Most charges against anti-abortion activists dropped in video case
By Lauren Taylor (Anchor/Reporter), Zachary Hill (Video Editor)
Prosecutors have dropped the majority of charges against two anti-abortion activists who secretly recorded Planned Parenthood executives. In one of the videos, the activists allegedly discussed the harvesting and sale of aborted fetal tissue with a Planned Parenthood employee.
Media Landscape
This story is a Media Miss by the left as only 9% of the coverage is from left leaning media. Learn more about this dataBias Distribution
Left
California strikes plea deal in Planned Parenthood undercover video case
Click to see story on Washington ExaminerCA reaches plea agreement, no prison time, for pro-life activists’ for release of undercover videos
Click to see story on Just the NewsPro-life activist says California has ended ‘weaponized political prosecution’ begun by Kamala Harris on undercover videos
Click to see story on DNyuzCalif. drops all charges against David Daleiden, Sandra Merritt in Planned Parenthood undercover videos case
Click to see story on The Christian PostCalifornia Finally Drops Prosecution Of Journo Who Exposed Planned Parenthood With Damning Videos
Click to see story on The Daily WirePro-life activist says California has ended ‘weaponized political prosecution’ begun by Kamala Harris on undercover videos
Click to see story on The BlazeCA Ends Prosecution Of Pro-Lifers Who Found Aborted Baby Sales
Click to see story on The FederalistRemember the Undercover Journalists Who Exposed Planned Parenthood’s Fetal Body Parts Scandal? Well…
Click to see story on TownhallPro-Lifer Wins After 8-Year Prosecution for Exposing Planned Parenthood Sale of Baby Body Parts
Click to see story on CBNKamala Harris Suffers Major Defeat as Charges Against David Daleiden and Sandra Merritt Dismissed
Click to see story on LifeNews.comTrump DOJ says it will end ‘weaponization’ of FACE Act
Click to see story on Catholic News AgencyCalifornia Drops Prosecution Against Sandra Merritt, Who Exposed Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales
Click to see story on NOQ ReportCalifornia Drops Prosecution Against Sandra Merritt, Who Exposed Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales
Click to see story on America First ReportUndercover pro-life advocates reach California plea deal
Click to see story on wng.orgCalifornia ‘lawfare’ case against pro-lifers first brought by Kamala Harris ends after nine years
Click to see story on Fox NewsCalifornia to Dismiss Case Against Journalists Who Exposed Abortion Industry
Click to see story on BreitbartJudgment Day for reporter who helped catch abortionists trading in baby body parts * WorldNetDaily * by Bob Unruh
Click to see story on WNDCalifornia drops case against David Daleiden for exposing Planned Parenthood baby parts scandal
Click to see story on LifeSiteNewsState Of California Drops All Charges Against David Daleiden for Exposing Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales – No Charges Brought Against Planned Parenthood For Their Crimes
Click to see story on Sons of Liberty MediaCalifornia Drops Prosecution Against Sandra Merritt, Who Exposed Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales
Click to see story on Conservative PlaylistUntracked Bias
“Stop Pedophilia” Campaign. Important Supreme Court Decision
Click to see story on Do RzeczyCalifornia Drops Charges Against Pro-Life Journalists
Click to see story on UpstractSupreme Court dismisses cassation of LGBT activist from New Left over “Stop pedophilia” campaign
Click to see story on Pch24.plCalifornia Drops All Charges Against David Daleiden for Exposing Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales – Conservative Angle
Click to see story on Conservative AngleCalifornia to Dismiss Case Against Journalists Who Exposed Abortion Industry’s Fetal Body Parts Practices – altnews.org
Click to see story on altnews.orgCalifornia Ends Sandra Merritt Prosecution in Extraordinary Plea Deal – The Iowa Standard
Click to see story on The Iowa StandardLast Time!! Victory for Press Freedom! California Dismisses All Charges Against Journalists Provida – Gateway Hispanic
Click to see story on gatewayhispanic.comState Of California Drops All Charges Against David Daleiden for Exposing Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales – No Charges Brought Against Planned Parenthood For Their Crimes
Click to see story on The Washington StandardCalifornia Drops Prosecution Against Sandra Merritt, Who Exposed Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales
Click to see story on littlebytesnews.comCalifornia Finally Ends Prosecution Of Journo Who Exposed Planned Parenthood With Damning Videos
Click to see story on domigood.comCalifornia Drops Charges Against Pro-life Activists at Center of Undercover ‘Planned Parenthood Sells Baby Parts’ Videos
Click to see story on protestia.comCalifornia Drops All Charges Against David Daleiden and Sandra Merritt: A Triumph for Truth and Accountability – TheWatchTowers.org
Click to see story on thewatchtowers.orgThe case, which has been dragging through the court system since 2017, involved David Daleiden of the Center for Medical Progress and journalist Sandra Merritt. They posed as workers for a company that claimed to procure fetal tissue and met with Dr. Mary Gatter, the president of the Planned Parenthood Medical Directors’ Council, in February 2015.
Daleiden and Merritt secretly recorded a conversation with Dr. Gatter and released a video of it. However, Planned Parenthood says that the video is heavily edited and misleading. The organization also declined to comment on its authenticity.
Download the SAN app today to stay up-to-date with Unbiased. Straight Facts™.
Point phone camera here
In the video, Merritt asks Dr. Gatter, “What would you expect for intact tissue? What sort of compensation?”
“Well, why don’t you start by telling me what you’re used to paying?” Dr. Gatter responds.
“Okay, I don’t think so. I’d like to hear, I would like to know, what would make you happy? What would work for you?” Merritt asks.
“Well, you know in negotiations, the person who throws out the figure first is at a loss, right?” Dr. Gatter says.
Gatter also tells the activists at one point in the video that Planned Parenthood is “not in it for the money.”
Under U.S. law, the use of fetal tissue for research is legal as long as it meets all requirements. However, selling fetal tissue violates federal law. Researchers can legally reimburse providers for certain costs related to the preparation, transportation and storage of fetal tissue.
The recordings sparked outrage, especially among anti-abortion activists, who called for defunding Planned Parenthood.
Planned Parenthood executives denied selling fetal tissue for profit.
Following the release of the video, a spokesperson for the organization said, “What we see on this tape is a woman who says ‘We’re not in it for the money,’ and that any money must be related to reimbursement for costs.”
Several states, including Florida, Indiana, Georgia and Massachusetts, launched investigations into Planned Parenthood clinics. All found the organization to comply with state and federal laws regarding fetal tissue.
California’s then-attorney general, Kamala Harris, investigated Daleiden and Merritt after the videos were posted online in 2016. Harris was elected to the Senate later that year, and her successor, now former U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services Xavier Becerra, brought 15 felony charges related to the illegally obtained videos against Daleiden and Merritt.
Now, nearly a decade later, California Attorney General Rob Bonta has dropped most of the charges.
Daleiden and Merritt pleaded “no contest” to a single felony count of illegally recording someone without their consent.
Get up to speed on the stories leading the day every weekday morning. Sign up for the newsletter today!
Learn more about our emails. Unsubscribe anytime.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
In a statement posted on X, Daleiden said: “The state of California agreed to totally dismiss the unprecedented video recording case Kamala Harris brought against me 9 years ago, in exchange for my entering a new plea of ‘no contest’ on a single charge. The agreement involved no admission of wrongdoing, no fines, and no probation.”
Bonta also released a statement saying: “While the Trump administration is issuing pardons to individuals convicted of harming reproductive health clinics and providers, my office is securing criminal convictions to ensure that Californians can exercise their constitutional rights to reproductive healthcare. We will not hesitate to continue taking action against those who threaten access to abortion care — whether by recording confidential conversations or other means.”
PROSECUTORS DROPPED MAJORITY OF CHARGES AGAINST TWO ANTI-ABORTION ACTIVISTS WHO SECRETLY RECORDED PLANNED PARENTHOOD EXECUTIVES ALLEGEDLY TALKING ABOUT THE HARVESTING AND SALE OF ABORTED BABY PARTS.
THE CASE IS HAS BEEN DRAGGING THROUGH THE COURT SYSTEM SINCE 2017.
DAVID DALEIDEN WITH THE CENTER FOR MEDICAL PROGRESS AND JOURNALIST SANDRA MERRITT POSED AS WORKERS OF WHAT THEY CALLED A FETAL TISSUE PROCUREMENT COMPANY AND MET WITH THE PRESIDENT OF PLANNED PARENTHOOD MEDICAL DIRECTORS’ COUNCIL, DR. MARY GATTER IN FEBRUARY 2015.
THEY SECRETLY RECORDED A CONVERSATION WITH DR. GATTER.
“WHAT WOULD YOU EXPECT FOR IN TACT TISSUE? WHAT SORT OF COMPENSATION?” THE UNDERCOVER INVESTIGATOR ASKED DR. GATTER.
“WELL, WHY DON’T YOU START BY TELLING ME WHAT YOU’RE USED TO PAYING?” DR. GATTER RESPONDED.
“OKAY, I DON’T THINK SO. I’D LIKE TO HEAR, I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW, WHAT WOULD MAKE YOU HAPPY? WHAT WOULD WORK FOR YOU?” THE INVESTIGATOR ASKED.
“WELL YOU KNOW IN NEGITIATIONS THE PERSON WHO THROWS OUT THE FIGURE FIRST IS AT A LOSS, RIGHT?” DR. GATTER SAID LAUGHING.
UNDER U.S. LAW THE USE OF FETAL TISSUE FOR RESEARCH IS LEGAL AS LONG AS IT MEETS ALL REQUIREMENTS, HOWEVER, SELLING FETAL TISSUE GOES AGAINST FEDERAL LAW.
RESEARCHERS CAN ONLY LEGALLY REIMBURSE PROVIDERS FOR CERTAIN COSTS RELATED TO THE PREPARATION, TRANSPORT, AND STORAGE OF FETAL TISSUE.
THE RECORDINGS SPARKED OUTRAGE ESPECIALLY FROM ANTI-ABORTION ACTIVISTS WHO CALLED FOR DEFUNDING PLANNED PARENTHOOD.
PLANNED PARENTHOOD EXECUTIVES DENIED SELLING FETAL TISSUE FOR PROFIT.
SEVERAL STATES ALSO LAUNCHED INVESTIGATIONS INTO THEIR PLANNED PARENTHOOD CLINICS. SEVERAL– INCLUDING FLORIDA, INDIANA, GEORGIA AND MASSACHUSSETS ALL FOUND PLANNED PARENTHOOD TO BE IN COMPLIANCE WITH STATE AND FEDERAL LAWS CONCERNING FETAL TISSUE.
CALIFORNIA’S THEN ATTORNEY GENERAL – NOW FORMER VICE PRESIDENT KAMALA HARRIS – BROUGHT AN INVESTIGATION INTO DALEIDEN AND MERRITT AFTER THE VIDEOS WERE POSTED ONLINE IN 2016.
HARRIS WAS ELECTED TO THE SENATE LATER THAT YEAR AND HER SUCCESSOR, NOW FORMER SECRETARY OF U.S. HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES, XAVIER BECERRA, BROUGHT 15 FELONIES ALL RELATED TO THE ILLEGALLY OBTAINED VIDEOS AGAINST DALEIDEN AND MERRITT.
NOW NEARLY A DECADE LATER CALIFORNIA’S ATTORNEY GENERAL ROB BONTA DROPPED MOST OF THE CHARGES.
DALEIDEN AND MERRITT PLEADED “NO CONTEST” SO ONE FELONY COUNT OF ILLEGALLY RECORDING SOMEONE WITHOUT THEIR CONSENT.
IN A STATEMENT POSTED ON X, DALEIDEN SAID “THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA AGREED TO TOTALLY DISMISS THE UNPRECEDENTED VIDEO RECORDING CASE KAMALA HARRIS BROUGHT AGAINST ME 9 YEARS AGO, IN EXCHANGE FOR MY ENTERING A NEW PLEA OF “NO CONTEST” ON A SINGLE CHARGE. THE AGREEMENT INVOLVED NO ADMISSION OF WRONGDOING, NO FINES, AND NO PROBATION.”
CALIFORNIA ATTORNEY GENERAL BONTA RELEASED A STATEMENT SAYING: “WHILE THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION IS ISSUING PARDONS TO INDIVIDUALS CONVICTED OF HARMING REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CLINICS AND PROVIDERS, MY OFFICE IS SECURING CRIMINAL CONVICTIONS TO ENSURE THAT CALIFORNIANS CAN EXERCISE THEIR CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS TO REPRODUCTIVE HEALTHCARE. WE WILL NOT HESITATE TO CONTINUE TAKING ACTION AGAINST THOSE WHO THREATEN ACCESS TO ABORTION CARE — WHETHER BY RECORDING CONFIDENTIAL CONVERSATIONS OR OTHER MEANS.”
Media Landscape
This story is a Media Miss by the left as only 9% of the coverage is from left leaning media. Learn more about this dataBias Distribution
Left
California strikes plea deal in Planned Parenthood undercover video case
Click to see story on Washington ExaminerCA reaches plea agreement, no prison time, for pro-life activists’ for release of undercover videos
Click to see story on Just the NewsPro-life activist says California has ended ‘weaponized political prosecution’ begun by Kamala Harris on undercover videos
Click to see story on DNyuzCalif. drops all charges against David Daleiden, Sandra Merritt in Planned Parenthood undercover videos case
Click to see story on The Christian PostCalifornia Finally Drops Prosecution Of Journo Who Exposed Planned Parenthood With Damning Videos
Click to see story on The Daily WirePro-life activist says California has ended ‘weaponized political prosecution’ begun by Kamala Harris on undercover videos
Click to see story on The BlazeCA Ends Prosecution Of Pro-Lifers Who Found Aborted Baby Sales
Click to see story on The FederalistRemember the Undercover Journalists Who Exposed Planned Parenthood’s Fetal Body Parts Scandal? Well…
Click to see story on TownhallPro-Lifer Wins After 8-Year Prosecution for Exposing Planned Parenthood Sale of Baby Body Parts
Click to see story on CBNKamala Harris Suffers Major Defeat as Charges Against David Daleiden and Sandra Merritt Dismissed
Click to see story on LifeNews.comTrump DOJ says it will end ‘weaponization’ of FACE Act
Click to see story on Catholic News AgencyCalifornia Drops Prosecution Against Sandra Merritt, Who Exposed Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales
Click to see story on NOQ ReportCalifornia Drops Prosecution Against Sandra Merritt, Who Exposed Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales
Click to see story on America First ReportUndercover pro-life advocates reach California plea deal
Click to see story on wng.orgCalifornia ‘lawfare’ case against pro-lifers first brought by Kamala Harris ends after nine years
Click to see story on Fox NewsCalifornia to Dismiss Case Against Journalists Who Exposed Abortion Industry
Click to see story on BreitbartJudgment Day for reporter who helped catch abortionists trading in baby body parts * WorldNetDaily * by Bob Unruh
Click to see story on WNDCalifornia drops case against David Daleiden for exposing Planned Parenthood baby parts scandal
Click to see story on LifeSiteNewsState Of California Drops All Charges Against David Daleiden for Exposing Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales – No Charges Brought Against Planned Parenthood For Their Crimes
Click to see story on Sons of Liberty MediaCalifornia Drops Prosecution Against Sandra Merritt, Who Exposed Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales
Click to see story on Conservative PlaylistUntracked Bias
“Stop Pedophilia” Campaign. Important Supreme Court Decision
Click to see story on Do RzeczyCalifornia Drops Charges Against Pro-Life Journalists
Click to see story on UpstractSupreme Court dismisses cassation of LGBT activist from New Left over “Stop pedophilia” campaign
Click to see story on Pch24.plCalifornia Drops All Charges Against David Daleiden for Exposing Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales – Conservative Angle
Click to see story on Conservative AngleCalifornia to Dismiss Case Against Journalists Who Exposed Abortion Industry’s Fetal Body Parts Practices – altnews.org
Click to see story on altnews.orgCalifornia Ends Sandra Merritt Prosecution in Extraordinary Plea Deal – The Iowa Standard
Click to see story on The Iowa StandardLast Time!! Victory for Press Freedom! California Dismisses All Charges Against Journalists Provida – Gateway Hispanic
Click to see story on gatewayhispanic.comState Of California Drops All Charges Against David Daleiden for Exposing Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales – No Charges Brought Against Planned Parenthood For Their Crimes
Click to see story on The Washington StandardCalifornia Drops Prosecution Against Sandra Merritt, Who Exposed Planned Parenthood Aborted Baby Part Sales
Click to see story on littlebytesnews.comCalifornia Finally Ends Prosecution Of Journo Who Exposed Planned Parenthood With Damning Videos
Click to see story on domigood.comCalifornia Drops Charges Against Pro-life Activists at Center of Undercover ‘Planned Parenthood Sells Baby Parts’ Videos
Click to see story on protestia.comCalifornia Drops All Charges Against David Daleiden and Sandra Merritt: A Triumph for Truth and Accountability – TheWatchTowers.org
Click to see story on thewatchtowers.orgStraight to your inbox.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
MOST POPULAR
-
Bodies recovered after passenger jet, Army helicopter collide
Watch 10:165 hrs ago -
Trump says Reagan plane crash should have been prevented
Watch 3:1010 hrs ago -
Sen. Tim Kaine said Reagan Airport is dangerous, warned of collision
Watch 3:1012 hrs ago -
Commercial plane and military helicopter collide at Reagan Airport in DC
Watch 3:1013 hrs ago