Insurance companies want half of Maui wildfire victims’ $4B settlement

Nearly a year after wildfires tore through Maui, claiming over 100 lives and destroying thousands of structures, the aftermath continues to unfold in legal battles and proposed settlements. The wildfires, fueled by drought conditions, high winds and downed power lines, marked Hawaii’s worst natural disaster on record.

Over 2,000 structures were reduced to ashes, leaving a trail of devastation in their wake.

In response to the disaster, thousands of residents initiated legal action against Hawaiian Electric, the island’s utility provider, blaming it for the fires. Recently, a tentative settlement agreement emerged from court-ordered mediation, proposing a $4 billion payout from Hawaiian Electric and other implicated companies to compensate impacted families.

However, the proposal sparked controversy.

A significant portion of the settlement amount is being contested by insurance companies, including major players like Allstate and State Farm. These insurers are seeking approximately $2 billion from the settlement fund as reimbursement for claims they paid out following the wildfires. Residents and affected parties expressed criticism and argued that insurers are prioritizing profit over the needs of wildfire victims.

“This action arises out of the greed of Hawaii’s insurance industry to put their own selfish profits ahead of the suffering of the people of Maui who are the true victims of the Maui fires,” the lawsuit filed against the insurers states.

As of now, the insurers named in the suit have not publicly commented on the allegations. The lawsuit, brought by homeowners who lost their homes and loved ones in the fires, challenges the insurers’ claim for reimbursement before fully compensating their policyholders for their losses.

Meanwhile, despite the tentative agreement, the $4 billion settlement deal has not yet received final approval from the court. While it was a product of consensus during mediation sessions, the judge overseeing the case has yet to sign off on the proposal.

For the residents of Maui still grappling with impact of the wildfires, the resolution of these legal matters will determine the extent to which justice and recovery are achieved.