Skip to main content
Politics

Democratic proposals to change the Supreme Court

Share

Democratic lawmakers are pushing to change the Supreme Court. Demands to “pack the court” began in earnest during the 2020 election after former President Donald Trump saw his three nominees to the high court confirmed. Those calls have seen a revival in recent weeks following multiple rulings from the latest SCOTUS term.

Several high-profile decisions led to repeated criticism of and calls to change the so-called “conservative” court that moved rightward with the confirmations of Trump nominees Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett.

So what proposals to change the court have actually been floated?

With a new Congress in 2021, Democrats pushed a bill to expand the Supreme Court from nine justices to 13. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., rejected the legislation, saying she had “no intention to bring it to the floor,” Politico reported.

University of Tennessee law professor and founder of InstaPundit Glenn Reynolds wrote a piece for Newsweek this week suggesting that court be expanded to 59 seats.

Looking back on the June incident where a suspect was arrested for threatening to kill Justice Kavanaugh, Reynolds wrote, “Indisputably, we live in a time when assassinating, impeaching, or otherwise removing a single Supreme Court Justice could flip a closely divided Court on important national issues, and when more and more extremists are talking about using violence to get their way in politics.”

“On a court with nine members divided 5-4 on many issues, you only have to get rid of one person. Especially when that person would be replaced by a president of the other party, as would have happened if Kavanaugh had been killed,” he continued. “That’s too appealing a target for some of the crazies out there, especially when ‘respectable’ people in the press and in politics are egging on the anger.”

Reynolds then offered an idea to make the court more “resilient”: add 50 justices to the court, one from each state.

“Each state’s governor would nominate a member of the Court from his or her state, who would then be confirmed by the Senate as usual,” he explained.

The likelihood of changing the court’s size is small, especially since President Joe Biden has said he’s not on board with the idea. And the American people don’t like it either. A new poll taken after the court overturned Roe v. Wade last month showed that most Americans (54%) still oppose the idea of expanding the court. Just a third (34%) said they were OK with it.

But changing the size of the court is not the Democrats’ only proposal.

Several lawmakers are proposing term limits for Supreme Court justices, which would allow each president to appoint at least one justice. One proposal from Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., would create 18-year terms for members of the high court. The bill would create a system in which the president would have a scheduled Supreme Court appointment every two years.

However, legal analysts have noted that creating term limits for justices would require a constitutional amendment since Article III of the U.S. Constitution grants federal judges lifetime appointments.

MAHMOUD BENNETT: IN PART 1 WE TALKED ABOUT GROWING CALLS TO EXPAND THE SUPREME COURT AND HOW THE POWER TO DO IT LIES IN THE HANDS OF CONGRESS

BUT WHAT EXACTLY ARE SOME OF THE PROPOSALS THAT HAVE BEEN MADE

LET’S START WITH COURT PACKING

IN 2021 PROGRESSIVE DEMOCRATS PROPOSED A PLAN TO CHANGE THE NUMBER OF JUSTICES FROM NINE TO 13. IT WAS REJECTED BY LEADERSHIP

BUT THE IDEA IS STILL ALIVE WITH MORE FRINGE PROPOSALS MAKING HEADLINES RECENTLY. ONE LAW PROFESSOR ADVOCATING FOR AN INCREASE TO 59 JUSTICES – ADDING ONE FROM EACH STATE. THE GOAL BEING TO REFRAME THE COURT AS MORE OF A LEGISLATIVE BODY

THEN THERE’S TERM LIMITS. THIS IDEA WOULD REQUIRE JUSTICES TO STEP DOWN AFTER A CERTAIN PERIOD OF TIME – THERE’S BEEN SUPPORT FROM BOTH SIDES BUT EXPERTS SAY IT WOULD REQUIRE A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT GIVEN THAT LIFE TERM LIMITS ARE THE LAW OF THE LAND

*REGARDLESS – THESE IDEAS ARE CONTROVERSIAL* WHILE DEMOCRATS ARE PUSHING FOR BIG CHANGE – POLLS SHOW A MAJORITY OF AMERICANS DON’T AGREE WITH EXPANDING THE SUPREME COURT

BUT WHAT ARE YOUR THOUGHTS ON ALL OF THIS? LET US KNOW IN THE COMMENTS BELOW