Judge says transgender player can stay in women’s volleyball tournament

Nov 26, 2024

Listen

Lauren Taylor Anchor/Reporter

By Lauren Taylor (Anchor/Reporter), Zachary Hill (Video Editor)

U.S. Magistrate Judge S. Kato Crews has denied requests to require a member of the San Jose State women’s volleyball team to sit out of an upcoming conference tournament over allegations that the player is transgender. The Mountain West Conference Women’s Championship is set to open the weekend of Nov. 30 in Las Vegas, Nevada.

Bias Distribution Powered by Ground News™

Nine current players in the conference filed a lawsuit arguing that allowing a transgender person to play on the women’s team was a safety risk and unfair. The plaintiffs also argue that Title IX bars transgender women from participating in women’s sports.

Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.

Point phone camera here

Crews’ ruling notes that the “alleged trans teammate” has been on San Jose State’s roster since 2022 and has played throughout the season.

San Jose State hasn’t confirmed whether a transgender student-athlete is a member of the women’s volleyball team. The player also hasn’t publicly discussed their identity.

However, in the ruling, Crews wrote, “No defendant disputed that SJSU rosters a trans woman volleyball player.”

Throughout the season, several opponents refused to play San Jose State and forfeited those games, granting the team six victories. The judge also declined the request to re-seed the tournament to exclude the forfeited losses.

In a statement, San Jose State University said it will “continue to support its student-athletes and reject discrimination in all forms,” adding that all athletes remain eligible under NCAA and conference rules.

“We are gratified that the court rejected an eleventh-hour attempt to change those rules. Our team looks forward to competing in the Mountain West Volleyball Tournament this week,” the statement read.

The plaintiffs said they plan to appeal the ruling.

The Independent Council on Women’s Sports is backing a separate lawsuit against the NCAA over its policy permitting transgender women to compete in women’s sports.

Tags: California, College Sports, Las Vegas, NCAA, Sports, Transgender

U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE S. KATO CREWS IN DENVER HAS DENIED REQUESTS TO REQUIRE A SAN JOSE STATE WOMEN’S VOLLEYBALL TEAM MEMBER TO SIT OUT OF AN UPCOMING CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT FOR ALLEGEDLY BEING TRANSGENDER. THE MOUNTAIN WEST CONFERENCE WOMEN’S CHAMPIONSHIP IS SET TO OPEN THIS WEEKEND IN LAS VEGAS.

NINE CURRENT PLAYERS IN THE CONFERENCE FILED A LAWSUIT ARGUING ALLOWING A TRANSGENDER PERSON TO PLAY ON THE WOMEN’S TEAM WAS A SAFETY RISK AND UNFAIR.

THE PLAINTIFFS ALSO SAY TITLE IX BARS TRANSGENDER WOMEN FROM PARTICIPATING IN WOMEN’S SPORTS.

CREWS’ RULING NOTES THE SAN JOSE STATE “ALLEGED TRANS TEAMMATE HAS BEEN ON ITS ROSTER SINCE 2022” AND HAS PLAYED ALL SEASON-LONG.

SAN JOSE STATE HAS NOT CONFIRMED IF THERE’S A TRANSGENDER STUDENT-ATHLETE IS A MEMBER OF THE WOMEN’S VOLLEYBALL TEAM AND THE PLAYER HAS NOT SPOKEN ABOUT THEIR IDENTITY.

IN THE RULING, THE JUDGE ALSO WROTE “NO DEFENDANT DISPUTED THAT SJSU ROSTERS A TRANS WOMAN VOLLEYBALL PLAYER.”

THROUGHOUT THE COURSE OF THIS SEASON, SEVERAL OPPONENTS REFUSED TO PLAY SAN JOSE STATE AND FORFEITED THOSE GAMES, GIVING SAN JOSE STATE SIX VICTORIES.

THE JUDGE ALSO DECLINED THE REQUEST TO RE-SEED THE TOURNAMENT WITHOUT THE FORFEITED LOSSES.

IN A STATEMENT, SAN JOSE STATE UNIVERSITY SAID IT WILL “CONTINUE TO SUPPORT ITS STUDENT-ATHLETES AND REJECT DISCRIMINATION IN ALL FORMS…” ADDING THAT ALL ATHLETES REMAIN ELIGIBLE UNDER NCAA AND CONFERENCE RULES. “WE ARE GRATIFIED THAT THE COURT REJECTED AN ELEVENTH-HOUR ATTEMPT TO CHANGE THOSE RULES. OUR TEAM LOOKS FORWARD TO COMPETING IN THE MOUNTAIN WEST VOLLEYBALL TOURNAMENT THIS WEEK.”

THE PLAINTIFFS SAID THEY PLAN TO APPEAL THE RULING.

THE INDEPENDENT COUNCIL ON WOMEN’S SPORTS IS BACKING A SEPARATE LAWSUIT AGAINST THE NCAA OVER ITS POLICY PERMITTING TRANSGENDER WOMEN TO COMPETE IN WOMEN’S SPORTS.