New Amnesty International report accuses Israel of genocide in Gaza

KARAH RUCKER: Amnesty International is now the first major international human rights organization to accuse Israel of genocide for its military actions in Gaza.

It’s an accusation that lawyers consider to be one of the most difficult to prosecute … requiring proof the acts were done with intent to destroy a group, in whole or in part.

Israel and the United States both deny that Israel’s actions constitute genocide.

Israel launched its mission in Gaza in response to the Hamas attacks on October 7th, where fighters killed nearly 12-hundred people in Israel.

Amnesty International published a nearly-300-page report detailing the evidence it reviewed before making the accusation. It’s based on nine months of reporting and research … including interviews with more than 200 people on the ground. They say Israel did not provide substantive answers to letters it sent over the span of nearly a year.

They reviewed 15 Israeli air strikes on civilian targets that killed more than 300 people and found no evidence Israel was aiming to achieve any military goal with those strikes. Amnesty International said “they are indicative of a pattern of repeated direct or indiscriminate attacks by the Israeli military in Gaza.”

The report found Israel responsible for food scarcity and the spread of diseases including hepatitis A and polio in Gaza, concluding that it showed intent to destroy the Palestinians.

They based their conclusion on Israel’s attacks on civilian infrastructure in Gaza, its repeated orders forcing hundreds of thousands of people out of the areas where they live, and the Israeli government blocking aid from moving into and across Gaza.

Amnesty International cites statements from some of Israel’s top officials as proof of intent on Israel’s part .. including Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich calling Palestinians the people of Amalek. That’s a reference to a Biblical story the report says soldiers and settlers would understand as a call for the destruction of Palestinians in Gaza.

In a post on LinkedIn, Amnesty International’s Deputy Secretary General acknowledged there would be criticism of their report, saying “We will be challenged. We will be criticized. We will be called anti-Semitic. It’s hard to describe as genocidal a state formed following another genocide. I hope us speaking out will create spaces for others to do so.”

Criticism even came from *within* the organization. A report by The Times of Israel says the Israeli chapter of Amnesty International broke with its parent group … saying that while they’re worried Israel has perpetrated “serious crimes” in Gaza, a majority of its members find the report doesn’t do enough to prove the claim of genocide.

An Israeli government spokesperson laid out their reasons for disagreeing with the report, including Hamas and Iran’s history of calling for the destruction of Israel and the aid that Israel *has* allowed into Gaza.

DAVID MENCER // Israeli Government Spokesperson:“’Genocide’, they cry about Israel. They distort reality and downplay the clear intent of Hamas to annihilate Israel. Just listen to what Hamas and Iran say.” // “Amnesty’s claims lack credible, verifiable evidence and omits Israel’s humanitarian measures. 1,166,000 tonnes of aid have gone into Gaza since the start of this war.” // “Amnesty manipulates international law to falsely portray legitimate self-defence as genocide.”

KARAH RUCKER: The report also came up in the U.S. at Thursday’s State Department press briefing. Here’s what a State Department spokesperson had to say.

VEDANT PATEL // U.S. State Department Spokesperson: “We disagree with the conclusions of such a report. We have said previously and continue to find that the allegations of genocide are unfounded.” // “And we continue to stress at every turn that there is a moral and strategic priority for Israel to comply with international humanitarian law. And that is something we’re going to continue to raise with partners in the region and directly with Israel.”

KARAH RUCKER: The International Court of Justice is still weighing a genocide claim South Africa filed against Israel last year.

And separately, the International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants last month for Israel’s Prime Minister Netanyahu and Defense Minister Yoav Gallant on charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity. 

The ICC can bring charges of genocide but is not currently charging any Israeli officials with doing so.

For Straight Arrow News, I’m Karah Rucker.

And for all the latest updates on this and other top stories, download the Straight Arrow News app.