We rely on doctors when we need medical attention. We count on plumbers to fix a leak. So why don’t we do the same for our teachers? They go to school for years to earn degrees in education. They study curriculum, child development, and teaching strategies. Yet, many people think they know better and are demanding control in the classroom.
Republican state lawmakers across the US are introducing bills that would require teachers to post all their materials online so that parents can review them.
At the heart of these bills is the suggestion that something nefarious is happening, something that schools don’t want parents to see. And it’s rooted in a culture war that teachers should not be dragged into.
Do you remember my segment on Critical Race Theory and how it’s not actually being taught in schools, but it’s being used as sort of a way for parents to grasp at any indicator that–gasp–the realities of systemic racism are being taught to our children?
Well, posting every detail of a curriculum essentially invites parents to look for more things to complain about, and these bills even open up avenues for parents to sue schools if they don’t like what they see.
Here’s what these bills are about. They’re about trying to get teachers to stop educating their students about matters of race and gender. They’re about trying to get teachers to present “impartial” opinions about things like the Holocaust, or slavery, or LGBTQ rights. It’s about censorship. That’s it.
Oh, and of course it also adds to the workload of teachers who are already taxed beyond belief.
One lawmaker even supports a requirement for teachers to wear body cameras. The invasiveness of this is truly astonishing, and, were it to be implemented, would almost certainly lead to resignations.
We need more teachers, not fewer, and the way to keep this most important of professions filled with the very best talent is to treat teachers with decency, respect, and autonomy.
You want your kids to hold a specific opinion that you yourself share? You should totally talk to them about it. It’s called parenting. Let the teachers teach.
One of my favorite websites to visit is symptomchecker.com. On that site, I can type in my “symptom” – say, I’m tired – and discover that either I need a cup of coffee, or I’m dying.
Diagnoses, it turns out, should not be made by Dr. Google. They should be made by doctors.
It’s the same with education. I mean I certainly care about my children’s education, I inform myself about what they’re learning, but I’m not shooting off emails to their teachers telling them what “I” think they should be doing in the classroom.
I mean I’m entitled to an opinion – and, of course, if something egregious happens it should be addressed – but I’d rather leave the educating to people who spent years and years training in education.
Seriously. Have you seen how the kids do long division these days? I am so happy that someone else is responsible for handling that.
Some members of the GOP, alas, disagree with this approach. Republican state lawmakers across the US are introducing bills that would require teachers to post all their materials online so that parents can review them.
Now, let’s not pretend that this is a simple case of “What? Parents deserve to know what’s going on!”
Of course, parents deserve to know what’s going on. Classroom materials aren’t like secrets that teachers are keeping. You want to know what’s inTo Kill A Mockingbird? Go read it, and if something in the curriculum conflicts with your ideologies or personal belief structure, have a conversation with your child’s teacher. They’ll probably try to work with you. But again that is not what this is about.
At the heart of these bills is the suggestion that something nefarious is happening, something that schools don’t want parents to see. And it’s rooted in a culture war that teachers should not be dragged into.
Do you remember my segment on Critical Race Theory and how it’s not actually being taught in schools, but it’s being used as sort of a way for parents to grasp at any indicator that – gasp – the realities of systemic racism are being taught to our children?
Well, posting every detail of a curriculum essentially invites parents to look for more things to complain about, and these bills even open up avenues for parents to sue schools if they don’t like what they see.
Here’s what these bills are about. They’re about trying to get teachers to stop educating their students about matters of race and gender. They’re about trying to get teachers to present “impartial” about opinions things like the Holocaust, or slavery, or LGBTQ rights. It’s about censorship. That’s it.
Oh, and of course it also adds to the workload of teachers who are already taxed beyond belief.
And also – quick product plug for my new book – deserve presents like The Big Activity Book for Teacher People, not disrespect.
One lawmaker even supports a requirement for teachers to wear body cameras. The invasiveness of this is truly astonishing, and, were it to be implemented, would almost certainly lead to resignations.
We need more teachers, not fewer, and the way to keep this most important of professions filled with the very best talent is to treat teachers with decency, respect, and autonomy.
You want your kids to hold a specific opinion that you yourself share? You should totally talk to them about it. It’s called parenting. Let the teachers teach.
Jordan Reid
Share
. . .
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
More from Jordan
Commentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
How shifting Russian targets impact global economy
Yesterday
Peter Zeihan
What explains West African coups? Will France respond?
Thursday
Peter Zeihan
Chinese housing overbuild may erode support for Xi Jinping
Wednesday
Peter Zeihan
Americans debate government shutdowns, spending priorities
Wednesday
Dr. Frank Luntz
Body cameras for teachers? Let educators do their jobs without censorship.
Mar 21, 2022
Share
. . .
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
By
We rely on doctors when we need medical attention. We count on plumbers to fix a leak. So why don’t we do the same for our teachers? They go to school for years to earn degrees in education. They study curriculum, child development, and teaching strategies. Yet, many people think they know better and are demanding control in the classroom.
One of my favorite websites to visit is symptomchecker.com. On that site, I can type in my “symptom” – say, I’m tired – and discover that either I need a cup of coffee, or I’m dying.
Diagnoses, it turns out, should not be made by Dr. Google. They should be made by doctors.
It’s the same with education. I mean I certainly care about my children’s education, I inform myself about what they’re learning, but I’m not shooting off emails to their teachers telling them what “I” think they should be doing in the classroom.
I mean I’m entitled to an opinion – and, of course, if something egregious happens it should be addressed – but I’d rather leave the educating to people who spent years and years training in education.
Seriously. Have you seen how the kids do long division these days? I am so happy that someone else is responsible for handling that.
Some members of the GOP, alas, disagree with this approach. Republican state lawmakers across the US are introducing bills that would require teachers to post all their materials online so that parents can review them.
Now, let’s not pretend that this is a simple case of “What? Parents deserve to know what’s going on!”
Of course, parents deserve to know what’s going on. Classroom materials aren’t like secrets that teachers are keeping. You want to know what’s in To Kill A Mockingbird? Go read it, and if something in the curriculum conflicts with your ideologies or personal belief structure, have a conversation with your child’s teacher. They’ll probably try to work with you. But again that is not what this is about.
At the heart of these bills is the suggestion that something nefarious is happening, something that schools don’t want parents to see. And it’s rooted in a culture war that teachers should not be dragged into.
Do you remember my segment on Critical Race Theory and how it’s not actually being taught in schools, but it’s being used as sort of a way for parents to grasp at any indicator that – gasp – the realities of systemic racism are being taught to our children?
Well, posting every detail of a curriculum essentially invites parents to look for more things to complain about, and these bills even open up avenues for parents to sue schools if they don’t like what they see.
Here’s what these bills are about. They’re about trying to get teachers to stop educating their students about matters of race and gender. They’re about trying to get teachers to present “impartial” about opinions things like the Holocaust, or slavery, or LGBTQ rights. It’s about censorship. That’s it.
Oh, and of course it also adds to the workload of teachers who are already taxed beyond belief.
And also – quick product plug for my new book – deserve presents like The Big Activity Book for Teacher People, not disrespect.
One lawmaker even supports a requirement for teachers to wear body cameras. The invasiveness of this is truly astonishing, and, were it to be implemented, would almost certainly lead to resignations.
We need more teachers, not fewer, and the way to keep this most important of professions filled with the very best talent is to treat teachers with decency, respect, and autonomy.
You want your kids to hold a specific opinion that you yourself share? You should totally talk to them about it. It’s called parenting. Let the teachers teach.
Why is accused sexual predator Russell Brand getting right-wing support?
British actor Russell Brand is under investigation for sexual assault allegations, leading some conservatives, including Tucker Carlson, to support him by suggesting that his right-leaning political beliefs triggered the investigation. Social media influencer Andrew Tate, currently awaiting trial in Romania on charges of rape and human trafficking, has also expressed support for Brand. Straight Arrow
Thursday
Old age aside, it’s clear why Biden trumps Trump
In the upcoming 2024 election, President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump lead in the polls, but both face criticism regarding their age. Biden often receives heightened attention for displaying signs of aging in public, including moments of stuttering and occasional tripping. Straight Arrow News contributor Jordan Reid wants to remind voters to steer
Sep 21
How should America respond to the latest COVID-19 surge?
The recent increase in COVID-19 cases has again brought the virus into the spotlight, reigniting discussions about vaccines, lockdowns and mask mandates. As new variants emerge and a new vaccine rollout is imminent, the familiar debates between Democrats and Republicans have resurfaced. Straight Arrow News contributor Jordan Reid looks back at America’s initial response to
Sep 14
Vivek Ramaswamy is making me nervous
Following the first Republican presidential debate, candidate Vivek Ramaswamy’s controversial viewpoints and characterizations of certain events are garnering both notoriety and support. In response to the heightened scrutiny, rival candidates are launching attacks on Ramaswamy’s campaign. Straight Arrow News contributor Jordan Reid argues Ramaswamy’s far-right, inflammatory positions have found unexpected traction with both the media
Sep 7
Biden impeachment is political distraction from Trump crimes
Republicans have explored a number of ways to impeach President Biden. House Speaker Kevin McCarthy’s newfound support for impeachment, however, represents a significant new shift in U.S. politics. Straight Arrow News contributor Jordan Reid argues that McCarthy’s flip comes from the need to distract American attention away from the criminal cases against former President Donald
Aug 31
Media Miss
Stories each side is underreporting
Former Loudoun schools chief guilty of retaliating against teacher
12 sources | 17% from the left
Local members of Congress weigh in on potential government shutdown
11 sources | 0% from the right
Latest Opinions
Getty Images
Biden proposes limited offshore oil and gas leases to support wind energy
Watch 2:20
19 hrs ago
The Elephant Sanctuary
California city first in nation to recognize legal rights of elephants
Watch 2:15
20 hrs ago
Getty Images
Sen. Feinstein’s death leaves Senate vacancy Gov. Newsom needs to fill
Watch 2:54
20 hrs ago
Premier of Ontario
Climate advocates, indigenous tribes protest efforts to mine $67B of minerals in Canada
Watch 2:50
20 hrs ago
Getty Images
Retailers report record $112B in lost inventory amid theft, violence
Watch 2:22
23 hrs ago
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Politics of lesser evils is bad for all Americans
Yesterday
Dr. Rashad Richey
How a No Labels candidate might affect outcome of 2024 election
Yesterday
John Fortier
Why is accused sexual predator Russell Brand getting right-wing support?
Thursday
Jordan Reid
High housing mortgage costs are a risk to whole economy
Wednesday
Newt Gingrich
Politics
Sen. Feinstein’s death leaves Senate vacancy Gov. Newsom needs to fill
20 hrs ago
Members of Congress still get paid during government shutdown
Sen. Dianne Feinstein, longest serving woman senator, dies at 90
Getty Images
U.S.
California city first in nation to recognize legal rights of elephants
20 hrs ago
Elon Musk weighs in on immigration policy in visit to US-Mexico border
DHS collects migrants’ DNA for growing database, raising privacy concerns
The Elephant Sanctuary
International
Cuban officials call Molotov cocktail attack on its US embassy terrorism
Tuesday
Canadian lawmakers apologize after celebrating Ukrainian Nazi fighter
Nicaragua’s Catholic president is persecuting members of his own religion
Reuters
Tech
TikTok workers: China may have more control over user data than we think
Yesterday
Musk makes cuts to X election integrity team
Ford pauses construction on $3.5 billion EV battery plant
Getty Images