Hey everyone, Peter zine here. We’re gonna talk about Taiwan today. So back on May 18, the US Trade Representative, Ms. Thai, finalized a trade deal with the Taiwanese. Now this isn’t like a big free trade deal. This is more like an A the early steps of what’s necessary to negotiate a free trade deal things on regulations and measures, basically getting all your ducks in a row, so you can start the real work. But still, this is the first time the United States has ever done something like this with something that’s technically not a country. And you only do this with countries. And one of the things we’ve been seeing over the last couple of years is the United States is moving bit by bit by bit towards formal recognition of Taiwan as an independent country. And now that we’re starting formal trade talks, you would expect a formal recognition of Taiwanese independence to me in the not too distant future. We’ve also seen this almost comical development of the White House where Biden will treat Taiwan like an independent country that we have a defense agreement with, even though we don’t formally say that it’s an independent country, and we don’t have a defense agreement with it. And then his comments are walked back by his people. But instead of two years ago, when they were being walked back within minutes, now, it’s takes a couple of weeks to get the lock back. So bit by bit by bit, we’re easing into a formal recognition. Of course, no one in Beijing is happy about that. And so a couple of things here. Number one, Taiwan is a major trading partner, I believe it’s the 12th most intense trading partner, so you know, several billion dollars of high tech stuff that’s valuable to everybody on both sides of the Pacific. So there’s a good economic reason. And that, of course, if the Taiwanese are not in Beijing’s grasp, it’s an important military asset. And we’re now seeing the very beginnings of the sort of military partnership that we started developing with the Ukrainians, you know, eight years ago. Now, if the Chinese were to launch an assault on Taiwan tomorrow, I have no doubt that they would win the war. Well, their military has, has a number of faults, it doesn’t have reach, it doesn’t have range, it doesn’t have staying power, they’re too dependent upon foreign sources for their energy. And for their high tech, you know, all these things are true. But it was designed with Taiwan in mind, and Taiwan is not that far away. And for the United States to get involved, it first has to cross the Pacific, which will take several weeks. So in the Chinese mind, it would be a high intensity campaign would just last a couple of weeks, maybe a month, and before anyone could really get involved, and they would probably win. And I think that’s a reasonable military assessment. But whenever you’re planning for war, you have to think about what happens the next day. And from the Chinese point of view, because no one recognizes Taiwan as a country, because there is no defense agreement with between the Taiwanese and anyone, they would at most face some moderate sanctions, that would fade out over a few years. And they think that that’s something they could absolutely stomach. And if that was true, I would agree. But two things are going on. First of all, the United States has a tendency to intervene militarily in places that it finds convenient, because it has global reach, and that the Chinese can only dream of achieving at some point this century. So the smart play, if you want to fight China isn’t to fight in the Taiwan Strait. I mean, this is straight out of Sun Tzu don’t face someone with a strong face, the more you’re the weak, China imports, three quarters of its energy, almost all of that along the path from the Persian Gulf by India, South China Sea and then up to the Chinese coastal cities. So what you do is you put a few destroyers, or equivalent with submarines in the Indian Ocean, and you cut the energy line. And since this is the source of most of the energy, and even a greater proportion of the stuff that allows the Chinese to grow their own food, you get a deindustrialization collapse, complete with famine. In six months. I would have believed that the Chinese recognize this a few years ago. But Chairman G has purged the system of everyone who’s competent, and everyone who’s willing to tell him anything, not just things he doesn’t want to hear, but anything to the point that it’s entirely possible that it’s now just a completely groupthink scenario in Beijing. And that certainly seems to be the case all the bureaucrats all the diplomats seem to be drinking all the Kool Aid and lost the capacity of independent thought or any sort of meaningful penetrating analysis. And so the belief is the actual war plan is that they sink any American naval assets that are within reach of them as part of the Taiwan operation. But the rest of the US Navy will continue to keep the SES seas safe for global shipping. And this sort of disconnect between their perception of reality. And the reality of American power, is, you know, one of the five dumbest things I’ve seen in the last 20 years and you know, two of the other dumb things have to do with the Chinese government in recent months. Anyway. So am I concerned that there’s going to be a war in Taiwan? Yes and no. First the know. They gotta know it’s not just a war. They can’t win over the Long term but one that will cost them the advanced economic status that they have fought so hard to get. And it is the end of China as a modern industrialized nation state. But then there’s the yes, they may have may have be so sunk into their propaganda. They think they think not only this is a winnable war, but one that the rest of the world would just sign off on. And in the aftermath of the Ukraine war, it blows my mind that I’m even considering this. But the more people I talk to are in the space both on both sides of the Pacific, the myopia the deliberate ignorance within the Chinese bureaucracy really has become breathtaking. And so the risk here is real. It would mean the end of not just the American Chinese relationship but of China as an entity, but it still might happen. Alright, that’s it for me. See you guys next time.
Commentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
‘Instill optimism’: Americans on how future generations can succeed
Friday Dr. Frank Luntz‘Have a little compassion’: Americans talk high holiday prices, anxiety
Dec 11 Dr. Frank Luntz‘System is rigged’: Black Americans on the American Dream
Nov 27 Dr. Frank Luntz‘Extremist’ or ‘phony’: Americans share who they voted for and why
Nov 21 Dr. Frank LuntzThe potential for a Chinese invasion of Taiwan may be growing
By Straight Arrow News
In May 2022, President Biden said the U.S. would intervene militarily should China invade Taiwan. In August of the same year, Nancy Pelosi visited the island, intensifying tensions in the already strained relations between the two superpowers. Now the U.S. and Taiwan have signed a new trade deal designed to bolster the economic ties between Washington and Taipei.
Straight Arrow News contributor Peter Zeihan reexamines the chances that China will decide to attack its neighbor.
Excerpted from Peter’s June 1 “Zeihan on Geopolitics” newsletter:
In mid-May, the U.S. Trade Representative established a trade initiative with Taiwan. While this isn’t a full-blown trade deal, it represents the shift in U.S. policy towards recognizing Taiwan as an independent country.
Taiwan is already an important trade partner for the U.S., so the economic rationale is there. You can also throw a check next to strategic reasoning, as keeping Taiwan out of Beijing’s grasp means access to critical military positioning for the U.S.
You can probably guess how the mainland feels about all this…but does that mean an invasion will happen? Unfortunately, I could see this going either way. It would be hard to imagine a world where Xi considers an attack a good idea, but who knows what will happen if everyone keeps drinking the CCP-Propaganda-Kool-Aid?
Hey everyone, Peter zine here. We’re gonna talk about Taiwan today. So back on May 18, the US Trade Representative, Ms. Thai, finalized a trade deal with the Taiwanese. Now this isn’t like a big free trade deal. This is more like an A the early steps of what’s necessary to negotiate a free trade deal things on regulations and measures, basically getting all your ducks in a row, so you can start the real work. But still, this is the first time the United States has ever done something like this with something that’s technically not a country. And you only do this with countries. And one of the things we’ve been seeing over the last couple of years is the United States is moving bit by bit by bit towards formal recognition of Taiwan as an independent country. And now that we’re starting formal trade talks, you would expect a formal recognition of Taiwanese independence to me in the not too distant future. We’ve also seen this almost comical development of the White House where Biden will treat Taiwan like an independent country that we have a defense agreement with, even though we don’t formally say that it’s an independent country, and we don’t have a defense agreement with it. And then his comments are walked back by his people. But instead of two years ago, when they were being walked back within minutes, now, it’s takes a couple of weeks to get the lock back. So bit by bit by bit, we’re easing into a formal recognition. Of course, no one in Beijing is happy about that. And so a couple of things here. Number one, Taiwan is a major trading partner, I believe it’s the 12th most intense trading partner, so you know, several billion dollars of high tech stuff that’s valuable to everybody on both sides of the Pacific. So there’s a good economic reason. And that, of course, if the Taiwanese are not in Beijing’s grasp, it’s an important military asset. And we’re now seeing the very beginnings of the sort of military partnership that we started developing with the Ukrainians, you know, eight years ago. Now, if the Chinese were to launch an assault on Taiwan tomorrow, I have no doubt that they would win the war. Well, their military has, has a number of faults, it doesn’t have reach, it doesn’t have range, it doesn’t have staying power, they’re too dependent upon foreign sources for their energy. And for their high tech, you know, all these things are true. But it was designed with Taiwan in mind, and Taiwan is not that far away. And for the United States to get involved, it first has to cross the Pacific, which will take several weeks. So in the Chinese mind, it would be a high intensity campaign would just last a couple of weeks, maybe a month, and before anyone could really get involved, and they would probably win. And I think that’s a reasonable military assessment. But whenever you’re planning for war, you have to think about what happens the next day. And from the Chinese point of view, because no one recognizes Taiwan as a country, because there is no defense agreement with between the Taiwanese and anyone, they would at most face some moderate sanctions, that would fade out over a few years. And they think that that’s something they could absolutely stomach. And if that was true, I would agree. But two things are going on. First of all, the United States has a tendency to intervene militarily in places that it finds convenient, because it has global reach, and that the Chinese can only dream of achieving at some point this century. So the smart play, if you want to fight China isn’t to fight in the Taiwan Strait. I mean, this is straight out of Sun Tzu don’t face someone with a strong face, the more you’re the weak, China imports, three quarters of its energy, almost all of that along the path from the Persian Gulf by India, South China Sea and then up to the Chinese coastal cities. So what you do is you put a few destroyers, or equivalent with submarines in the Indian Ocean, and you cut the energy line. And since this is the source of most of the energy, and even a greater proportion of the stuff that allows the Chinese to grow their own food, you get a deindustrialization collapse, complete with famine. In six months. I would have believed that the Chinese recognize this a few years ago. But Chairman G has purged the system of everyone who’s competent, and everyone who’s willing to tell him anything, not just things he doesn’t want to hear, but anything to the point that it’s entirely possible that it’s now just a completely groupthink scenario in Beijing. And that certainly seems to be the case all the bureaucrats all the diplomats seem to be drinking all the Kool Aid and lost the capacity of independent thought or any sort of meaningful penetrating analysis. And so the belief is the actual war plan is that they sink any American naval assets that are within reach of them as part of the Taiwan operation. But the rest of the US Navy will continue to keep the SES seas safe for global shipping. And this sort of disconnect between their perception of reality. And the reality of American power, is, you know, one of the five dumbest things I’ve seen in the last 20 years and you know, two of the other dumb things have to do with the Chinese government in recent months. Anyway. So am I concerned that there’s going to be a war in Taiwan? Yes and no. First the know. They gotta know it’s not just a war. They can’t win over the Long term but one that will cost them the advanced economic status that they have fought so hard to get. And it is the end of China as a modern industrialized nation state. But then there’s the yes, they may have may have be so sunk into their propaganda. They think they think not only this is a winnable war, but one that the rest of the world would just sign off on. And in the aftermath of the Ukraine war, it blows my mind that I’m even considering this. But the more people I talk to are in the space both on both sides of the Pacific, the myopia the deliberate ignorance within the Chinese bureaucracy really has become breathtaking. And so the risk here is real. It would mean the end of not just the American Chinese relationship but of China as an entity, but it still might happen. Alright, that’s it for me. See you guys next time.
Hurricane Helene hits US coast, Appalachia and beyond
Israel holds upper hand against Lebanon, Hezbollah and Iran
The Sinaloa Cartel civil war
New Ukrainian weapons hit Russia where it hurts
Weighing social costs vs. economic benefits on immigration
Underreported stories from each side
Scott Jennings: The biggest scandal in America is the cover-up of Biden’s condition
19 sources | 13% from the left Getty ImagesSinema reflects on criticism in exit interview: ‘Don’t give a s‑‑‑’
11 sources | 10% from the right Getty ImagesLatest Stories
Biden considers commuting death row: Report
Louisville police issue citation to homeless woman in labor
New book accuses Spotify of promoting fake artists
Andrew Cuomo sues for defamation after sexual harassment allegations
Driver kills at least two in Germany Christmas market attack
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Time to say goodbye to DEI
Friday Star ParkerIt’s time to take failed capitalism out of Christmas
Friday Dr. Rashad RicheyMusk-Ramaswamy DOGE initiative overdue and full of challenges
Thursday John FortierTrump’s Mar-a-Lago interview is a preview of troubles ahead
Thursday Jordan Reid