Stanford Law to hold mandatory ‘free speech’ session after protest: Media Miss

Mar 23, 2023

Shannon Longworth Reporter

By Shannon Longworth (Reporter), Ben Burke (Producer)

Stanford Law School students will be required to participate in a half-day session in the spring quarter to educate them on freedom of speech and the “norms of the legal profession.” Dean Jenny S. Martinez announced the move in an open letter on Wednesday, weeks after students and an associate dean disrupted a federal judge’s address earlier this month.

The school’s chapter of the conservative Federalist Society hosted the disrupted event and invited Stuart Kyle Duncan, a federal judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, as a guest speaker. Kyle Duncan was appointed by former President Trump. In 2022, Kyle Duncan joined an unsigned opinion stating that the COVID-19 vaccine requirement violated Navy service members’ religious liberties.

When he attempted to speak at Stanford Law School, students interrupted him, and the school’s associate dean for diversity, equity, and inclusion, Tirien Steinbach, took the microphone to voice her thoughts.

“For many people in this law school who work here, who study here and who live here, your advocacy, your opinions from the bench, land as absolute disenfranchisement of their rights,” Steinbach said in video of the incident.

In the open letter, Martinez said Steinbach is now on leave and that “commitment to diversity and inclusion means that we must protect the expression of all views.” Martinez acknowledged the school’s policy that “protest is allowed but disruption is not,” and said faculty will receive additional training.

Straight Arrow News aims to identify when stories are being underreported on either side of the political aisle and media landscape. This story is a Media Miss for left-leaning outlets, with most sources reporting it being either right-leaning or center-oriented outlets, according to Ground.News.

Tags: COVID-19, Free Speech, Media Miss, Protests, Stanford University

SHANNON LONGWORTH: STUDENTS AT STANFORD LAW ARE GETTING A LESSON IN FREE SPEECH. A HALF-DAY SESSION IN THE SPRING QUARTER TO EDUCATE ON THE FIRST AMENDMENT AND THE “NORMS OF THE LEGAL PROFESSION.”

IT’S MANDATORY, AFTER STUDENTS AND AN ASSOCIATE DEAN INTERRUPTED A FEDERAL JUDGE’S ADDRESS EARLIER THIS MONTH.

THE SCHOOL’S CHAPTER OF THE CONSERVATIVE FEDERALIST SOCIETY HOSTED THE EVENT AND INVITED JUDGE STUART KYLE DUNCAN TO BE A GUEST SPEAKER.

KYLE DUNCAN IS A FEDERAL JUDGE ON THE US COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT, WHICH IS CONSIDERED THE MOST CONSERVATIVE FEDERAL APPEALS COURT IN THE COUNTRY. HE WAS APPOINTED BY PRESIDENT TRUMP, AND IN 2022 MADE WAVES WHEN HE JOINED AN UNSIGNED OPINION THAT AGREED THE COVID-19 VACCINE REQUIREMENT VIOLATED NAVY SERVICE MEMBERS’ RELIGIOUS LIBERTIES.

WHEN HE ATTEMPTED TO SPEAK AT STANFORD LAW SCHOOL, STUDENTS INTERRUPTED AND THE SCHOOL’S ASSOCIATE DEAN FOR DIVERSITY, EQUITY, AND INCLUSION, TIRIEN STEINBACH, TOOK THE MICROPHONE TO VOICE HER THOUGHTS.

TIRIEN STEINBACH: “FOR MANY PEOPLE IN THIS LAW SCHOOL WHO WORK HERE, WHO STUDY HERE AND WHO LIVE HERE, YOUR ADVOCACY, YOUR OPINIONS FROM THE BENCH, LAND AS ABSOLUTE DISENFRANCHISEMENT OF THEIR RIGHTS.” *SHOUTING*

LONGWORTH: THE LAW SCHOOL’S DEAN, JENNY MARTINEZ, SAID IN A PUBLIC LETTER ON WEDNESDAY THAT STEINBACH IS NOW ON LEAVE, AND “COMMITMENT TO DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION MEANS THAT WE MUST PROTECT THE EXPRESSION OF ALL VIEWS.” MARTINEZ ACKNOWLEDGED THE SCHOOL’S POLICY THAT “PROTEST IS ALLOWED BUT DISRUPTION IS NOT,” AND SAID FACULTY WILL RECEIVE ADDITIONAL TRAINING.

THIS STORY IS A MEDIA MISS, AS IT’S BEEN UNDERREPORTED BY LEFT-LEANING OUTLETS. AT STRAIGHT ARROW NEWS, WE WORK TO BRING YOU A VARIETY OF STORIES WITH THE CONTEXT YOU NEED.