Harvard has been under fire lately, and understandably so, given how my alma mater, which once had, as part of a shameful chapter, blatant admissions quotas to keep out Jews in the 1930s, how my school now appears to have gone back in time and become once again a hotbed of antisemitism. “The fish rots from the head,” as goes the old Yiddish saying, and so if antisemitism has indeed taken root on the river Charles, it happened with an assist from spineless Harvard administrators, who had been way too lenient with ill-mannered students who stormed through campus calling for an intifada, aka the mass slaughter of Jews. Meanwhile, the liberal media worked overtime to provide an assist of its own to Dr. Claudine Gay, Harvard’s first Black president. Gay narrowly escaped getting canned, despite the fact that she flunked the leadership test and failed Jewish students on campus. And if that wasn’t bad enough, she then doubled down on failure by turning in a pathetic performance before Congress, where she couldn’t even summon the moral clarity to say that calling for the killing of Jews violated Harvard’s code of conduct. Even after all those mistakes and missteps, Gay kept her job, thanks to the support of the Harvard Corporation, one of two ruling bodies that oversee the university. Members of the board didn’t have the guts to fire a racial trailblazer. After all, it took Harvard nearly 400 years to appoint the first Black woman president after a long parade of White men. The school couldn’t really unceremoniously show her the door after less than six months on the job. Harvard was already being called antisemitic, it didn’t want to add racist to the list. Aside from the race issue, Gay’s job security was probably also helped along by the fact that the media accepted her narrative, that she was this kind of heroic warrior for free speech, as opposed to what she really was: A bureaucrat so focused on self-preservation that she was eager to avoid conflict. And that conflict avoidance meant not forcing students at America’s oldest university to conduct themselves in a respectful manner toward one another. That bizarre strategy almost cost Gay her job. It also subjected Harvard to a national ridicule and accusations of, don’t laugh, mind control. I spent the last few weeks being told by people who never went to Harvard that Harvard brainwashes its students and indoctrinates young people to think alike. That’s news to me. And I’m sure it will be news to other Harvard alumni. So you get a handful of my tribe together and you’ll get 30 or 40 or 50 different opinions, a lot of argument, maybe even a few fistfights. Just look at our political class. Secretary of State Antony Blinken, a Democrat, went to Harvard, but so did his predecessor, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo. They don’t agree on a whole lot. Ted Cruz, a Texas Republican, went to Harvard. And so did Texas Democrat Julian Castro. They’ve both been friends of mine for more than 20 years, and I can tell you this much: Those two fellas have completely different worldviews. Finally, look at the Supreme Court, where the current lineup of justices includes four graduates of Harvard Law School: Ketanji Brown Jackson and Elena Kagan on the left, Neil Gorsuch on the right, and John Roberts somewhere in the center. As someone with two Harvard degrees, believe me when I tell you this, there is no brainwashing going on here. Harvard doesn’t tell you what to think. It never, has never will. It’s content if it manages to get you to actually think, and maybe to think critically. What you do from there is on you. President Gay should now think long and hard about what she’s been through these past few weeks, and sadly, what she put Harvard through, and then she should resolve to do much better going forward.
Related
Ruben Navarrette
Columnist, host & author
View Video LibraryCommentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
Why Putin axed Shoigu
Yesterday
Peter Zeihan
New roles for Russia, North Korea, Iran in global arms trade
Monday
Peter Zeihan
Why interest rates will be higher for longer
Friday
Peter Zeihan
‘The worst it’s ever been’: Young Americans on democracy
Thursday
Dr. Frank Luntz
Don’t blame Harvard for Claudine Gay’s poor leadership
Dec 19, 2023
By Straight Arrow News
Following the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel and Israel’s subsequent military response, reports have documented increasing antisemitism on elite college campuses, including Harvard. Dr. Claudine Gay, Harvard’s president, faced accusations of failing to discipline student protesters who advocated for the genocide of Jews. Calls for her resignation intensified after a lackluster performance on Capitol Hill. Gay later walked back some of her testimony, clarifying that “calls for violence against our Jewish community have no place at Harvard.”
Straight Arrow News contributor Ruben Navarrette contends that Dr. Gay, Harvard’s first Black female president, has inadequately managed the esteemed institution through the controversy. He suggests not solely blaming Harvard, however, but its weak leaders, who may be overly eager to avoid conflict and preserve their positions.
Harvard has been under fire lately, and understandably so, given how my alma mater, which once had, as part of a shameful chapter, blatant admissions quotas to keep out Jews in the 1930s — how my school now appears to have gone back in time and become once again a hotbed of antisemitism.
“The fish rots from the head,” as goes the old Yiddish saying, and so if antisemitism has indeed taken root on the river Charles, it happened with an assist from spineless Harvard administrators, who had been way too lenient with ill-mannered students who stormed through campus calling for an intifada, aka the mass slaughter of Jews.
Meanwhile, the liberal media worked overtime to provide an assist of its own to Dr. Claudine Gay, Harvard’s first Black president. Gay narrowly escaped getting canned, despite the fact that she flunked the leadership test and failed Jewish students on campus. And if that wasn’t bad enough, she then doubled down on failure by turning in a pathetic performance before Congress, where she couldn’t even summon the moral clarity to say that calling for the killing of Jews violated Harvard’s code of conduct. Even after all those mistakes and missteps, Gay kept her job.
Harvard has been under fire lately, and understandably so, given how my alma mater, which once had, as part of a shameful chapter, blatant admissions quotas to keep out Jews in the 1930s, how my school now appears to have gone back in time and become once again a hotbed of antisemitism. “The fish rots from the head,” as goes the old Yiddish saying, and so if antisemitism has indeed taken root on the river Charles, it happened with an assist from spineless Harvard administrators, who had been way too lenient with ill-mannered students who stormed through campus calling for an intifada, aka the mass slaughter of Jews. Meanwhile, the liberal media worked overtime to provide an assist of its own to Dr. Claudine Gay, Harvard’s first Black president. Gay narrowly escaped getting canned, despite the fact that she flunked the leadership test and failed Jewish students on campus. And if that wasn’t bad enough, she then doubled down on failure by turning in a pathetic performance before Congress, where she couldn’t even summon the moral clarity to say that calling for the killing of Jews violated Harvard’s code of conduct. Even after all those mistakes and missteps, Gay kept her job, thanks to the support of the Harvard Corporation, one of two ruling bodies that oversee the university. Members of the board didn’t have the guts to fire a racial trailblazer. After all, it took Harvard nearly 400 years to appoint the first Black woman president after a long parade of White men. The school couldn’t really unceremoniously show her the door after less than six months on the job. Harvard was already being called antisemitic, it didn’t want to add racist to the list. Aside from the race issue, Gay’s job security was probably also helped along by the fact that the media accepted her narrative, that she was this kind of heroic warrior for free speech, as opposed to what she really was: A bureaucrat so focused on self-preservation that she was eager to avoid conflict. And that conflict avoidance meant not forcing students at America’s oldest university to conduct themselves in a respectful manner toward one another. That bizarre strategy almost cost Gay her job. It also subjected Harvard to a national ridicule and accusations of, don’t laugh, mind control. I spent the last few weeks being told by people who never went to Harvard that Harvard brainwashes its students and indoctrinates young people to think alike. That’s news to me. And I’m sure it will be news to other Harvard alumni. So you get a handful of my tribe together and you’ll get 30 or 40 or 50 different opinions, a lot of argument, maybe even a few fistfights. Just look at our political class. Secretary of State Antony Blinken, a Democrat, went to Harvard, but so did his predecessor, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo. They don’t agree on a whole lot. Ted Cruz, a Texas Republican, went to Harvard. And so did Texas Democrat Julian Castro. They’ve both been friends of mine for more than 20 years, and I can tell you this much: Those two fellas have completely different worldviews. Finally, look at the Supreme Court, where the current lineup of justices includes four graduates of Harvard Law School: Ketanji Brown Jackson and Elena Kagan on the left, Neil Gorsuch on the right, and John Roberts somewhere in the center. As someone with two Harvard degrees, believe me when I tell you this, there is no brainwashing going on here. Harvard doesn’t tell you what to think. It never, has never will. It’s content if it manages to get you to actually think, and maybe to think critically. What you do from there is on you. President Gay should now think long and hard about what she’s been through these past few weeks, and sadly, what she put Harvard through, and then she should resolve to do much better going forward.
Related
US college protests test First Amendment limits
Protests against Israel’s alleged genocide in Gaza have spread across university campuses around the globe. While most protests initially coalesced around anti-genocide sentiments and a shared value for human life, some critics have observed slogans, rhetoric and behavior that they claim has become more alarming over time. Accusations have surfaced of “outside agitators” deliberately spoiling…
Tuesday
Arizona bill legalizing shooting migrants is part of GOP brand
In February 2024, Arizona Republicans proposed a bill that would have permitted property owners to murder anyone accused of trespassing on their property. Although the bill did not explicitly mention immigrants, Arizona State Rep. Justin Heap (R) stated in a hearing that the bill aimed to address a perceived loophole through which migrants have moved…
May 8
Republicans unraveling before our very eyes
In less than a year, Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., has filed two motions to remove House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La. Her latest motion came after she and other staunch conservative U.S. representatives expressed outrage with Johnson’s management of a $95 billion international defense bill and a $1.2 trillion federal funding bill, which were both…
Apr 30
Trump supporters want to be victims of anti-white racism
The racial anxieties of conservative white Americans are certainly nothing new to U.S. history, but in recent years observers have warned of a range of factors that may be radicalizing right-leaning Americans into political violence and extremism. Donald Trump, in particular, often receives credit for normalizing this extremism for a new generation of Americans. Straight…
Apr 23
Texas is Hispanic, and that’s not going to change
Hispanic people now make up the largest ethnic group in Texas, according to the latest U.S. census data, and almost half of all minors in the state are Hispanic or Latino. This data feeds the fears of some right-wing Americans who believe in the “great replacement” theory. The theory states that non-white populations are displacing…
Apr 16
Underreported stories from each side
Biden administration preparing to hand out 10K migrant ID cards in several US cities: report
14 sources | 0% from the left
Reuters
GOP Sen. Mitt Romney says Biden should have pardoned Trump
12 sources | 17% from the right
Reuters
Latest Stories
US-built pier for humanitarian aid anchored in Gaza
Watch 0:54
1 hr ago
Slovakia’s prime minister in serious condition after assassination attempt
Watch 0:57
1 hr ago
Putin meets with Xi in China as leaders look to strengthen ties
Watch 6:33
3 hrs ago
More American workers cheating to pass workforce drug tests
Watch 2:04
17 hrs ago
Raskin opens probe into Trump’s $1 billion request to oil executives
Watch 1:52
18 hrs ago
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Biden sees Trump jail time as sole path to reelection
23 hrs ago
Newt Gingrich
Why the United States must regulate ghost guns
23 hrs ago
Adrienne Lawrence
Unfair Biden executive order favors Democrats in November
Yesterday
Ben Weingarten
US college protests test First Amendment limits
Tuesday
Ruben Navarrette