Commentary
-
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
A year ago, the world watched, stunned, during the disastrous withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan. The initiative, which started with the Trump Administration’s poorly thought-out Doha Agreement and knee-capped by Trump’s hollowing-out of the State Department, but was also unquestionably handled with profound incompetence by the Biden Administration, was a horror show from start to finish. With images of babies being hauled over walls at the Kabul Airport and desperate people falling to their deaths from airborne planes seared into our collective memory.
A year later, in part due to the understandable exhaustion that comes with a daily litany of Defcon-1 level hysteria courtesy of the news cycle, the “story” – which, let’s remember, is a matter of daily life for the Afghan people – is only intermittently headline news. So because a limited attention span when it comes to suffering isn’t a courtesy afforded to our fellow human beings, let’s look at where Afghanistan is now.
When the Taliban took over, more rapidly than I think anyone had anticipated, advances in human rights – specifically women’s rights – and media freedom were rolled back almost immediately. Millions of Afghans face severe and life-threatening food insecurity due to a loss of income paired with skyrocketing costs. A U.N. report of the 10 months following the withdrawal documented extrajudicial assassinations, torture, and dramatic cutbacks in free press, peaceful protest, and women’s and girls’ access to everything from education to mobility.
Is what’s happening to the Afghan people the responsibility of the United States government? In large part…yes. For two decades, administrations across aisles worked to create a tremendously aid-dependent Afghan state without seriously investing in a political infrastructure that would ensure ongoing peace.
And now we’re seeing the fallout of this failure. And to those who want to focus on the problems in America – America first – I do hear you. We are all battered, exhausted, we are just racked by fears of everything from economic insecurity to ever-escalating gun violence, and it’s easy to say, “Hey, what is happening over there is not my problem.”
All this is exacerbated by the fact that uncertainty exists with regards to how humanitarian funds will be allocated in the Taliban-ruled country, thereby disincentivizing US donors to provide aid. Is engaging with the regime legitimizing it, or even directly funding it?
It’s a fair question. And the answer to, “will some of the proffered aid fall into Taliban hands” is, unfortunately, yes. But the prevention of an even greater humanitarian catastrophe than the one that the Afghani people are facing now requires that we accept that efforts will inevitably involve some degree of liaising with the Taliban, as well as a reasonable degree of certainty that yes, some humanitarian aid – but, crucially, not all – will end up in Taliban control.
Is that a hard pill to swallow? Of course it is. And the July airstrike targeting al-Qaeda leader only underscores the ongoing terrorist threat posed to the United States. It makes sense to approach the issue of aid allocation with caution, and if you check out the links below this video, you’ll find a list of excellent organizations that are working with leaders inside the country to deliver aid to the people who desperately need it.
Importantly, though, “caution” doesn’t preclude action, and the moral and reputational consequences of abandoning those who have been endangered as a direct consequence of their support for the United States – as well as human beings suffering near-famine consequences through no fault of their own – are severe, and would only serve to further destabilize our standing in the international community.
It’s not a question of America first, or America second. It’s an intersectional issue – one that cannot, and must not, be sidelined.
-
It’s okay for Met Gala celebrities to avoid politics
During this year’s Met Gala, as some celebrities donned dramatic dresses made of sand or thousands of crystals, there was a noticeable absence of political statements. Some activists on social media responded with a campaign aimed at taking away the platform for celebrities who have refused to use their positions to speak up for people…
-
Why the Trump family is missing from court appearances
Former President Donald Trump is currently attending his Manhattan trial as a defendant facing 34 charges of falsifying business records. Despite this ongoing legal fight, sightings of his family have been rare at the proceedings. While his adult son Eric made one appearance, none of his other children, nor his third wife Melania, have been…
-
Careful Left, campus protests will end up benefiting Trump
Protests against the Israel-Hamas war have flared up at universities across the United States and around the world. Some universities resorted to calling the police to break up larger protests, leading to mass arrests at places like the University of Southern California and the use of tear gas in Florida, among others. At the University…
-
Portraying far-left and far-right as equal in ‘Civil War’ is wrong
The movie “Civil War,” which depicts Texas and California seceding from the nation to wage war on Washington, D.C., reflects a what-if scenario fueled by memories of the Jan. 6 Capitol attack. But as the presidential election looms, discussions about civil war have moved beyond theoretical debates to become a serious consideration among some voters.…
-
Why I doubt Trump will be convicted in hush money case
Donald Trump is the first former president to face trial on criminal charges. In the first of potentially four trials, Trump entered a plea of not guilty to 34 counts of falsifying business records. These charges stem from a $130,000 payment made to the adult actress and stripper Stormy Daniels, which aimed to keep her…
Latest Opinions
-
Ukraine launches major drone counter-attack on Russian sites
-
Honda will use Formula 1 technology in its upcoming EV lineup
-
‘Fake eyelashes,’ ‘butch body’: Insults fly in congressional hearing
-
Billionaires discuss how to shut down Columbia protests in group chat: Report
-
Congress launches probe of UCLA after violence on campus
Popular Opinions
-
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.