There is nothing funny about the situation in Gaza – where, in addition to the tens of thousands of lives lost, the citizens are currently facing a famine of proportions that may contribute to a ruling of genocide against Israel in the international court system. The images of starving children are haunting, unforgettable. There is also nothing funny about the 134 Israeli hostages remaining in Gaza under the control of Hamas, which presents a conundrum for comedians, especially those who tackle the political spectrum.
So, take recent SNL host Ramy Youssef, whose opening monologue directly addressed the conflict. The thing is, I loved the monologue. I did. It’s worth a watch if you haven’t seen the whole thing. I thought he was sincere and brave, and willing to speak on behalf of humanity rather than one “side” or the other. And somehow, while doing this, he also made me laugh, which is no easy feat.
The thing is, the news cycle is so unrelentingly negative, that…look, as human beings, at a certain point, you stop being able to absorb the information. It’s just too much, especially when the events taking place feel wholly out of your hands to do anything about.
(Sidenote: remember to vote for Biden, please. Even if you’re not a superfan, get yourself to the polls and participate in saving democracy. That you can do.)
Comedians on variously-sized stages around the country are, in increasing numbers, taking on the conflict. Some of the jokes elicit deserved groans from the audience. Others are more nuanced, managing to draw attention to the realities of life as a Jew or a Palestinian in a less-expected way…a way that may bring a different kind of awareness, may reach people who might not otherwise be reached.
There is a saying that goes something like “tragedy plus time equals comedy.” That’s not always so; not in cases of tremendous human suffering. You can also certainly argue that there is no right way to joke about tragedy, that’s an acceptable perspective, although not necessarily my own.
But when done right – and, like I said, it is no easy feat to get these kinds of jokes “right” – comedy has a way of reinvigorating a discussion, making things hurt a little less, just for a moment, and giving us the emotional and mental space to perhaps find a more common ground.
Commentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
‘Extreme’ or ‘fake’: Swing voters weigh Trump or Harris
Nov 4 Dr. Frank Luntz‘Strong’: Why some men say they’ll vote for Trump
Oct 29 Dr. Frank Luntz‘Easy answer is China’: National security experts discuss gravest concerns
Oct 24 Dr. Frank Luntz‘Awful’: Americans discuss Congress, Supreme Court, capitalism
Oct 18 Dr. Frank LuntzPolitical comedy has a role to play in Gaza
By Straight Arrow News
Political comedians in the U.S. have sometimes struggled to cover the war in Gaza, which has been defined by tremendous human suffering and high political polarization, none of which seems particularly funny. Comedian Ramy Youssef attempted to tackle some of those issues in an opening monologue of a recent “Saturday Night Live” (SNL) episode.
Straight Arrow News contributor Jordan Reid gives her review of Youssef’s speech and then discusses the wider problems that political comedians face when covering tragic events. She argues that there is a unique role for comedians to help create a common space for public discussion on wars and other severe disasters, especially when public emotions are running too hot for us to have civil debates in other forums.
There is nothing funny about the situation in Gaza — where, in addition to the tens of thousands of lives lost, the citizens are currently facing a famine of proportions that may contribute to a ruling of genocide against Israel in the international court system. The images of starving children are haunting, unforgettable. There is also nothing funny about the 134 Israeli hostages remaining in Gaza under the control of Hamas, which presents a conundrum for comedians, especially those who tackle the political spectrum.
So, take recent SNL host Ramy Youssef, whose opening monologue directly addressed the conflict. The thing is, I loved the monologue. I did. It’s worth a watch if you haven’t seen the whole thing. I thought he was sincere and brave, and willing to speak on behalf of humanity rather than one “side” or the other. And somehow, while doing this, he also made me laugh, which is no easy feat.
The thing is, the news cycle is so unrelentingly negative, that… look, as human beings, at a certain point, you stop being able to absorb the information. It’s just too much, especially when the events taking place feel wholly out of your hands to do anything about.
There is nothing funny about the situation in Gaza – where, in addition to the tens of thousands of lives lost, the citizens are currently facing a famine of proportions that may contribute to a ruling of genocide against Israel in the international court system. The images of starving children are haunting, unforgettable. There is also nothing funny about the 134 Israeli hostages remaining in Gaza under the control of Hamas, which presents a conundrum for comedians, especially those who tackle the political spectrum.
So, take recent SNL host Ramy Youssef, whose opening monologue directly addressed the conflict. The thing is, I loved the monologue. I did. It’s worth a watch if you haven’t seen the whole thing. I thought he was sincere and brave, and willing to speak on behalf of humanity rather than one “side” or the other. And somehow, while doing this, he also made me laugh, which is no easy feat.
The thing is, the news cycle is so unrelentingly negative, that…look, as human beings, at a certain point, you stop being able to absorb the information. It’s just too much, especially when the events taking place feel wholly out of your hands to do anything about.
(Sidenote: remember to vote for Biden, please. Even if you’re not a superfan, get yourself to the polls and participate in saving democracy. That you can do.)
Comedians on variously-sized stages around the country are, in increasing numbers, taking on the conflict. Some of the jokes elicit deserved groans from the audience. Others are more nuanced, managing to draw attention to the realities of life as a Jew or a Palestinian in a less-expected way…a way that may bring a different kind of awareness, may reach people who might not otherwise be reached.
There is a saying that goes something like “tragedy plus time equals comedy.” That’s not always so; not in cases of tremendous human suffering. You can also certainly argue that there is no right way to joke about tragedy, that’s an acceptable perspective, although not necessarily my own.
But when done right – and, like I said, it is no easy feat to get these kinds of jokes “right” – comedy has a way of reinvigorating a discussion, making things hurt a little less, just for a moment, and giving us the emotional and mental space to perhaps find a more common ground.
Trump’s extreme MAGA loyalist appointees are cause for alarm
Americans have tough work ahead if they want to remain free
Trump’s racist rally a preview of what’s to come if he wins
The case against TikTok
Why is Trump spreading lies about FEMA and disaster response?
Underreported stories from each side
FEMA officials ‘view Trump supporters as domestic terrorists,’ whistleblower tells House Oversight Committee
19 sources | 0% from the left AP ImagesGaetz sent more than $10k to two women who testified in House investigation: Reports
21 sources | 0% from the right Getty ImagesLatest Stories
Florida man charged in plot to blow up New York Stock Exchange
DOJ asks judge to force Google to sell off its Chrome web browser
Ukraine says Russia fires intercontinental ballistic missile
‘Bomb cyclone’ whips US Northwest, California with intense winds and rain
NYC Mayor Adams Names Jessica Tisch as NYPD Head
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trump poised to unleash transformative mandate
16 hrs ago Newt GingrichHow Gov. Gavin Newsom is ‘Trump-proofing’ his state
20 hrs ago Adrienne LawrenceTrump’s loyal cabinet picks to drive his policy agenda
Yesterday Ben WeingartenWhite identity politics scores another win
Yesterday Ruben Navarrette