Debate over gun control laws is white hot after recent mass shootings in Buffalo, New York and Uvalde, Texas. The gunman in the Buffalo case allegedly published a 180-page “manifesto” that laid out plans to attack Black people and repeatedly cited the so-called “great replacement” theory. Straight Arrow News contributor Jordan Reid argues certain right-wing media groups indirectly — and ultimately explicitly — contribute to conditions making racially-motivated mass shootings all too common:
I don’t often speak directly to the right. I don’t see much point in it, frankly. In my experience, the right which is less the far right and just all of the right except for strangely enough, Liz Cheney – generally responds to direct statements and questions with some combination of avoidance and gaslighting.
But I’m angry today, and I would really, really like to hear what the right has to say about the Buffalo shooting beyond offering thoughts and prayers.
The Buffalo shooting is one in a long line of racially motivated slayings based on a narrative that has been, if not explicitly supported by the right-wing community, certainly implicitly. In the aftermath of shootings targeting people of color, the right likes to explain away the incidents as, for lack of a better word, blips.
It’s not because of easy access to military grade weaponry; it’s because of mental illness. It’s not because of dangerous and omnipresent racist rhetoric; it’s because of a few bad actors. And it’s certainly not because white supremacy has been not-so-slowly, not-so-insidiously emerging from the fringes of the far right ideology into the mainstream, its adherents gaining steam from amplification by outlets like Fox News and host Tucker Carlson. No, it couldn’t possibly be that. Except that’s exactly what happened. And what will continue to happen, so long as these media outlets continue to use their platforms to suggest that White people are being, quote, replaced, their God-given power being co-opted by people who don’t look like them, and are therefore lesser.
JORDAN REID: I don’t often speak directly to the right. I don’t see much point in it, frankly. In my experience, the right which is less the far right and just all of the right except for strangely enough, Liz Cheney – generally responds to direct statements and questions with some combination of avoidance and gaslighting.
But I’m angry today, and I would really, really like to hear what the right has to say about the Buffalo shooting beyond offering thoughts and prayers.
The Buffalo shooting is one in a long line of racially motivated slayings based on a narrative that has been, if not explicitly supported by the right-wing community, certainly implicitly.
On May 14, a gunman opened fire at a market in a predominantly Black neighborhood of Buffalo, New York. The gunman wore military-style protective gear, and carried a semi-automatic rifle. He killed ten people, and wounded three more and 13 people in all were victims, 11 of the 13 hurt or killed in the attack were Black.
In the aftermath of shootings targeting people of color, the right likes to explain away the incidents as, for lack of a better word, blips.
It’s not because of easy access to military grade weaponry; it’s because of mental illness. It’s not because of dangerous and omnipresent racist rhetoric; it’s because of a few bad actors.
And it’s certainly not because white supremacy has been not-so-slowly, not-so-insidiously emerging from the fringes of the far right ideology into the mainstream,
Its adherents gaining steam from amplification by outlets like Fox News and host Tucker Carlson. No, it couldn’t possibly be that. Except that’s exactly what happened. And what will continue to happen, so long as these media outlets continue to use their platforms to suggest that white people are being, quote, replaced, their God-given power being co-opted by people who don’t look like them, and are therefore lesser.
Elements of the so-called Replacement Theory, apparently cited by the gunman in a “manifesto” – make frequent appearances on Tucker Carlson’s hugely popular weeknight show, albeit with terms like “the elites” or “the ruling class” substituting for, you know, Jews.
Among other claims, the theory holds that falling birthrates – due in part to feminist ideologies and increasing support for gender non-conformative individuals – and lax immigration policies are leading to the literal replacement of white people.
The theory has been cited in several mass shootings since 2018, including the synagogue shooting in Pittsburgh and the El Paso Walmart shooting. “They” want to replace “you.”
It’s a simple narrative, and an effective one, it’s commonly used by authoritarian leaders to fire people up. Think Fox News doesn’t know this? Think again.
According to an analysis in The New York Times, Carlson supported the idea that white voters are being replaced with voters from the “Third World” or immigrants in over four hundred episodes. It’s not exactly the dictionary definition of a blip.
TUCKER CARLSON: we’re sad to tell you, a horrifying amount of violence in the united states over the weekend as increasingly there is
JORDAN REID: What happened in Buffalo is horrible, it’s unthinkable and I’m sure you’ll hear people on the right say that. It’s an easy thing to say. The harder thing, as anyone who is trying to raise children to be good people knows, is to turn that harsh lens onto yourself. Except for in this case the result isn’t a playground altercation, it’s a national tragedy.
So I have to ask those on the right – not that I expect an answer – at what point does implicit sanctioning become explicit support? I’d argue that we’re there. I’d argue that We’ve been there a very long time but no matter how many times we say the quiet part out loud, the result is the same: Distraction, blame shifting, redirection, and, ultimately, nothing at all.
Jordan Reid
Author; Founding Editor, Ramshackle Glam
View Video LibraryShare
. . .
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Commentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
Methane is the low-hanging fruit at COP28 climate summit
3 hrs ago
Peter Zeihan
Can far-right Wilders consolidate his power in the Netherlands?
Yesterday
Peter Zeihan
Argentina President-elect Javier Milei is no Donald Trump
Friday
Peter Zeihan
Why I’m done with Twitter (X) … and Elon Musk
Thursday
Peter Zeihan
Right-wing media played a role in Buffalo shooting
May 26, 2022
Share
. . .
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
By Straight Arrow News
Debate over gun control laws is white hot after recent mass shootings in Buffalo, New York and Uvalde, Texas. The gunman in the Buffalo case allegedly published a 180-page “manifesto” that laid out plans to attack Black people and repeatedly cited the so-called “great replacement” theory. Straight Arrow News contributor Jordan Reid argues certain right-wing media groups indirectly — and ultimately explicitly — contribute to conditions making racially-motivated mass shootings all too common:
JORDAN REID: I don’t often speak directly to the right. I don’t see much point in it, frankly. In my experience, the right which is less the far right and just all of the right except for strangely enough, Liz Cheney – generally responds to direct statements and questions with some combination of avoidance and gaslighting.
But I’m angry today, and I would really, really like to hear what the right has to say about the Buffalo shooting beyond offering thoughts and prayers.
The Buffalo shooting is one in a long line of racially motivated slayings based on a narrative that has been, if not explicitly supported by the right-wing community, certainly implicitly.
On May 14, a gunman opened fire at a market in a predominantly Black neighborhood of Buffalo, New York. The gunman wore military-style protective gear, and carried a semi-automatic rifle. He killed ten people, and wounded three more and 13 people in all were victims, 11 of the 13 hurt or killed in the attack were Black.
In the aftermath of shootings targeting people of color, the right likes to explain away the incidents as, for lack of a better word, blips.
It’s not because of easy access to military grade weaponry; it’s because of mental illness. It’s not because of dangerous and omnipresent racist rhetoric; it’s because of a few bad actors.
And it’s certainly not because white supremacy has been not-so-slowly, not-so-insidiously emerging from the fringes of the far right ideology into the mainstream,
Its adherents gaining steam from amplification by outlets like Fox News and host Tucker Carlson. No, it couldn’t possibly be that. Except that’s exactly what happened. And what will continue to happen, so long as these media outlets continue to use their platforms to suggest that white people are being, quote, replaced, their God-given power being co-opted by people who don’t look like them, and are therefore lesser.
Elements of the so-called Replacement Theory, apparently cited by the gunman in a “manifesto” – make frequent appearances on Tucker Carlson’s hugely popular weeknight show, albeit with terms like “the elites” or “the ruling class” substituting for, you know, Jews.
Among other claims, the theory holds that falling birthrates – due in part to feminist ideologies and increasing support for gender non-conformative individuals – and lax immigration policies are leading to the literal replacement of white people.
The theory has been cited in several mass shootings since 2018, including the synagogue shooting in Pittsburgh and the El Paso Walmart shooting. “They” want to replace “you.”
It’s a simple narrative, and an effective one, it’s commonly used by authoritarian leaders to fire people up. Think Fox News doesn’t know this? Think again.
According to an analysis in The New York Times, Carlson supported the idea that white voters are being replaced with voters from the “Third World” or immigrants in over four hundred episodes. It’s not exactly the dictionary definition of a blip.
TUCKER CARLSON: we’re sad to tell you, a horrifying amount of violence in the united states over the weekend as increasingly there is
JORDAN REID: What happened in Buffalo is horrible, it’s unthinkable and I’m sure you’ll hear people on the right say that. It’s an easy thing to say. The harder thing, as anyone who is trying to raise children to be good people knows, is to turn that harsh lens onto yourself. Except for in this case the result isn’t a playground altercation, it’s a national tragedy.
So I have to ask those on the right – not that I expect an answer – at what point does implicit sanctioning become explicit support? I’d argue that we’re there. I’d argue that We’ve been there a very long time but no matter how many times we say the quiet part out loud, the result is the same: Distraction, blame shifting, redirection, and, ultimately, nothing at all.
Viral Big Mac video is misleading as inflation cools
In December 2022, an Idaho man ordered a limited-edition smoked half-pound Big Mac meal with a side of fries and a soda. The total cost came to $16.10. Now, one year later, his social media post on the purchase is going viral, and is attracting interest from right-leaning outlets like the New York Post, the
Thursday
Trump’s ‘vermin’ rhetoric is straight from Hitler playbook
On Nov. 11, Donald Trump referred to liberals as “vermin.” The United Nations widely recognizes this rhetorical dehumanization as a crucial prerequisite for organized violence, terrorism and genocide. Adolf Hitler’s Nazi party, for instance, repeatedly used the German word for “vermin” to describe Jewish populations before, during and after the Holocaust. Straight Arrow News contributor
Nov 24
Israel-Hamas war should not punish innocent civilians in Gaza
The mortality and human suffering in Gaza is horrific, with 0.5% of Gaza’s total population killed and 60%-70% of all Gazans displaced from their homes in the past five weeks since Oct. 7. In the U.S., controversy over supporting Palestine or Israel is on the rise, leading to heated protests and — in some cases
Nov 16
Scottish baby box highlights the failings of US childcare
On TikTok, a woman in Scotland showed the contents of a “baby box” care package that expecting mothers receive from their government, which even included a tiny mattress for the baby. The video has sparked a debate on the other side of the Atlantic, where U.S. state and federal governments restrict access to maternal healthcare
Nov 9
Speaker Mike Johnson is an extremist and insurrectionist
The new speaker of the House, Rep. Mike Johnson, R-La., was the fourth nominee for the job after the ousting of Kevin McCarthy. A staunch conservative and Trump ally, Johnson authored numerous bills restricting abortion access, and has defended Louisiana’s same-sex marriage ban before the Supreme Court. He was also a key figure in the
Nov 2
Media Miss
Underreported stories from each side
Speaker Johnson gives Biden an ultimatum on Ukraine funding, immigration
14 sources | 0% from the left
Reuters
Special counsel outlines bid to show Trump motive, knowledge of plan to stay in power
12 sources | 0% from the right
AP Images
Latest Opinions
@Maria_Drutska via X
Multiple fires destroy military manufacturing plants deep inside Russia
Watch :51
5 mins ago
Getty Images
FBI interviewed priest, choir director when creating ‘anti-Catholic’ memo
Watch 1:43
27 mins ago
Getty Images
Ukraine, low on most everything, enters ‘new phase’ of war
Watch 3:23
39 mins ago
AP Images
‘Blinking red lights everywhere’: FBI Director Wray warns of terror threats
Watch 1:33
2 hrs ago
Getty Images
Top economists say no recession likely in 2024 after predicting one for 2023
Watch 2:47
3 hrs ago
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
US officials corrupting Biden’s Israel-Hamas position
2 hrs ago
Ben Weingarten
Great journalists must be fearless in face of threats
4 hrs ago
Ruben Navarrette
GOP prediction of economic disaster under Biden never happened
Yesterday
David Pakman
Biden losing support of Black Americans, identity politics is to blame
Friday
Star Parker
Politics
FBI interviewed priest, choir director when creating ‘anti-Catholic’ memo
27 mins ago
‘Blinking red lights everywhere’: FBI Director Wray warns of terror threats
White House warns U.S. is running out of money for Ukraine aid: The Morning Rundown, Dec. 5, 2023
Getty Images
U.S.
Top economists say no recession likely in 2024 after predicting one for 2023
3 hrs ago
Inside Dave Chappelle’s ‘Art as Activism’ workshop he started after ‘The Closer’ controversy
Border talks fall apart in Senate days before vote on Biden’s aid package
Getty Images
International
Multiple fires destroy military manufacturing plants deep inside Russia
5 mins ago
Ukraine, low on most everything, enters ‘new phase’ of war
White House calls protest at Israeli restaurant in Philadelphia an act of antisemitism
@Maria_Drutska via X
Tech
Spotify’s latest round of layoffs to cut 1,500 jobs in battle to become profitable
Yesterday
Wireless-charging public road in Detroit expands range of EVs
Ex-Google CEO warns of AI threats to humanity within 5-10 years
Getty Images