According to U.S. Border Patrol data, nearly 2.4 million migrants were arrested at the southwestern border this year, the highest number ever recorded. Republicans have been increasing criticism of President Joe Biden’s immigration policies ahead of the coming midterm elections. Former President Donald Trump recently told a crowd in Robstown, Texas that immigrants are “invading our southern border.” Straight Arrow News contributor Ruben Navarrette contends Republican lawmakers like Gov. Greg Abbott, R-Texas, love to complain about migrants’ drain on the state’s resources, but the truth is something entirely different.
There’s a word, a magic word that Americans are guaranteed to hear quite often whenever the immigration issue comes up. It’s a word intend to gin up sympathy for states that have fallen on hard times, supposedly, because they’re being invaded by foreigners supposedly, through no fault of their own. Allegedly. That word is the B word:
Burden.
Texas Governor Greg Abbott and Arizona Governor Doug Ducey, both Republicans, have bused migrants to Washington, D.C. and New York as part of a publicity stunt to score points with conservatives. It was a cruel maneuver and unfair one. The migrants in question had played by the rules. They turned themselves into federal authorities and they were waiting a decision on their asylum claims to defend their actions. The governor’s deployed the B word. Both complained about the enormous burden that their states are inflicted with due to illegal migration. After the first busts of what Abbott called unlawful migrants got to Washington, the governor of the Lone Star State tweeted, “Texas should not have to bear the burden of the Biden administration’s failure to secure the border.”
What burden? That’s a flat out lie. I lived in Texas for five years while I was writing for the Dallas Morning News. Take it from me. Illegal immigration is not a burden to Texans. It’s a boondoggle. In fact, it’s such a good deal that if it didn’t exist, Texas would have to go out and invent it just to keep their state’s economy afloat. See, the critics of illegal immigration, many of whom also oppose legal immigration, well, these critics like to talk about the cost of having millions of undocumented people roaming around the Lone Star State. They talk and talk about the pressure on schools, jails and the health care system. Fair enough. Fair enough. But funny thing, though…those same folks never talked about the benefits, the benefits of all that undocumented labor.
There’s a word, a magic word that Americans are guaranteed to hear quite often whenever the immigration issue comes up. It’s a word intend to gin up sympathy for states that have fallen on hard times, supposedly, because they’re being invaded by foreigners supposedly, through no fault of their own. Allegedly. That word is the B word burden. Texas Governor Greg Abbott and Arizona governor Doug Ducey. Both Republicans have bus migrants to Washington DC and New York as part of a publicity stunt to score points with conservatives. It was a cruel maneuver and unfair one. The migrants in question had played by the rules. They turned themselves into federal authorities and they were waiting a decision on their asylum claims to defend their actions. The governor’s deployed the B word. Both complained about the enormous burden that their states are inflicted with due to illegal migration. After the first busts of what Abbott called unlawful migrants got to Washington, the governor of the Lone Star State tweeted, quote, Texas should not have to bear the burden of the Biden administration’s failure to secure the border. What burden that’s a flat out lie. I lived in Texas for five years. While I was writing for the Dallas Morning News. Take it from me. Illegal immigration is not a burden to Texans. It’s a boondoggle. In fact, it’s such a good deal that if it didn’t exist, Texas would have to go out and invent it just to keep their state’s economy afloat. See the critics of illegal immigration, many of whom also pose legal immigration. But that’s a story for another day. Well, these critics like to talk about the cost of having millions of undocumented people roaming around the Lone Star State. They talk and talk about the pressure on schools, jails, and the health care system. Fair enough. Fair enough. But funny thing, though, those same folks never talked about the benefits, the benefits of all that undocumented labor. All that the state of Texas reaps from all those undocumented people spending their hard earned money to buy clothes and furniture and food and gas, not to mention paying taxes. That’s right, paying taxes, sales, taxes, property taxes, you name it, the undocumented are not immune to taxes. And then there’s the secondary benefit. The fact that these people do jobs that Texans won’t do not at any price, and that this allows Texas businesses from restaurants and hotels to farms and ranches, and well, just about anything, you name it to make money and go out and pay a bunch more in taxes. Someone should add all up and do a cost benefit analysis. Well guess what someone did. Jose Ivan Rodriguez Sanchez, a postdoctoral research fellow at the Baker Institute for Public Policy at Rice University, investigate this very topic and research paper. Sanchez set out to assess both the positive and negative effects of illegal immigration. He focused on the year 2018 when, according to the report, Texas had an estimated 1.6 million undocumented residents who made up 5.7% of the total state population. In 2018, Texas collected $2.4 billion from this group, and that was just in state taxes. For every $1 the Texas State Government spends on public services for undocumented immigrants The report found the state collects $1.21 in revenue. So let me get this straight. $1 goes out, and $1.21 comes back in. That’s some burden texts. I bet law states would take that deal in a heartbeat and not complain about it. Republicans are always talking about how people need to pull their own weight. There was strong arming the poor and bad mouthing welfare recipients and student loan borrowers who they claim want to get something for nothing. Well, now here they are the same Republicans playing the victim looking for sympathy, whining and complaining about the so called burden that they suffer from carrying around all these heavy bags of cash that just fell in their laps, thanks to illegal immigrants. States like Texas and Arizona have economies that hum along and good times and bad. And they owe their economic success to the same immigrants that they complain about every single day. Now, all of a sudden, they say they want to get rid of these migrants while continuing to reap the benefits of the economies that the migrants built. That’s not fair. That’s getting something for nothing. That’s welfare, Republican style.
Ruben Navarrette
Columnist, host & author
View Video LibraryShare
. . .
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Commentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
Argentina President-elect Javier Milei is no Donald Trump
Friday
Peter Zeihan
Why I’m done with Twitter (X) … and Elon Musk
Thursday
Peter Zeihan
‘It’s their land’: Americans debate Gaza, Israel and Hamas
Thursday
Dr. Frank Luntz
Small nuclear reactors are not the future of energy
Tuesday
Peter Zeihan
Texas claims of immigrant ‘burden’ is a flat out lie
Oct 25, 2022
Share
. . .
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
By Straight Arrow News
According to U.S. Border Patrol data, nearly 2.4 million migrants were arrested at the southwestern border this year, the highest number ever recorded. Republicans have been increasing criticism of President Joe Biden’s immigration policies ahead of the coming midterm elections. Former President Donald Trump recently told a crowd in Robstown, Texas that immigrants are “invading our southern border.” Straight Arrow News contributor Ruben Navarrette contends Republican lawmakers like Gov. Greg Abbott, R-Texas, love to complain about migrants’ drain on the state’s resources, but the truth is something entirely different.
There’s a word, a magic word that Americans are guaranteed to hear quite often whenever the immigration issue comes up. It’s a word intend to gin up sympathy for states that have fallen on hard times, supposedly, because they’re being invaded by foreigners supposedly, through no fault of their own. Allegedly. That word is the B word burden. Texas Governor Greg Abbott and Arizona governor Doug Ducey. Both Republicans have bus migrants to Washington DC and New York as part of a publicity stunt to score points with conservatives. It was a cruel maneuver and unfair one. The migrants in question had played by the rules. They turned themselves into federal authorities and they were waiting a decision on their asylum claims to defend their actions. The governor’s deployed the B word. Both complained about the enormous burden that their states are inflicted with due to illegal migration. After the first busts of what Abbott called unlawful migrants got to Washington, the governor of the Lone Star State tweeted, quote, Texas should not have to bear the burden of the Biden administration’s failure to secure the border. What burden that’s a flat out lie. I lived in Texas for five years. While I was writing for the Dallas Morning News. Take it from me. Illegal immigration is not a burden to Texans. It’s a boondoggle. In fact, it’s such a good deal that if it didn’t exist, Texas would have to go out and invent it just to keep their state’s economy afloat. See the critics of illegal immigration, many of whom also pose legal immigration. But that’s a story for another day. Well, these critics like to talk about the cost of having millions of undocumented people roaming around the Lone Star State. They talk and talk about the pressure on schools, jails, and the health care system. Fair enough. Fair enough. But funny thing, though, those same folks never talked about the benefits, the benefits of all that undocumented labor. All that the state of Texas reaps from all those undocumented people spending their hard earned money to buy clothes and furniture and food and gas, not to mention paying taxes. That’s right, paying taxes, sales, taxes, property taxes, you name it, the undocumented are not immune to taxes. And then there’s the secondary benefit. The fact that these people do jobs that Texans won’t do not at any price, and that this allows Texas businesses from restaurants and hotels to farms and ranches, and well, just about anything, you name it to make money and go out and pay a bunch more in taxes. Someone should add all up and do a cost benefit analysis. Well guess what someone did. Jose Ivan Rodriguez Sanchez, a postdoctoral research fellow at the Baker Institute for Public Policy at Rice University, investigate this very topic and research paper. Sanchez set out to assess both the positive and negative effects of illegal immigration. He focused on the year 2018 when, according to the report, Texas had an estimated 1.6 million undocumented residents who made up 5.7% of the total state population. In 2018, Texas collected $2.4 billion from this group, and that was just in state taxes. For every $1 the Texas State Government spends on public services for undocumented immigrants The report found the state collects $1.21 in revenue. So let me get this straight. $1 goes out, and $1.21 comes back in. That’s some burden texts. I bet law states would take that deal in a heartbeat and not complain about it. Republicans are always talking about how people need to pull their own weight. There was strong arming the poor and bad mouthing welfare recipients and student loan borrowers who they claim want to get something for nothing. Well, now here they are the same Republicans playing the victim looking for sympathy, whining and complaining about the so called burden that they suffer from carrying around all these heavy bags of cash that just fell in their laps, thanks to illegal immigrants. States like Texas and Arizona have economies that hum along and good times and bad. And they owe their economic success to the same immigrants that they complain about every single day. Now, all of a sudden, they say they want to get rid of these migrants while continuing to reap the benefits of the economies that the migrants built. That’s not fair. That’s getting something for nothing. That’s welfare, Republican style.
Biden risks losing Latino vote in 2024 election
Currently, 63.7 million Latinos live in the U.S. — around 19% of the total population. Historically, Latinos have predominantly supported left-leaning candidates in elections. However, recent poll data for the 2024 election suggests a shift, with more Latinos indicating support for Republican candidates. Straight Arrow News contributor Ruben Navarrette asserts that President Joe Biden has
Tuesday
Americans should be grateful for Mexican, Canadian neighbors
The United States is fortunate to share its borders with amicable North American neighbors. It boasts the longest undefended border globally with Canada and a 2,000-mile border with Mexico. The U.S. government recognizes Canada as a “neighbor, friend and ally” while referring to Mexico as a “strategic partner.” Straight Arrow News contributor Ruben Navarrette reminds
Nov 21
Don’t move on from Hamas’ horrific attack on Israel
As a pro-Israel rally unfolds in Washington, D.C., a substantial segment of the global population is condemning Israel’s war in Gaza, which has now killed over 10,000 Palestinians and displaced roughly 1.5 million civilians from their homes. Large pro-Palestinian demonstrations have become common around the world and in the United States. Straight Arrow News contributor
Nov 14
As the world moves on, never forget Oct. 7, 2023
Hamas’ surprise Oct. 7 attack claimed over 1,400 Israeli lives and has been called the worst day for the Jewish people since the Holocaust. The subsequent Israeli siege and bombing of Gaza, which has now killed over 10,000 Palestinians, unleashed a storm of arguments across the internet and around the world. Straight Arrow News contributor
Nov 7
Why Americans sympathize with both Palestinians and Israelis
The Israeli-Palestinian conflict again grabbed hold of the world’s attention following the Oct. 7 Hamas attack in southern Israel. While American public support for Israel increased in the wake of that attack, a majority of Americans today say they empathize with the people of both Israel and Palestine. Straight Arrow News contributor Ruben Navarrette explains
Oct 31
Media Miss
Stories each side is underreporting
Anti-Abortion Medical Groups Sue to Stop Washington Inquiry
6 sources | 0% from the left
AP Images
Georgia Republicans advance House and Senate maps as congressional proposal waits in the wings
20 sources | 6% from the right
Getty Images
Latest Opinions
Reuters
SpaceX launches S. Korean spy satellite days after North’s launch
Watch 1:18
Yesterday
Axios
Ex-Google CEO warns of AI threats to humanity within 5-10 years
Watch 1:28
Yesterday
AP Images
New York City officials consider first US congestion pricing program
Watch 1:54
Yesterday
Reuters
Filipino coast guard builds station in contested South China Sea
Watch 1:49
Yesterday
Getty Images
Texas sues Pfizer, says company lied about efficacy of COVID vaccine
Watch 1:53
Yesterday
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Biden losing support of Black Americans, identity politics is to blame
Yesterday
Star Parker
Trump’s push to prosecute Capitol Police reveals anti-democracy stance
Yesterday
Dr. Rashad Richey
Viral Big Mac video is misleading as inflation cools
Thursday
Jordan Reid
To address poverty, tax the rich and vote blue
Wednesday
Adrienne Lawrence
Politics
Sen. Rand Paul performs Heimlich maneuver on choking colleague
Friday
Tommy Tuberville says military holds could be resolved in about a week
Henry Kissinger dies at 100: The Morning Rundown, Nov. 30, 2023
Getty Images
U.S.
SpaceX launches S. Korean spy satellite days after North’s launch
Yesterday
Texas sues Pfizer, says company lied about efficacy of COVID vaccine
Dave Chappelle asked to write George Santos joke, here’s his response
Reuters
International
Filipino coast guard builds station in contested South China Sea
Yesterday
Airstrikes resume in Gaza as cease-fire ends: The Morning Rundown, Dec. 1, 2023
Anti-immigration signs spark hate crime probes in Northern Ireland
Reuters
Tech
Ex-Google CEO warns of AI threats to humanity within 5-10 years
Yesterday
Judge blocks Montana TikTok ban from taking effect Jan. 1
It’s ChatGPT’s birthday. Here’s how it changed the AI game in 1 short year.
Axios