnas told the committee.
[RAY BOGAN]
Republican brought in two witnesses who were former business partners of Hunter Biden.
Jason Galanis, who worked with Hunter Biden on acquisition projects, testified from prison.
[Jason Galanis]
“The entire value-add of Hunter Biden to our business was his family name and his access to his father, Vice President Joe Biden.” Galanis said.
The other witness, Tony Bobulinski, worked with Hunter Biden on a project involving a Chinese Energy company. He said Joe Biden was the brand sold by Hunter Biden to those seeking to gain access and influence with the United States government.
[Tony Bobulinski]
“Joe Biden was more than a participant in and beneficiary of his family’s business; he was an active, aware enabler who met with business associates such as myself to further the business, despite being buffered by a complex scheme to maintain plausible deniability,” Bobulinski said.
[RAY BOGAN]
Bobulinski first came forward with these accusations in October 2020 when former President Trump invited him to be his guest at a presidential debate. He has repeated many of the same accusations since that time. It is leading to questions about the next steps for the impeachment inquiry.
SAN asked Rep. Eric Burlison, R-Mo., where Republicans plan to take it from here.
[Rep. Eric Burlison, R-Mo.]
“What’s hopefully is going to be added is that you guys actually will cover it. Because if you ask most Americans they don’t, they don’t know the story,” Burlison said. “(Hunter) was doing business with some of the most corrupt individuals in the world.”
[RAY BOGAN]
Rep. Raskin said Republicans appear to be preparing to write criminal referrals, rather than moving toward an impeachment vote. Those referrals would urge the Justice Department to investigate specific crimes but they would not be binding.
Related
Media Landscape
See who else is reporting on this story and which side of the political spectrum they lean. To read other sources, click on the plus signs below.
Learn more about this dataLeft 17%
Center 61%
Right 22%
Bias Distribution
Far
Left
+0
Click to close
Hunter Biden Leaves Republicans Hanging At High-Profile Hearing
Click to see story on HuffPost
‘Hey Comer!’ Dem puts GOP on spot as impeachment effort flails for evidence
Click to see story on Raw Story
Revealed: Texts shed light on anti-Biden witness’ ‘connections to Russia’
Click to see story on Alternet
Even Fox News Is Tired of Republicans’ Bogus Biden Impeachment
Click to see story on The New Republic
Click to close
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Associated Press News
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on abc News
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Coast Reporter
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Star Tribune
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Prince George Citizen
Biden impeachment faces pressure as Republicans divided on level of support
Click to see story on PBS NewsHour
Moskowitz DARES Republicans to Hold Biden Impeachment Vote in Wild Scene: ‘Hey Comer, How Come You Haven’t Called for Impeachment?’
Click to see story on Mediaite
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move. – The Boston Globe
Click to see story on Boston Globe
Click to close
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on KRDO
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on KIFI
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Winnipeg Free Press
Republicans Reject Motion to Impeach Joe Biden
Click to see story on Newsweek
Major News Networks Take A Pass On Full Coverage Of Latest Joe Biden Impeachment Inquiry Hearing
Click to see story on Deadline
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on WPLG
Jay Ambrose: The test Biden can’t pass
Click to see story on Pioneer Press
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KCRA 3
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on WKMG
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Click on Detroit
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on San Diego Union Tribune
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WCVB
House GOP Impeachment Devolves Into Bickering
Click to see story on Political Wire
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WLWT
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WMUR
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WLKY
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WESH
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on Koco News5
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Helena Independent Record
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KETV
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WDSU
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WTAE
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WYFF
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Lincoln Journal Star
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KCCI
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KMBC
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WISN
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WBAL-TV
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WPTZ
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WMTW
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WVTM
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WAPT
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KOAT
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on The Columbian
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WPBF
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WGAL
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WXII
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KSBW
Republicans, Democrats argue over Biden impeachment
Click to see story on The Center Square
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on tribtoday.com
House panel members clash at latest Biden oversight hearing
Click to see story on Roll Call
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on WJCL
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on KHBS
US House panel holds Biden impeachment hearing, but next steps unclear
Click to see story on KSL
Click to close
Republicans’ second impeachment hearing to showcase Biden family ‘scam’ – Washington Examiner
Click to see story on Washington Examiner
US House panel holds Biden impeachment hearing, but next steps unclear
Click to see story on The Straits Times
Конгрессмен надел маску Путина на слушание по импичменту Байдена
Click to see story on RIA Novosti [🇷🇺-affiliated]
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on MY Northwest
Congressman came to the hearings on the impeachment of Bayden in Putin’s mask
Click to see story on Lenta.RU [🇷🇺-affiliated]
Six questions the Biden impeachment inquiry must still answer
Click to see story on justthenews.com
Click to close
Hunter Biden Hearing Grinds To A Halt After Ranking Democrat Threatens Bobulinski With Subpoena
Click to see story on The Daily Caller
House Republicans Push Forward With Impeachment Hearing Despite Hunter Biden Snub
Click to see story on The Epoch Times
Biden Impeachment: President To Get Invite For Testimony, GOP Chairman Says
Click to see story on The Daily Wire
‘Deeply Concerning’: Democratic Senator Opposes Biden Judicial Nominee Over Anti-Police Ties
Click to see story on Washington Free Beacon
Lackluster Impeachment Hearing With Biden Associates Could Signal Looming End to the Probe
Click to see story on The New York Sun
House Oversight Committee Hearing Examines ‘Joe Biden’s Abuse of Public Office’ › American Greatness
Click to see story on American Greatness
The World and Everything in It: March 20, 2024
Click to see story on wng.org
Will the Biden Impeachment Inquiry Bear Fruit Today?
Click to see story on discernreport.com
Former Hunter Biden associates to testify publicly in next phase of impeachment inquiry
Click to see story on Fox News
Biden Business Associate Devon Archer Refuses to Attend Impeachment Inquiry Hearing
Click to see story on Breitbart
Click to close
Far
Right
+0
Click to close
Untracked Bias
“U.S. Representatives” hold a new hearing on the impeachment of President Biden
Click to see story on الوطن
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroad. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on Airdrie City View
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads. As Hunter Biden declines to appear, GOP eyes next move
Click to see story on pantheonsite.io
Biden impeachment inquiry is at a crossroads as Hunter Biden declines to appear
Click to see story on mor-tv.com
Click to close
76 other sources covering this story
Total News Sources
76
Leaning Left
12
Center
44
Leaning Right
16
Last Updated
1 month ago
Unbiased news.
Directly to
your inbox.
Free!
MOST POPULAR
-
Harvey Weinstein’s rape conviction overturned, victims could see new trial
Watch 2:13
Thursday
-
Pythons decimate Florida’s wildlife, is eating them the answer?
Watch 2:04
Tuesday
-
Trump could lose Secret Service protection if found guilty
Watch 2:10
Tuesday
-
Argentina asks to join NATO as Milei looks to enhance security, strengthen ties
Watch 1:57
Apr 19