How one dresses shouldn’t be a crime, right? But it is in Phoenix. In Arizona’s capital city, a vague ordinance has allowed police to prosecute people who are dressed “sexily” shall we say. If a law enforcement officer finds that a person is scantily dressed, well, Phoenix police can charge them with “manifesting prostitution.” And that’s a crime that carries a mandatory sentence of at least 15 days in jail. You’re likely thinking that this law sits dormant, right? But it doesn’t.
Police have charged more than 450 people under this attire based ordinance, upending lives over simply someone’s preference for certain clothing in a climate that happens to run hot. Of course, it’s often the case in the land of the free — and it is the case here — that a disproportionate number of those being charged under the law are Black. Now this unconstitutional ordinance is nothing more than weaponized white supremacy, and it must be shut down.
Statutes like this appear racially neutral on their face, but they are not in application or in enforcement. Lawmakers know that, white America knows that but nothing is done. A blond hair blue-eyed white woman walking down Main Street in a tight black dress will be viewed differently than if it were me walking down Main Street in the exact same get up. That is a fact. It’s more likely the case that I’d be viewed as an individual manifesting prostitution simply because of my melanin count. And we really have misogynoir to blame for that. That is the racial and gender bias uniquely experienced by Black women. And one of those biases? It manifests in the form of hyper sexualization, and that bias reaches as far back as slavery.
At the inception of the slave trade, Europeans did their damnedest to dehumanize Black bodies, and all be it the attire being appropriate for the hot climates, well, white people then were appalled by the clothing that Africans wore, finding it lewd. So in the quest to dehumanize the Black body, well, white people stereotyped African women as being sexually promiscuous. Now this label, it helped them justify enslavement and the sexual violation of Black female bodies. And that harmful and utterly degrading trope — labeling black women and girls as innately sexual beings — well that has followed us to this very day.
And so now in Phoenix, where Black people compose just over 7% of the population, while Black bodies are 53% of those charged with manifesting prostitution, in light of their lewd attire — which many would deem appropriate given the hot climate. It’s really full circle here. And as much as many people in white America will maintain that ordinances like those in Phoenix have nothing to do with race, when we know that that is not the case, because our minds use race as a mechanism for determining who really seems to break the law.
Hence, laws like this ordinance and Phoenix become just another mechanism for dehumanizing Black people, really just reminding us that our bodies are policed in ways that white bodies are not. And the consequences, well, they are very real. A mandatory 15 day stint in jail can cost people their jobs. Can you simply disappear for two weeks and have no issue whatsoever with your employer? Most people can’t go MIA, particularly Black people, as we are far less likely to have salaried positions that allow for such sudden leave. We’re also less likely to have funds to hire accomplished legal counsel who can help beat the charge on our behalf. And missing work, well, that often means missing rent, car payments and so much more.
Plus, consider what happens when a Black woman is convicted of manifesting prostitution simply on account of her attire. Well, such a charge on one’s record would likely harm their future professional prospects, which are tied to economic mobility, as we know. I could not imagine trying to explain to a prospective employer how I was just donning the latest tight Fashion Nova dress on a Friday night, rather than trying to sell my goodies around the block.
To say such an exchange would be demoralizing would be an understatement. Black women should be allowed to wear whatever we want to wear without being hyper-sexualized and demoralized with accusations and charges of criminality. And don’t get me wrong — sex work is work. I am not throwing shade on the profession. What I am throwing shade on is ordinances like Phoenix’s manifesting prostitution. Because at the end of the day, these kind of vague laws do nothing more than manifest racism.
Related
Adrienne Lawrence
Legal analyst, law professor & award-winning author
View Video LibraryCommentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
‘The worst it’s ever been’: Young Americans on democracy
8 hrs ago
Dr. Frank Luntz
How to handle plunging US birth rate before it’s too late
8 hrs ago
Peter Zeihan
Japan must confront reality of military threats
Yesterday
Peter Zeihan
US may need to find new sources of uranium
Tuesday
Peter Zeihan
Black people more likely to be arrested under Phoenix dress code
Aug 02, 2023
By Straight Arrow News
A city ordinance in Phoenix allows police to arrest people for dressing scantily on charges of “manifesting an intent to commit or solicit an act of prostitution,” but the law doesn’t appear to treat everyone equally. Recent data obtained by the Phoenix New Times reveals that the majority of those charged with this offense over the past two years were Black.
Straight Arrow News contributor Adrienne Lawrence argues that such a law is just another instance of Black people facing unjust treatment compared to their white counterparts.
And so now in Phoenix, where Black people compose just over 7% of the population, while Black bodies are 53% of those charged with “manifesting prostitution,” in light of their lewd attire — which many would deem appropriate given the hot climate. It’s really full circle here. And as much as many people in white America will maintain that ordinances, like those in Phoenix, have nothing to do with race, when we know that that is not the case, because our minds use race as a mechanism for determining who really seems to break the law.
Hence, laws like this ordinance in Phoenix become just another mechanism for dehumanizing Black people, really just reminding us that our bodies are policed in ways that white bodies are not. And the consequences, well, they are very real.
A mandatory 15-day stint in jail can cost people their jobs. Can you simply disappear for two weeks and have no issue whatsoever with your employer? Most people can’t go MIA, particularly Black people, as we are far less likely to have salaried positions that allow for such sudden leave. We’re also less likely to have funds to hire accomplished legal counsel who can help beat the charge on our behalf. And missing work, well, that often means missing rent, car payments and so much more.
How one dresses shouldn’t be a crime, right? But it is in Phoenix. In Arizona’s capital city, a vague ordinance has allowed police to prosecute people who are dressed “sexily” shall we say. If a law enforcement officer finds that a person is scantily dressed, well, Phoenix police can charge them with “manifesting prostitution.” And that’s a crime that carries a mandatory sentence of at least 15 days in jail. You’re likely thinking that this law sits dormant, right? But it doesn’t.
Police have charged more than 450 people under this attire based ordinance, upending lives over simply someone’s preference for certain clothing in a climate that happens to run hot. Of course, it’s often the case in the land of the free — and it is the case here — that a disproportionate number of those being charged under the law are Black. Now this unconstitutional ordinance is nothing more than weaponized white supremacy, and it must be shut down.
Statutes like this appear racially neutral on their face, but they are not in application or in enforcement. Lawmakers know that, white America knows that but nothing is done. A blond hair blue-eyed white woman walking down Main Street in a tight black dress will be viewed differently than if it were me walking down Main Street in the exact same get up. That is a fact. It’s more likely the case that I’d be viewed as an individual manifesting prostitution simply because of my melanin count. And we really have misogynoir to blame for that. That is the racial and gender bias uniquely experienced by Black women. And one of those biases? It manifests in the form of hyper sexualization, and that bias reaches as far back as slavery.
At the inception of the slave trade, Europeans did their damnedest to dehumanize Black bodies, and all be it the attire being appropriate for the hot climates, well, white people then were appalled by the clothing that Africans wore, finding it lewd. So in the quest to dehumanize the Black body, well, white people stereotyped African women as being sexually promiscuous. Now this label, it helped them justify enslavement and the sexual violation of Black female bodies. And that harmful and utterly degrading trope — labeling black women and girls as innately sexual beings — well that has followed us to this very day.
And so now in Phoenix, where Black people compose just over 7% of the population, while Black bodies are 53% of those charged with manifesting prostitution, in light of their lewd attire — which many would deem appropriate given the hot climate. It’s really full circle here. And as much as many people in white America will maintain that ordinances like those in Phoenix have nothing to do with race, when we know that that is not the case, because our minds use race as a mechanism for determining who really seems to break the law.
Hence, laws like this ordinance and Phoenix become just another mechanism for dehumanizing Black people, really just reminding us that our bodies are policed in ways that white bodies are not. And the consequences, well, they are very real. A mandatory 15 day stint in jail can cost people their jobs. Can you simply disappear for two weeks and have no issue whatsoever with your employer? Most people can’t go MIA, particularly Black people, as we are far less likely to have salaried positions that allow for such sudden leave. We’re also less likely to have funds to hire accomplished legal counsel who can help beat the charge on our behalf. And missing work, well, that often means missing rent, car payments and so much more.
Plus, consider what happens when a Black woman is convicted of manifesting prostitution simply on account of her attire. Well, such a charge on one’s record would likely harm their future professional prospects, which are tied to economic mobility, as we know. I could not imagine trying to explain to a prospective employer how I was just donning the latest tight Fashion Nova dress on a Friday night, rather than trying to sell my goodies around the block.
To say such an exchange would be demoralizing would be an understatement. Black women should be allowed to wear whatever we want to wear without being hyper-sexualized and demoralized with accusations and charges of criminality. And don’t get me wrong — sex work is work. I am not throwing shade on the profession. What I am throwing shade on is ordinances like Phoenix’s manifesting prostitution. Because at the end of the day, these kind of vague laws do nothing more than manifest racism.
Related
NYPD’s lack of lawsuit disclosure shields it from accountability
An examination of public records obtained through Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests revealed that nearly 13,000 legal cases brought against the New York City Police Department (NYPD) resulting in settlements or monetary awards over the past decade were not publicly disclosed, despite legal requirements to do so. Some analysts suggest that the NYPD’s failure…
Yesterday
Students learning brutal lesson on how police respond to protests
Student protests against Israel’s war in Gaza have escalated in the United States and around the world as civilian death counts in both Gaza and the West Bank continue to climb. Estimates show Israeli forces killed at least 42,500 Palestinians since Oct. 7, 2023, and another two million survivors have been displaced from their homes.…
May 1
Supreme Court must end criminalization of homelessness
On April 22, the U.S. Supreme Court addressed the nation’s homelessness crisis, considering whether an Oregon city had the right to ban homeless people from camping in public spaces. A majority of justices appeared inclined to support the city’s efforts to regulate homeless encampments on public grounds. This decision carries significant implications for the growing…
Apr 24
Why are non-consensual pelvic exams still happening?
More states are beginning to crack down on the surprisingly common practice of medical students and professional staff performing non-consensual pelvic exams on unconscious men and women in hospitals, universities and other medical facilities. Just one year ago today, those practices remained legal in a majority of U.S. states. Now, however, a new directive from…
Apr 17
Congress should repeal the Foreign Dredge Act
The collapse of Baltimore’s Key Bridge presents challenges for cleanup and construction crews who rely on dredging vessels to complete their work. That’s partly because of the Foreign Dredge Act, a 1906 law that prohibits foreign-made dredging vessels. Congress is now introducing a measure to revise parts of that law, although previous attempts to do…
Apr 10
Underreported stories from each side
Trump slams Biden over conditioning weapons supply to Israel
14 sources | 8% from the left
Getty Images
Missouri cuts off Medicaid funds from Planned Parenthood
8 sources | 13% from the right
USA Today
Latest Stories
Is a bill to require proof of citizenship for voting necessary?
Watch 4:52
3 hrs ago
GM to end production of the Chevrolet Malibu to make more EVs
Watch 1:23
3 hrs ago
First aid ship bound for new Gaza pier sets sail from Cyprus
Watch 1:55
4 hrs ago
Trump asks oil companies to raise $1B, vows rollback of Biden’s green policies
Watch 1:26
4 hrs ago
Migrants in Denver issue list of demands to city before clearing encampments
Watch 1:32
5 hrs ago
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Putin’s promise of a long war might be hollow threat
8 hrs ago
Leon Aron
Why the Trump family is missing from court appearances
9 hrs ago
Jordan Reid
Arizona bill legalizing shooting migrants is part of GOP brand
Yesterday
Ruben Navarrette
NYPD’s lack of lawsuit disclosure shields it from accountability
Yesterday
Adrienne Lawrence