Kansas is the latest state to join a growing list of attorneys general suing the Department of Commerce over the Census Bureau’s inclusion of noncitizens in its population count. Louisiana, Ohio, West Virginia and now Kansas are all challenging the agency’s decision to count immigrants regardless of citizenship status.
4 states join lawsuit against Census Bureau
The census follows the Residence Rule, which counts people based on where they live or sleep most of the time. However, all four states want that rule thrown out.
Point phone camera here
The lawsuit argues immigrants living in the U.S., regardless of whether they’re in the country illegally or have a lawful temporary visa, are being counted in the census. The attorneys general say this practice inflates population numbers. They say, in turn, it impacts the allocation of Congressional seats and Electoral College votes.
The lawsuit highlights how the Residence Rule affected states like Ohio and West Virginia. It says both states lost a Congressional seat, while states with larger noncitizen populations gained seats.
The lawsuit cites Pew Research data that suggests immigrants living illegally in the U.S. made up about 1% of Ohio’s population, less than 3% in Kansas, 1.5% in Louisiana, and about 0.3% in West Virginia.
However, in California, immigrants lacking proper documentation made up nearly 5% of the state’s population, which the lawsuit claims is the highest in the nation.
Census in the U.S. Constitution
The U.S. Constitution mandates that the federal government conduct a census every 10 years and that individuals should be counted regardless of citizenship status. The next U.S. census is scheduled for 2030. The attorneys general argue that including noncitizens violates the 14th Amendment, which guarantees equal representation for U.S. citizens.
Get up to speed on the stories leading the day every weekday morning. Sign up for the newsletter today!
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
Census impacts federal funding for states
Additionally, the lawsuit claims states like Texas and California received more federal funding due to the census numbers. The attorneys general argue noncitizens, who often cannot access these funds, helped allocate money they’re ineligible to use.
Advocates, such as the Latino Community Network, stress the importance of the census in determining vital resources like housing and emergency services. They say an undercount could lead to misallocation of federal funds when and where they are needed most.
Tags: Census, Election, Electoral College, Immigrant, Immigration, Kansas, Louisiana, Ohio, U.S. Census Bureau, United States, West Virginia
[Lauren Taylor]
KANSAS IS THE LATEST STATE TO JOIN THE LIST OF ATTORNEYS GENERAL TAKING THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE TO COURT OVER ONE OF ITS AGENCIES.
LOUISIANA, OHIO, WEST VIRGINIA AND NOW KANSAS WANT THE CENSUS BUREAU TO STOP ADDING NONCITIZENS TO AMERICA’S POPULATION TOTAL.
ACCORDING TO THE CENSUS, THE AGENCY RELIES ON THE RESIDENCE RULE WHICH COUNTS WHERE PEOPLE LIVE OR SPEND MOST OF THEIR TIME–BUT ALL STATES WANT IT THROWN OUT.
THE LAWSUIT SAYS IMMIGRANTS LIVING IN THE U-S ARE COUNTED IN THE CENSUS REGARDLESS IF THEY ARE IN THE COUNTRY ILLEGALLY OR HAVE A TEMPORARY VISA UNDER THE RESIDENCE RULE.
THE FOUR ATTORNEYS GENERAL SAY THE 2020 CENSUS INFLATED NUMBERS BY INCLUDING ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS—IMPACTING THE ELECTORAL COLLEGE AND THE NUMBER OF VOTES EACH STATE GETS BASED ON ITS POPULATION SIZE.
THE LAWSUIT POINTS TO STATES LIKE OHIO AND WEST VIRGINIA, WHERE EACH LOST A CONGRESSIONAL SEAT, WHILE STATES WITH LARGER NONCITIZEN POPULATIONS GAINED SEATS.
NUMBERS FROM PEW RESEARCH SHOW IMMIGRANTS LIVING IN THE U-S ILLEGALLY MADE UP ONE PERCENT OF OHIO’S POPULATON–LESS THAN THREE PERCENT IN KANSAS, ONE POINT FIVE PERCENT IN LOUISIANA AND ABOUT POINT THREE IN WEST VIRGINIA.
BUT IN CALIFORNIA ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS MADE UP CLOSE TO 5 PERCENT OF THEIR POPULATION–THE LAWSUIT SAYS ITS THE NATIONS HIGHEST.
THE CENSUS IS WRITTEN INTO THE CONSTITUTION—REQUIRING THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TO CONDUCT ONE EVERY TEN YEARS, REGARDLESS OF CITIZENSHIP STATUS.
THE ATTORNEYS GENERAL ARGUE THAT COUNTING NONCITIZENS IS BLOCKING PROPER REPRESENTATION, BOTH POLITICALLY AND WITH RESOURCES—PLUS IT VIOLATES THE 14TH AMENDMENT.
THEY ALSO SAY TEXAS AND CALIFORNIA RECEIVED MORE FEDERAL MONEY BECAUSE OF THE CENSUS, INCLUDING FUNDS NONCITIZENS—WHO CAN’T USE THEM—HELPED ALLOCATE.
THE LATINO COMMUNITY NETWORK SAYS THE CENSUS IS VITAL IN DETERMINING RESOURCES INCLUDING WHERE MORE HOUSING IS NEEDED OR WHERE ADDITIONAL FIREFIGHTERS NEED TO BE ALLOCATED–SO UNDERCOUNTS WILL AFFECT FUNDING WHEN ITS TIME TO DISTRIBUTE.
THE NEXT CENSUS IS SCHEDULED FOR 2030.
FOR STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS, I’M LAUREN TAYLOR
Straight to your inbox.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
