Skip to main content
Adrienne Lawrence Legal analyst, law professor & award-winning author
Share
Opinion

NYPD’s lack of lawsuit disclosure shields it from accountability

Share
Adrienne Lawrence Legal analyst, law professor & award-winning author
Share

An examination of public records obtained through Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests revealed that nearly 13,000 legal cases brought against the New York City Police Department (NYPD) resulting in settlements or monetary awards over the past decade were not publicly disclosed, despite legal requirements to do so. Some analysts suggest that the NYPD’s failure to be transparent about these cases could contribute to police misconduct.

Straight Arrow News contributor Adrienne Lawrence contends that by concealing information about judgments and payouts, the NYPD avoids consequences and is able to portray itself more favorably to the general public.

How do you forget to log more than half, nearly 13,000 lawsuits filed against you? If you cannot do your job, or do it without getting sued to the nth degree, how can we the people determine whether we should keep you in that job? It’s evident that the NYPD does not want New York City people to know about the mounting costs of police misconduct, and that even with a $5.8 billion budget, the NYPD struggles are not just a few bad apples.

But things are not getting better. New Yorkers deserve transparency just as much as they deserve public servants who protect and serve within the bounds of the law. There has to the consequences for the NYPD intentionally failing to disclose to the public the more than $1.2 billion in settlements and monetary awards that it paid with city [tax]payer’s funds. Hearings must be held, heads should roll from top to bottom, budgets should be cut to reflect the true cost.

The NYPD only acts up to this point because they are not actually facing any consequences for their failure to report a 10-figure payout. If we want legal compliance from law enforcement, there must be literal consequences attached. The transparency is just the first step to sanitizing corruption. Actual accountability must come next.

I love public records. They provide transparency as to government action. Light is one of the great sanitizers of corruption, they say, because when there’s a lack of transparency, there can be no accountability. And recently, we learned that the New York City Police Department hasn’t been as transparent about their legal troubles over the past 10 years, and it seems that the nation’s largest police department will not face any consequences for that lack of transparency. A years long investigation by city and state found that the NYPD failed to report that it had settled or paid out judgments in more than 12,000 lawsuits since 2013 12,748 lawsuits to be exact. That’s the number of suits the NYPD never reported that it was using New York taxpayer funds to defend and pay out despite being legally required to report that information. TRANSLATION The NYPD decided not to report what turned out to be 56% of lawsuits that it faced and paid from January 2013 to December 2023. So they kept mum about more than half of the times ever sued. How much more money do you think the NYPD paid? That’s $1.2 billion over the decade. This omission included high profile cases and small lawsuits. Now by omitting these litany of lawsuits from legally required reporting databases. Over the course of the last decade, the NYPD has been able to craft a narrative that made it look for less problematic in the eyes of plaintiffs and the public. The department leverage that narrative to its advantage. For example, in a budget hearing last May, the NYPD Deputy Commissioner of litigation, Michael Gerber said that lawsuit payouts were down with a 50% drop in claims asserting that this is a key measure in terms of police performance. Yeah, claims were down 50% Michael, because y’all weren’t reporting 56% of them. Come on. concealing the truth to this degree is indicative of nothing short of corruption. You can’t tell me that these omissions were not intentional. How do you forget to log more than half nearly 13,000 lawsuits filed against you? If you cannot do your job or do it without getting sued to the enth degree? How can we the people determine whether we should keep you in that job. It’s evident that the NYPD does not want new york city people to know about the mounting costs of police misconduct and that even with a $5.8 billion budget, the NYPD struggles are not just a few bad apples. But things are not getting better. New Yorkers deserve transparency just as much as they deserve public servants who protect and serve within the bounds of the law. There has to the consequences for the NYPD intentionally failing to disclose to the public, the more than $1.2 billion in settlements and monetary awards that it paid with city payers funds. Hearings must be held the head should roll from top to bottom budget should be cut to reflect the true cost the NYPD is only acts up to this point because they are not actually facing any consequences for their failure to report a 10 figure payout. If we want legal compliance from law enforcement there must be literal consequences attached. The transparency is just the first step to sanitize and corruption. Actual accountability must come next.

More from Adrienne Lawrence

Latest Commentary

We know it is important to hear from a diverse range of observers on the complex topics we face and believe our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions.

The commentaries published in this section are solely those of the contributors and do not reflect the views of Straight Arrow News.


Latest Opinions

In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum. We hope these different voices will help you reach your own conclusions.

The opinions published in this section are solely those of the contributors and do not reflect the views of Straight Arrow News.

Weekly Voices

Left Opinion Right Opinion
Wednesday
Left Opinion Right Opinion
Thursday
Left Opinion Right Opinion
Friday
Left Opinion Right Opinion