A judge sentenced a Milwaukee woman to 11 years in prison for the death of a man she said raped and sexually trafficked her as a teenager. The controversial case drew national attention for years.
Chrystul Kizer, now 24, pleaded guilty in May 2024 to reckless homicide in the 2018 killing of 34-year-old Randall Volar. At the time of the incident, Kizer was 17.
Point phone camera here
Kizer’s defense attorney stated that Volar contacted Kizer when she was 16 after she posted an online ad for prostitution. The attorney said Kizer turned to the site out of desperation to support her siblings.
When Kizer and Volar met, Volar was under investigation for sexual conduct with underage girls as young as 12. Police later discovered evidence of abuse involving multiple victims.
Volar was arrested in February 2018, charged and released without bail. In June 2018, Kizer shot and killed Volar, set his house on fire and fled the scene in Volar’s BMW.
Volar filmed himself abusing Kizer on multiple occasions, according to The Washington Post.
Kizer’s defense argued she should have immunity from prosecution under a 2008 Wisconsin sex trafficking law. However, going to trial would have risked a possible life sentence, so she pleaded guilty in May to a lesser second-degree reckless homicide charge.
At her sentencing hearing, the judge did not allow cameras in the courtroom.
“The court is well aware of your relationship with Mr. Volar,” Kenosha County Judge David Wilk said. “However, you are not permitted to be the instrument of his reckoning. To hold otherwise is to endorse a descent into lawlessness and chaos.”
Before her sentencing, Kizer quoted the Book of Genesis from the Bible, admitted to what she described as her sins and asked for mercy.
The judge ultimately sentenced her to 11 years in prison. However, some sex trafficking survivor advocates called the sentencing unfair. They also promised to continue fighting for Kizer’s freedom.
A MILWAUKEE WOMAN HAS BEEN SENTENCED TO 11 YEARS IN PRISON FOR THE DEATH OF A MAN SHE SAYS RAPED AND SEX-TRAFFICKED HER AS A TEENAGER.
THE CONTROVERSIAL CASE HAS BEEN IN THE NATIONAL SPOTLIGHT FOR YEARS.
CHRYSTUL KIZER WHO IS NOW 24 YEARS OLD PLEADED GUILTY IN MAY TO “RECKLESS HOMICIDE” IN THE 2018 KILLING OF 34-YEAR-OLD RANDALL VOLAR.
AT THE TIME OF THE INCIDENT – KIZER WAS JUST 17.
KIZER’S DEFENSE ATTORNEY SAYS THIS MAN CONTACTED KIZER WHEN SHE WAS 16 AFTER SHE POSTED AN ONLINE AD FOR PROSTITUTION –
HER ATTORNEY SAYING KIZER TURNED TO THE SITE OUT OF DESPERATION TO FEED HER SIBLINGS.
AT THE TIME VOLAR AND KIZER MET –
VOLAR WAS ALREADY UNDER INVESTIGATION FOR SEXUAL CONDUCT WITH UNDERAGE GIRLS AS YOUNG AS 12.
POLICE LATER DISCOVERED EVIDENCE OF ABUSE INVOLVING MULTIPLE VICTIMS.
VOLAR WAS ARRESTED IN FEBRUARY OF 2018.
CHARGED. AND RELEASED WITHOUT BAIL.
FOUR MONTHS LATER – KIZER – SHOT AND KILLED VOLAR – SETTING HIS HOUSE ON FIRE AND LEAVING THE SCENE IN HIS BMW.
ACCORDING TO THE WASHINGTON POST – VOLAR HAD FILMED HIMSELF ABUSING KIZER ON MULTIPLE OCCASIONS.
KIZER’S DEFENSE ARGUED SHE SHOULD HAVE IMMUNITY FROM PROSECUTION UNDER A 2008 WISCONSIN SEX TRAFFICKING LAW.
BUT GOING TO TRIAL WOULD MEAN KIZER RISKED A POSSIBLE LIFE SENTENCE.
SO SHE PLED GUILTY IN MAY TO A LESSER SECOND DEGREE RECKLESS HOMICIDE CHARGE.
AT HER SENTENCING HEARING – NO CAMERAS WERE ALLOWED TO RECORD IN THE COURTROOM.
BUT KENOSHA COUNTY JUDGE DAVID WILK SAID
“THE COURT IS WELL AWARE OF YOUR RELATIONSHIP WITH MR. VOLAR. HOWEVER, YOU ARE NOT PERMITTED TO BE THE INSTRUMENT OF HIS RECKONING. TO HOLD OTHERWISE IS TO ENDORSE A DESCENT INTO LAWLESSNESS AND CHAOS.”
BEFORE HER SENTENCING KIZER QUOTED THE BOOK OF GENESIS FROM THE BIBLE, ADMITTED TO WHAT SHE DESCRIBED AS HER SINS – AND ASKED FOR MERCY.
ULTIMATELY – SENTENCED TO 11 YEARS IN PRISON.
SOME SEX TRAFFICKING SURVIVOR ADVOCATES – CALLING THE SENTENCING UNFAIR. AND ARE PROMISING TO CONTINUE TO FIGHT FOR KIZER’S FREEDOM.
Straight to your inbox.
By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.
MOST POPULAR
-
Getty Images
NORAD Santa tracker's history goes back nearly 70 years
-
Getty Images
Massachusetts Gov. Healey clarifies state’s stance on migrants
-
Getty Images
Drug lord Fabio Ochoa released, returns to Colombia after 25 years in US prison
-
Getty Images
President-elect Trump wants to rename Denali Mount Mckinley