data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a5339/a5339f3a15bd28a4327c01592dcd3b563dc3dd8f" alt="Microsoft's new unlimited time off policy sounds great, but the pressure to keep up with work may create new pressure for employees."
Commentary
-
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
Last week, Microsoft changed its company policy to give salaried employees unlimited – or “discretionary” paid time off, allowing them to create, in their words, a more flexible work environment, where employees are able to work when and where they choose…so long as they get the work done.
This policy is an addition to “regular” time off for sick days, mental health days, jury duty, and so forth.
Which sounds great. Truly. I was the sole earner for our family when my kids were younger and my ex-husband was living part-time in another state where he went to school – and to this day, I honestly cannot wrap my mind around how mothers with inflexible jobs do it.
As an aside, I will double down forever on the very different expectations our society has when it comes to a mother’s responsibilities versus a father’s – so while this emphasis on flexibility obviously benefits everyone, I’m going to give the win to working moms.
But, as always, it’s not that simple. No, we can’t have nice things.
Because the announcement of the new policy came almost simultaneously with the company’s decision to lay off 10,000 workers, creating a situation where the remaining employees have an increased workload…and are also viscerally aware of their replaceability.
So personally, even though I was the sole earner in our household for two years while my ex-husband went to school, I found it very, very hard to take any true time off.
Because I technically *could* get everything done by working around the clock – whether I was working on actual work, or on the much less culturally-valuable work of keeping tiny humans alive – I felt intense pressure to do just that. Focus 100% of my attention on my family – forget about relaxation – when I’m on vacation? Are you kidding me? That’s not how you prove yourself.
The thing about this seemingly excellent policy is that employees are – understandably – skeptical about it. A number of studies have found that employees with an unlimited PTO policy actually took less time off, on average, than employees with a set amount of vacation days.
And the effectiveness of the policy still depends to a large extent on the specific corporate culture.
Some managers will encourage employees to take advantage of DTO, while others will telegraph their displeasure in ways that range from uncomfortable (“Jeez, this is really a crunch time for us…”) to punitive – for example, giving preferred projects to an employee who’s able to be at the office more consistently. Which swings that sexual, gender and racial bias door wiiiiide open.
When deployed correctly, discretionary time off can enhance productivity, employee retention, and trust between employees and managers. It’s a good thing, in theory. We just have to take care with its actual practice.
-
RFK Jr.’s war on psychiatric meds risks decades of progress
On Feb. 18, during his first meeting with staff, Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. stated that he intends to address the possible overmedication of children and the risks of antidepressants — echoing a Trump executive order aimed at reducing childhood chronic disease rates. The order has sparked concerns over youth access… -
Loss of USAID makes America and the world less safe
Elon Musk and President Trump shocked the U.S. foreign policy community and America’s partners around the world with the early and abrupt closure of USAID, the United States Agency for International Development. USAID was a cornerstone of U.S. foreign policy and consistently received bipartisan support from Congress. Experts warned that the decision puts millions of… -
Trump’s ‘Gulf of America’ renaming is mere political spectacle
Aboard Air Force One, en route to the Super Bowl in New Orleans, President Trump held a news conference. As the flight entered international waters over the Gulf of Mexico, he issued an executive order renaming it the “Gulf of America” and declaring Feb. 9 as “Gulf of America Day.” The order, titled Restoring Names… -
President Trump politicizes DC plane crash as Americans mourn
Sixty-seven people died when a Black Hawk helicopter crashed into American Airlines Flight 5342 as it came in for a landing at Reagan National Airport on the night of Jan. 29 outside of Washington, D.C. Investigators are still examining the accident and putting details together, but believe that the helicopter was flying at too high… -
Project 2025 is Trumpism on steroids
President Trump has already taken several actions that align with Project 2025, a far-right blueprint for Trump’s second term developed by the Heritage Foundation. Among other intiatives, his administration has moved to eliminate DEI programs, reinstate service members dismissed for refusing the COVID-19 vaccine, and revive “Schedule F,” a policy making it easier to fire…
Latest Opinions
-
Getty Images
San Francisco DA Charges 11 in SNAP fraud scheme involving $4M
-
Getty Images
California’s minimum wage increase led to job losses, higher prices: Study
-
Getty Images
Appeals court blocks Arizona’s proof of citizenship law, cites voter suppression
-
Getty Images
‘The free world needs a new leader’: Trump-Zelenskyy make jaws drop
-
Getty Images
Justin Timberlake cancels final US show in Columbus minutes before showtime
Popular Opinions
-
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.