![Jordan Reid says the right is wrong when they compare abortion rights to vaccine mandates.](https://san.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/ReidonAbortionRightsThumbnail.png?w=1433)
Commentary
-
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
I bet you think, you know, where I stand on abortion rights, and you are correct. I am in favor of a woman’s right to choose, which is why I’ve been following the Supreme Court’s likely overturning or at least knee-capping of Roe versus Wade with considerable attention and the occasional brain explosion.
Okay. Let’s start with the concept of bodily autonomy. This is a person’s right to determine what they want to do with their own life and future. This is clearly an issue that’s central to abortion rights, but it’s also become a central issue with regards to anti-vaxxers or people who don’t want to wear masks.
See very early on in the pandemic, the political right began appropriating language used by the reproductive rights activists, my body, my choice, et cetera, which was clearly meant to be a poke at the libs, but let’s dig deeper here.
I mean, isn’t the far right these days all about individuals getting to choose what they do or do not do to their own bodies, whether or not to get the shot? Aren’t they up in arms about any attempt to mandate vaccination so as to slow the spread of a deadly disease that has at this point killed nearly 800,000 people in the United States alone? Bodily autonomy for everyone! Oh right, except for women. Which brings me back to my most recent brain explosion. There, there have been many, the past few years have been hard on my brain.
Amy Comey Barrett, a Supreme Court appointee of President Trump, had some pretty interesting things to say with regards to whether an abortion ban impacts a women’s bodily autonomy. Let’s take a listen.
Justice Amy Comey Barrett: There is, without question, an infringement on bodily autonomy, you know, which we have in other contexts, like vaccines.
Okay. So the right opposes vaccine mandates because they’re a violation of bodily autonomy, but they justify an abortion ban and the removal of a woman’s right to bodily autonomy by saying that vaccine mandates are basically the same thing, which is just taking a vaccine mandate argument and using it in whatever direction suits your interest on any given day.
This is the trap that they’re trying to put liberals in. If you argue that vaccine mandates are legal, because nobody has the right to bodily autonomy, you must also concede that a ban on abortion is legal because nobody has the right to bodily autonomy. Conversely, if you argue that a woman should have the right to choose, you have to extend that access to bodily autonomy to anti-vaxxers except there is a fatal flaw in this argument.
If you don’t take advantage of access to a safe, readily available vaccine, you contribute to the spread of a sickness, which kills people. If you deprive a woman of reproductive rights, you also deprive her of access to potentially life-saving procedures, which kills people.
Nobody is storming houses in the middle of the night jabbing shots into arms willynilly. Those supporting vaccine mandates are simply saying that should you choose to participate in society, you also need to accept your moral responsibility to protect the health and safety of the other members. When you take away a woman’s right to choose, you even criminalize those choices, you put every part of her in danger, her mental health, her ability to provide for herself, even her life.
One removes danger. The other amplifies it. This is a false equivalency.
Justice Barrett, you’re a smart woman, which is why I’m certain that your attempt to cite vaccine mandates in support of the overturning of abortion rights, it’s not about logic or constitutional argument. It’s trolling, and it’s a hard pill to swallow knowing that a Supreme Court justice isn’t above that.
-
Americans must reject Trump to defend our democracy
At the end of the Republican National Convention, Donald Trump accepted the nomination as the GOP candidate for president. In the first part of his acceptance speech, Trump called for unity and healing, although he derailed into partisanship as he continued. Critics have debated the media’s role in handling Trump’s speech. Some argued he was…
-
It’s time for Kamala Harris to pick up the torch
Debates have continued among Democrats about whether President Joe Biden is the best candidate for the 2024 election or whether an alternative Democratic leader might be more electable. While there’s no shortage of fellow Democratic leaders to choose from, President Biden and his supporters have continued to assert that Biden can and will win as…
-
Republicans want to sabotage US education
Former President Donald Trump’s official educational policy platform reveals plans to eliminate the Department of Education and seize the financial assets and endowments of elite U.S. universities. These proposals and others have convinced some liberal critics that the true goal of Republicans is to intentionally weaken U.S. education. Watch the above video as Straight Arrow…
-
Despite poor debate performance, Biden deserves our support
President Joe Biden himself admits that he delivered a “bad” performance in the first 2024 presidential debate. About a week after what some consider to be the worst debate performance in the history of televised debates, polls indicate that more voters than ever have an unfavorable opinion of the president, believe he is too old…
-
The modern-day Republican woman has terrifying role models
In a recent New York Magazine cover story entitled, “How Did Republican Women End Up Like This,” Rebecca Traister writes about some of the more polarizing examples of female Republican leaders and their positions on abortion, the transgender movement and women in general. With Republican women set to play a major role in the November…
Latest Opinions
-
U.S. Department of Defense
Congress still trying to figure out how to reduce wasteful military spending
-
DVIDS
US Navy, Air Force making waves with new weapons at RIMPAC
-
Getty Images
Israeli PM Netanyahu meets with Trump at Mar-a-Lago
-
Getty Images
Growing US nuclear power resurgence reaches the nation’s heartland
-
Getty Images
Beer from the sun, other solar thermal projects get government funding
Popular Opinions
-
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.