Commentary
-
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
In 2018, the Supreme Court heard the case of Masterpiece Cakeshop versus Colorado Civil Rights Commission, the controversial and well-covered case about a Christian baker, Jack Phillips, being punished for refusing to bake a gay wedding cake. The Christian Baker won that case. So you think that would be the end of it? It would settle the debate on the issue? Well, not quite.
The decision is what constitutional scholars call a narrow ruling. This means that the decision made in that case only applies to that case and is not a precedent for future rulings. The court noted that the commission’s open hostility toward Phillips religious claims, but they stopped far short of answering the critical questions related to anti-discrimination law and our constitutionally protected religious liberties.
This is a debate that continues. So now, four years later, the Supreme Court is once again faced with this issue, as is the Congress. Recently, the court heard oral arguments regarding a devoutly Christian Colorado web designer, Lorie Smith, and Colorado’s pro-gay laws. Lorie wants to expand her business to serve online wedding registries, but wants to do so in a way that complements her faith.
Unfortunately, that Colorado law makes it nearly impossible. And there at the Supreme Court and the court heard those arguments this past Monday. And sadly, the antics and actions didn’t stop with Lorie. Jack Phillips, the Christian baker, he’s also back in court after being targeted by LGBTQ advocates for refusing to bake a transgender reveal cake. The Supreme Court’s attempt to avoid this issue and kick the can down the road has hurt us.
It’s only served the purpose of making both sides really, really angry. And now it’s spilling out into the Congress. Both the gay rights lobby and the religious community are at odds with each other. And the big question for all of society is, can we co-exist? Can these two groups live in the same country? One can only hope this time that they’ll be a difference, that there’ll be a reconciliation, that religious liberties are religious liberties protected in the Constitution regardless of what the gay activists want.
And as we await the court’s decision, it’s important that all Americans realize what is at risk, because in a free country, you can be compelled to act. However, you can’t be compelled, though, to act against your own faith and have threats from government action. We’re a free country. People are able to choose how they want to live. But now we’re talking about a conflicting worldview.
Is it acceptable for the government to force anyone to promote speech they fundamentally disagree with? We can only hope the court will answer these questions this time with a resounding no. We’ll know next summer. The left will have you believe that intrusions on religious liberties are necessary to protect the LGBTQ community. Similarly, advocates have argued that refusing to subject the religious community to harsh penalties will unleash a wave of racist, sexist and homophobic hate.
This is the lie we should all reject. Both Jack and Lorie never refuse services to the LGBTQ community. They just refused to endorse, promote or facilitate messages that defied their faith. America is a tolerant and loving country. We can have civil disagreements without demonizing each other. Or can we? Because this is coming to a head. Because at core, Lorie Smith and Jack Phillips are simply Christian business owners seeking to earn a living within the bounds of their faith in a free country.
They should be able to do so. They should be able to protect their religious liberties while serving their public without invoking such hatred response from the alphabet mafia that is now attempting to pass their agenda in Congress and have the president of the United States sign it into law.
-
House Speaker Johnson’s foreign aid bill shows a focused GOP
Following months of deliberation regarding U.S. assistance to its allies, the Senate approved a $95 billion aid package for Ukraine, Israel, and Taiwan. Republican House Speaker Mike Johnson spearheaded the approval of this wartime funding amidst renewed calls from Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., for him to resign. Straight Arrow News contributor Star Parker asserts…
-
Biden using taxpayer dollars to buy voters is indefensible
In July 2023, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned President Biden’s attempt to cancel more than $400 billion in student debt. Biden has since been exploring ways to bypass the ruling. Recently, he announced that over 270,000 individuals enrolled in his income-driven repayment plan (SAVE) will have $7.4 billion in debt canceled. This action brings the…
-
Trump should move ahead with federal abortion bans
Decades-long Republican efforts to roll back abortion access are now paying off in the aftermath of Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, the Supreme Court ruling which overturned Roe v. Wade. And yet today, an overwhelming majority of Americans say that they believe at least some abortion access should be protected. GOP presidential candidate Donald…
-
Biden’s White House shows hostility toward Christianity on Easter
President Biden and First Lady Jill Biden recently hosted an education-themed Easter egg roll at the White House, while also acknowledging International Transgender Day of Visibility. Some Republicans criticized the White House for banning religious themes from designs in the children’s egg decorating contest. Straight Arrow News contributor Star Parker argues that the White House…
-
Kamala Harris’s abortion clinic visit endorses crime against humanity
Kamala Harris became the first American vice president in history to visit an abortion services provider while in office on Thursday, Mar. 14. That visit was a part of her “Fight for Reproductive Freedoms” tour, which she hopes will mobilize Americans concerned about dwindling access to reproductive healthcare and abortion services. Straight Arrow News contributor…
Latest Opinions
-
Divisive college protests bring out bipartisan unity in Congress
-
Anticipated offshore wind rebound faces test after Biden admin proposal
-
US gray wolves in danger of being taken off endangered species list
-
Violence on UCLA campus over war in Gaza forces cancellation of classes
-
Tesla may have made EV charging harder, even for other car brands
Popular Opinions
-
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.