Skip to main content
U.S.

Justice Sotomayor’s staff pushed her book sales, raising ethics questions

Media Landscape

See who else is reporting on this story and which side of the political spectrum they lean. To read other sources, click on the plus signs below. Learn more about this data
Left 43% Center 33% Right 24%
Bias Distribution Powered by Ground News

Another Supreme Court justice is being scrutinized over how they make money off the bench. An investigation by The Associated Press reveals Justice Sonia Sotomayor has made millions of dollars from the books she has written. The scrutiny surrounds how those books were sold.

According to the AP, Sotomayor’s staff pushed colleges, universities and libraries to buy her books in bulk for guest signings and speeches. The allegation brings into question what is considered ethical behavior by a Supreme Court justice. 

Sotomayor is the latest member of the high court to be investigated for questionable ethics decisions that critics blame on a lack of restriction.

According to the investigation, Sotomayor’s court staffers were found to be deeply involved in helping the justice promote her literary career by organizing speaking engagements that sold her books for personal financial gain. This is typically prohibited for members of Congress and other government officials, but is not for members of the Supreme Court

Through 100 public record requests, The Associated Press found that Sotomayor’s staffers repeatedly pressed event planners and businesses to purchase more books before an engagement for a higher pre-order. 

In 2019, staffers told a Portland library that the 250 books it ordered wouldn’t be enough. They suggested the library purchase 1,000 copies of her children’s book “Just Ask!”. 

Similar incidents took place before speaking engagements at the University of California and the University of Wisconsin. According to the AP, staffers suggested to school officials that they order Sotomayor books that could be sold at the event. 

In 2017 at Clemson University, officials offered to buy 60 signed copies ahead of an appearance by the justice, but they were told by Sotomayor staffers that most schools order around 400. And in 2018, Michigan State spent more than $100,000 on signed Sotomayor books. 

The Associated Press said it reached out to the Supreme Court to question whether the book sales were ethically sound. The high court responded “yes.”

“Judicial ethics guidance suggests that a judge may sign copies of his or her work, which may also be available for sale, but there should be no requirement or suggestion that attendees are required to purchase books in order to attend. Asking whether attendees were reminded that they must either buy or bring a book in order to enter a signing line at an event would in no way conflict with the standard outlined above,” the answer from the Supreme Court stated. 

The Associated Press said it wasn’t just Sotomayor who leveraged publicly sponsored travel to boost book sales, but it said her staff was more forceful and successful than others. The ethical standards of Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito have also been scrutinized in recent reports.

Tags: , , ,

KARAH RUCKER: THE SPOTLIGHT CONTINUES TO HOVER OVER SUPREME COURT JUSTICES AND WHAT CONSTITUTES AS ETHICAL BEHAVIOR FROM THE BENCH. AN INVESTIGATION BY THE ASSOCIATED PRESS REVEALS SUPREME COURT JUSTICE SONIA SOTOMAYOR HAS MADE MILLIONS OF DOLLARS FROM BOOKS SHE HAS WRITTEN –AT LEAST IN PART DUE TO HER STAFF PUSHING COLLEGES, UNIVERSITIES, AND LIBRARIES TO BUY HER BOOKS IN BULK FOR GUEST SIGNINGS AND SPEECHES.

 

SOTOMAYOR IS JUST THE LATEST MEMBER OF THE HIGH COURT TO HAVE A LAYER OF HER HISTORY PEELED BACK BY THE MEDIA –WITH BOTH CONSERVATIVE AND LIBERAL JUSTICES BEING LOOKED INTO FOR ANY QUESTIONABLE ETHICS DECISIONS THEY’VE BEEN LEGALLY ALLOWED TO MAKE BECAUSE OF WHAT CRITICS CALL A LACK OF RESTRICTION.

 

SOTOMAYOR’S COURT STAFF IS TAXPAYER FUNDED –AND WAS FOUND HELPING THE JUSTICE’S PERSONAL BOOK VENTURES BY PROMOTING HER LITERARY CAREER.

ACCORDING TO AP –STAFFERS WERE FOUND TO BE DEEPLY INVOLVED IN ORGANIZING SPEAKING ENGAGEMENTS INTENDED TO SELL BOOKS FOR PERSONAL FINANCIAL GAIN.

 

SOMETHING THAT IS TYPICALLY PROHIBITED  FOR MEMBERS OF CONGRESS AND OTHER GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS –YET IT IS NOT FOR THE HIGH COURT.

 

HERE’S SOME OF WHAT THE ASSOCIATED PRESS UNCOVERED THROUGH MORE THAN 100 PUBLIC RECORD REQUESTS.

 

IN 2019 – SOTOMAYOR WAS PROMOTING A NEW CHILDREN’S BOOK “JUST ASK!”.

A PORTLAND COMMUNITY COLLEGE  AND LIBRARY BOOKED THE JUSTICE TO HOST AN EVENT.

 

SOTOMAYOR STAFFERS EMAILED THE LIBRARY AS THE EVENT NEARED –

CONCERNED THE HOSTING PARTY DIDN’T ORDER ENOUGH OF HER BOOKS.

QUOTE – “FOR AN EVENT WITH 1,000 PEOPLE AND THEY HAVE TO HAVE A COPY OF JUST ASK TO GET INTO THE LINE, 250 BOOKS IS DEFINITELY NOT ENOUGH. FAMILIES PURCHASE MULTIPLES AND PEOPLE WILL BE UPSET IF THEY ARE UNABLE TO GET IN LINE BECAUSE THE BOOK REQUIRED IS SOLD OUT.”

 

THIS WASN’T AN ISOLATED PUSH FOR A HIGHER PRE-ORDER.

AT THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA –SOTOMAYOR WAS TO GIVE A COMMENCEMENT SPEECH. HER STAFF – SUGGESTED THE SCHOOL BUY COPIES OF SIGNED BOOKS IN CONNECTION WITH THE EVENT.

 

BEFORE VISITING THE UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN – STAFF ALSO SUGGESTED A BOOK SIGNING EVENT. IN 2017 AT CLEMSON UNIVERSITY – SCHOOL OFFICIALS OFFERED TO BUY 60 SIGNED COPIES AHEAD OF AN APPEARANCE BY THE JUSTICE –

HER STAFF SUGGESTED MOST SCHOOLS ORDER AROUND 400.

 

IN 2018 – MICHIGAN STATE SPENT MORE THAN 100 THOUSAND DOLLARS ON SIGNED BOOKS. THE ASSOCIATED PRESS REACHED OUT TO THE SUPREME COURT –

QUESTIONING WHETHER THIS WAS ETHICALLY OKAY. TO WHICH THEY RESPONDED – YES.

 

 “JUDICIAL ETHICS GUIDANCE SUGGESTS THAT A JUDGE MAY SIGN COPIES OF HIS OR HER WORK, WHICH MAY ALSO BE AVAILABLE FOR SALE, BUT THERE SHOULD BE NO REQUIREMENT OR SUGGESTION THAT ATTENDEES ARE REQUIRED TO PURCHASE BOOKS IN ORDER TO ATTEND. ASKING WHETHER ATTENDEES WERE REMINDED THAT THEY MUST EITHER BUY OR BRING A BOOK IN ORDER TO ENTER A SIGNING LINE AT AN EVENT WOULD IN NO WAY CONFLICT WITH THE STANDARD OUTLINED ABOVE.”

 

THE ASSOCIATED PRESS SAID IT WASN’T JUST SOTOMAYOR WHO LEVERAGED PUBLICLY SPONSORED TRAVEL TO BOOST BOOK SALES. BUT SAID SOTOMAYOR’S STAFF – WAS MOST “FORCEFUL” –AND MOST “SUCCESSFUL.” SOTOMAYOR JOINS JUSTICES CLARENCE THOMAS AND SAMUEL ALITO IN RECENT EXPOSES –

LOOKING AT THE ETHICAL STANDARDS FOR SUPREME COURT JUSTICES