![The silence surrounding the leak of the Dobbs opinion hurts the credibility of the Supreme Court. Is the court taking the probe seriously?](https://san.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Silence-on-Dobbs-opinion-leak-a-blow-to-SCOTUS-credibility.png?w=1920)
Commentary
-
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
Chief Justice John Roberts called the leak of Samuel Alito’s draft Dobbs opinion an “egregious breach.”
So what does he call it when we have no earthly idea if the person responsible for the “egregious breach” is being brought to justice?
The AP asked SCOTUS a bunch of questions about the leak – two months after the investigation had been announced — including whether it was still investigating it. The Court answered none of them.
Already there were lingering questions about the parts of the probe we did know something about.
We don’t know why the Supreme Court’s marshal was tabbed to lead it, nor if she had the resources to get the job done. We don’t know what the probe entailed beyond the fact, reportedly, the Court was asking clerks for cell phone records and to sign affidavits in connection with the probe, and that the marshal collected electronic devices from some Court employees.
We don’t know whether the Court will announce the findings of its investigation – starting with who the leaker was – nor the punishment the leaker will face, and what the Court will do to ensure a leak like this never happens again.
Now the universe of people who could have obtained and leaked the opinion – described as “a person familiar with the court’s proceedings” in the Dobbs case – is small.
If the Court doesn’t know by now who leaked it, isn’t this rank incompetence? If the Court does know who leaked it, but is sitting on it, how could we see this as anything but political?
What could be more important to protecting the Court’s integrity and credibility than to show it has zero tolerance for and will stop at nothing to punish the person responsible for such a devastating attack on the Court’s ability to do its most basic duty: Deliberate, discreetly, and insulated from political pressure and intimidation.
Silence on the probe only compounds the error of not ruling immediately in the wake of the leak, which fueled — what else — but a campaign of political pressure and intimidation, including an assassination plot against Justice Brett Kavanaugh.
Does the chief justice, so attuned to public opinion about the Court, think the probe can be dismissed as some kind of internal matter to be handled privately, and to fade away?
Are one or more justices involved in the leak? Could that explain Roberts’s silence?
The longer he keeps mum, the greater the speculation will grow.
Surely the chief justice doesn’t think fostering this speculation is in the interest of the Court as an institution, which he claims to care so deeply about?
Of course the Chief Justice’s past attempts to protect the Court as an institution did nothing of the sort, either. Remember, he rewrote Obamacare as a tax to save it.
He failed in his attempt to split the baby in issuing a similarly tortured Dobbs concurrence, while also failing to flip Justice Kavanaugh towards his favored position. And he’s pursued an “incrementalist” approach in many of his rulings, not following the law to its logical conclusion, if in his view the results would be too jarring, or not deferential enough to precedent, no matter how wrongheaded.
For this institution defender, continued silence on the Dobbs probe leak will perpetuate the damage of the “egregious breach” the longer it persists.
This is about more than meting out justice to an individual for a single act. That act was, in Chief Justice Roberts’s own words, a “betrayal of the confidences of the Court” – a singular blow against this most hallowed of institutions.
When is Chief Justice Roberts going to act like it?
-
‘Deep State’ failed to protect Trump
The stated mission of the United States Secret Service is to “ensure the safety and security of our protectees.” However, on July 13 in Butler, Pennsylvania, the Secret Service allowed a lone would-be assassin to fire a shot at former President Donald Trump, grazing his ear with a bullet. Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle resigned…
-
The Regime once again meddling in election to hurt Trump
On Tuesday, July 9, the U.S. Department of Justice issued a cybersecurity advisory warning companies about a Russian social media bot farm. U.S. officials told reporters that these Russian bots are targeting U.S. voter groups in key swing states and implied that the goal is to undermine President Joe Biden. Watch the above video as…
-
Clarence Thomas has it right on presidential immunity case
On July 1, the United States Supreme Court ruled in a 6-3 majority opinion for Trump v. United States that American presidents have absolute immunity from prosecution for actions that fall within their constitutional duties. The ruling asserts that evidence of official criminal acts committed by a president cannot even be presented in any U.S.…
-
SCOTUS’ Murthy v. Missouri ruling will live in infamy
On June 26, the U.S. Supreme Court sided with the federal government in the Murthy v. Missouri case regarding official communications between the government and social media platforms. In a 6-3 decision written by Justice Amy Coney Barrett, the court stated that the plaintiffs did not have the legal standing to seek an injunction against…
-
Anti-Trumpers care about power, not democracy
News commentators across the political spectrum — including some contributors here at Straight Arrow News — have warned Americans about Donald Trump’s aspirations to make himself a dictator and effectively end the American republic if he regains power in November. Their warnings cite Trump’s own legal arguments, public statements and past behavior, including the attempted…
Latest Opinions
-
U.S. Department of Defense
Congress still trying to figure out how to reduce wasteful military spending
-
DVIDS
US Navy, Air Force making waves with new weapons at RIMPAC
-
Getty Images
Israeli PM Netanyahu meets with Trump at Mar-a-Lago
-
Getty Images
Growing US nuclear power resurgence reaches the nation’s heartland
-
Getty Images
Beer from the sun, other solar thermal projects get government funding
Popular Opinions
-
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.