The economic uncertainty fueled by the war in Ukraine has had a particularly strong impact on the global food supply, in particular, the wheat market. Approximately 25% of the world’s wheat supply comes from Russia and Ukraine, and the disruption to the market has sparked fears of a worldwide food crisis. Those concerns have sparked a renewed interest in palm oil. One of the world’s biggest producers of palm oil, Indonesia, has banned exports of the crop. Straight Arrow News contributor Larry Lindsey says history has proven that export bans only wind up hurting the poorest and most vulnerable members of society.
During the 1930s, unemployment was a major problem. In order to protect people from being unemployed, governments around the world, led by the United States, imposed tariffs on imports. The idea was to benefit domestic producers as opposed to foreign producers.
Well, when you put a tariff on something, it’s price goes up. The producers gain, but the consumers lose. And on net, the consumer loss is more than what the producer gains. That’s mainly because there are lower real incomes when prices go up. So people could afford to buy even less of just about everything. Then other countries followed suit and we had something called beggar thy neighbor tariffs. The idea was that, I don’t care what happens to exporters in another country. I just want to protect myself. Well, the whole process contributed to a great depression that was virtually worldwide.
Well, fast forward to today. Unemployment isn’t the problem; inflation is. But governments still haven’t learned. So what we’re doing now in many countries is to ban exports. The idea is to keep the goods at home that will increase domestic supply and push prices down. The politicians can then claim that they have fought to reduce inflation. Now, of course, when you don’t export, prices overseas go up a lot. Then other countries begin to ban exports as well for the same reason.
There’s a long-term problem in all this. When you keep domestic prices low over time, the countries that produce those goods go out of business and these… barriers are going to be up for a long time. Again, take America as an example. We imposed a crude oil export ban back during the oil crisis in 1975. We never got around to repealing it until 2015 – 40 years later. So these things tend to stay.
There’s an old saying that those who forget history are doomed to repeat it. Well, a little history. During the 1930s, unemployment was a major problem. In order to protect people from being unemployed, governments around the world, led by the United States, imposed tariffs on imports. The idea was to benefit domestic producers as opposed to foreign producers.
Well, when you put a tariff on something, it’s price goes up. The producers gain, but the consumers lose. And on net, the consumer loss is more than what the producer gains. That’s mainly because there are lower real incomes when prices go up. So people could afford to buy even less of just about everything. Then other countries followed suit and we had something called beggar thy neighbor tariffs. The idea was that, I don’t care what happens to exporters in another country. I just want to protect myself. Well, the whole process contributed to a great depression that was virtually worldwide.
Well, fast forward to today. Unemployment isn’t the problem; inflation is. But governments still haven’t learned. So what we’re doing now in many countries is to ban exports. The idea is to keep the goods at home that will increase domestic supply and push prices down. The politicians can then claim that they have fought to reduce inflation. Now, of course, when you don’t export, prices overseas go up a lot. Then other countries begin to ban exports as well for the same reason.
There’s a long-term problem in all this. When you keep domestic prices low over time, the countries that produce those goods go out of business and these… barriers are going to be up for a long time. Again, take America as an example. We imposed a crude oil export ban back during the oil crisis in 1975. We never got around to repealing it until 2015 – 40 years later. So these things tend to stay.
Well, two prominent examples. India has banned the export of wheat without special government…approval. Now you gotta remember, India is the second largest producer of wheat in the world. Just on the announcement, the price of wheat globally went up 5%. That was on top of an already 25% rise that occurred because of the Russia-Ukraine conflict. And then in Indonesia, they banned the export of palm oil, which is widely used in the area as a cooking oil. Well, prices collapsed domestically, and a lot of palm growers went out of business. They may not come back. In total, 19 countries in the world have now banned food exports of one kind or another. A total of 31 different commodities of food are impacted. That affects, believe it or not, 17% of all world calorie consumption. That is one heck of a lot of calories.
Now the purpose of rising prices, which happens when you restrict exports, is that the prices are designed to ration the available supply, which means some people will lose out. Those people tend to be the poorest people on the planet. And so we’re going to have actually people starving around the world because of this practice. We’re also starting a global commodity supercycle, according to some.
Well, that rise in prices over the long term now has on its side the best helper you can get – the governments around the world who foolishly forget history and are enacting all these export bans.
Larry Lindsey
Share
. . .
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
More from Larry
Commentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
Chinese housing overbuild may erode support for Xi Jinping
21 hrs ago
Peter Zeihan
Americans debate government shutdowns, spending priorities
23 hrs ago
Dr. Frank Luntz
Will China invade Taiwan as a diversion?
Yesterday
Peter Zeihan
What will happen if Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov dies?
Monday
Peter Zeihan
History tells us that export bans are a very bad idea
Jun 23, 2022
Share
. . .
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
By
The economic uncertainty fueled by the war in Ukraine has had a particularly strong impact on the global food supply, in particular, the wheat market. Approximately 25% of the world’s wheat supply comes from Russia and Ukraine, and the disruption to the market has sparked fears of a worldwide food crisis. Those concerns have sparked a renewed interest in palm oil. One of the world’s biggest producers of palm oil, Indonesia, has banned exports of the crop. Straight Arrow News contributor Larry Lindsey says history has proven that export bans only wind up hurting the poorest and most vulnerable members of society.
There’s an old saying that those who forget history are doomed to repeat it. Well, a little history. During the 1930s, unemployment was a major problem. In order to protect people from being unemployed, governments around the world, led by the United States, imposed tariffs on imports. The idea was to benefit domestic producers as opposed to foreign producers.
Well, when you put a tariff on something, it’s price goes up. The producers gain, but the consumers lose. And on net, the consumer loss is more than what the producer gains. That’s mainly because there are lower real incomes when prices go up. So people could afford to buy even less of just about everything. Then other countries followed suit and we had something called beggar thy neighbor tariffs. The idea was that, I don’t care what happens to exporters in another country. I just want to protect myself. Well, the whole process contributed to a great depression that was virtually worldwide.
Well, fast forward to today. Unemployment isn’t the problem; inflation is. But governments still haven’t learned. So what we’re doing now in many countries is to ban exports. The idea is to keep the goods at home that will increase domestic supply and push prices down. The politicians can then claim that they have fought to reduce inflation. Now, of course, when you don’t export, prices overseas go up a lot. Then other countries begin to ban exports as well for the same reason.
There’s a long-term problem in all this. When you keep domestic prices low over time, the countries that produce those goods go out of business and these… barriers are going to be up for a long time. Again, take America as an example. We imposed a crude oil export ban back during the oil crisis in 1975. We never got around to repealing it until 2015 – 40 years later. So these things tend to stay.
Well, two prominent examples. India has banned the export of wheat without special government…approval. Now you gotta remember, India is the second largest producer of wheat in the world. Just on the announcement, the price of wheat globally went up 5%. That was on top of an already 25% rise that occurred because of the Russia-Ukraine conflict. And then in Indonesia, they banned the export of palm oil, which is widely used in the area as a cooking oil. Well, prices collapsed domestically, and a lot of palm growers went out of business. They may not come back. In total, 19 countries in the world have now banned food exports of one kind or another. A total of 31 different commodities of food are impacted. That affects, believe it or not, 17% of all world calorie consumption. That is one heck of a lot of calories.
Now the purpose of rising prices, which happens when you restrict exports, is that the prices are designed to ration the available supply, which means some people will lose out. Those people tend to be the poorest people on the planet. And so we’re going to have actually people starving around the world because of this practice. We’re also starting a global commodity supercycle, according to some.
Well, that rise in prices over the long term now has on its side the best helper you can get – the governments around the world who foolishly forget history and are enacting all these export bans.
US debt interest is cause for concern
Economist Paul Krugman recently said that interest payments on U.S. debt won’t be a major concern in the years ahead. The U.S. national debt is almost at $33 trillion, and the interest payments alone on that debt are approaching $500 billion per year. Straight Arrow News contributor Larry Lindsey disagrees with Krugman and instead urges
Sep 11
The truth about corporate lending and credit tightening
Banks have started to tighten credit due to the Federal Reserve’s interest rate hikes, which represent a deliberate strategy to temper economic growth and reduce inflation. According to the most recent Senior Loan Officer Opinion Survey, a majority of banks reported that they had tightened lending standards for larger and medium-sized businesses in the past
Sep 5
China’s economic decline mirroring Japan’s past
China is currently experiencing record high youth unemployment and a decrease in economic growth. Japan faced similar issues in 1989 when deflation and over-investment caused their stock market to collapse. Straight Arrow News contributor Larry Lindsey suggests that China could end up mirroring Japan’s crash. But he believes that China might be hit harder due
Aug 28
Even after BRICS summit, US dollar is not going away
The BRICS summit is scheduled to take place Aug. 22-24 in Johannesburg, South Africa with member nations Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa. Together, these nations account for 16 percent of international trade, a substantial portion of which is conducted in U.S. dollars. These countries want to decrease their dependence on the dominant U.S.
Aug 21
Don’t underestimate Putin’s grip on power
Is the Ukraine war also a public relations war? The U.S. has sometimes promoted the idea that Putin’s power may be weakening. First, rumors that Putin had cancer began circulating. Then there was the Wagner Group’s short-lived rebellion against Russia’s military leadership. Putin, on the other hand, is pushing the argument that the West is
Jul 31
Stories each side is underreporting
Russia To Hike Defence Spending By Almost 70 Percent In 2024: Ministry
21 sources | 8% from the left
Slightly fewer number of Americans apply for jobless benefits as layoffs remain rare
26 sources | 0% from the right
Latest Opinions
Getty Images
Hyundai and Kia recall 3.3M vehicles over fire risk, tell drivers to ‘park outside’
Watch :55
1 hr ago
Getty Images
Musk makes cuts to X election integrity team
Watch 1:14
2 hrs ago
AP
Candidates clash at 2nd GOP primary debate: The Morning Rundown, Sept. 28, 2023
Watch 7:33
3 hrs ago
@NYCMayor via X
NYPD deploys K5 robot to patrol subway station
Watch 3:10
18 hrs ago
Getty Images
Poll: More Americans would blame Republicans for government shutdown
Watch 2:19
19 hrs ago
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
High housing mortgage costs are a risk to whole economy
22 hrs ago
Newt Gingrich
Stop blaming Hutchinson for alleged Giuliani groping
23 hrs ago
Adrienne Lawrence
Charges against Hunter Biden are a head fake
Yesterday
Ben Weingarten
Biden’s hardline immigration policies too similar to Trump’s
Yesterday
Ruben Navarrette
Politics
Candidates clash at 2nd GOP primary debate: The Morning Rundown, Sept. 28, 2023
3 hrs ago
Poll: More Americans would blame Republicans for government shutdown
House, Senate vote on bills as government shutdown looms: The Morning Rundown, Sept. 27, 2023
AP
U.S.
NYPD deploys K5 robot to patrol subway station
18 hrs ago
Booming home-schooling movement shifts from religious to more diverse: poll
New Orleans braces for saltwater intrusion impacting drinking supply
@NYCMayor via X
International
Cuban officials call Molotov cocktail attack on its US embassy terrorism
Tuesday
Canadian lawmakers apologize after celebrating Ukrainian Nazi fighter
Nicaragua’s Catholic president is persecuting members of his own religion
Reuters
Tech
Musk makes cuts to X election integrity team
2 hrs ago
Ford pauses construction on $3.5 billion EV battery plant
NASA: Asteroid sample from 200 million miles away lands in Utah
Getty Images