How future generations could shift US support for Israel

There is no reason to expect the Gaza war to end anytime soon. And while both Israel and Hezbollah really don’t want to have military conflict, there are some factors that are pushing them more in each other’s face. So we can’t rule out a specific war there. But what this does is keep Israel at top of mind for a lot of American security planners, especially for the White House. Because at the end of the day, Israel relies on American tech transfer and weapon procurement in order to keep its own security in order. And the question is, whether or not that is in a degree of danger.
And we cut through the chase and say that the short answer is no. For now, there’s two issues that kind of define this problem. The first is that the political evolution of Israel is towards a much more
stodgy reactionary approach to not just politics, but security. If you consider Israel in the Palestinian territories as a single unit, there’s three forces in play. The first, of course, is the Palestinians themselves, who are capable of doing resistance, but not in a traditional manner, what we saw back in October with the terrorist assaults, that’s about the most they can hope for, there are no anti tank rockets, there are no air forces, there are no tanks. So from a security point of view, this is a pain in the ass and tragic. But it’s not a traditional state challenge. What it is, is an ongoing grinding issue of occupation and resistance, that will always be there in the background. The second group
are the Jews, the specifically the secular Jews who have controlled the governing system of Israel for the last 75 years. Now these of course, break into different groups with different politics, just like any other country, but ultimately, they’re all drawn from a similar political stock, if you will. The third group, the one that is disrupting this balance, if that’s the right word, are the Haredi, the ultra orthodox were much more conservative, for the most part, not integrated into Israeli Israeli life. And until very recently, we’re not even contributing to the military, we’ve recently had a change in law there, which we will link to that piece and the implications of it here. Anyway, this is a group where they basically live on the government dole, and do what their Rabbi’s tell them to do. It’s not that simple. Don’t send me hate mail for that statement. But these are people who are not as sophisticated as the Jewish population of the secular kind. And they have some very, very, very, very, very, very strong opinions on what should be done to and about the Palestinians, much more hawkish, but they haven’t really contributed to
the assets that are necessary to carry out that policy, because they pay very little taxes, most of them haven’t served in the military. And yet they want a very hardline response. Well, for the last couple of decades, this ultra orthodox coalition has been a bigger and a bigger factor in internal Israeli politics, and have been the kingmakers in any number of governments including the current one. And because they’re basically paid to exist by the state, their numbers are growing very rapidly. And we’re going to be hit a position within the next 25 years, where they are going to be neck and neck in terms of voting power with the traditional secular Jews. And that transition from here to there is going to generate a very different set of policy options in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem. So the question is, how does this relate to the Americans? Well, in the short term, it really doesn’t. Donald Trump, when he was president was very pro Israeli, very anti Palestinian, his policies reflected that. And the folks in charge of the Jewish government in Israel were very, very supportive of that.
Under Biden, there’s been a little bit more oblique criticism. The Palestinians, of course, would disagree with that assessment. But Biden is basically started call a spade a spade and said that some of the things that the Orthodox tinge government in Israel is doing are perhaps not legal, internationally, and border on time to time a little bit genocidal. And at times, that criticism has boiled up in international affairs and actually affected the ability of Israel to access American weapons. It hasn’t gotten to a breakpoint, because one of the advantages in the United States of having a president who’s older than dust is he remembers when the Jewish state was formed, which means he remembers personally the Holocaust. He remembers Abraham, and Isaac and all the rest. And so he knows that in the long sweep of history, what’s going on right now is a bit of a bump. But Biden will not be there forever. Trump will not be there forever. And we’re having a demographic shift in the United States as well as in Israel. Right now in 2020. For the majority of Americans baby boomers are probably the most pro
Israel generation we have have already retired. And over that same transition period where the orthodox sects are going to basically rise to power in Israel, America’s baby boomers are going to die out. And the young generation coming up from below the Zoomers and the bliss to a lesser degree, the millennials are not nearly as even handed when it comes to Israel versus the Palestinians. So demographics are absolutely against Israel on this topic, but never forget that demographics are like a glacier. They move slowly. They don’t matter until the day they do. We’re not going to hit that day in the next four years. But we will hit it in the next four decades. So for now, the Israeli government regardless of its makeup, can be assured of long term American support. But long term does not mean permanent.