Skip to main content

Opinion: Will Americans keep putting up with public schools?

Oct 21, 2021


While the pandemic disrupted schools nationwide, it also provided a new window into what is happening in the classroom. The fallout is on display as parents express concerns about curriculum, raising the question: are we spending money wisely on public education? The school debate is also playing out in the race for Governor in Virginia where one candidate delivered a strong message about whether parents should have a say in what their kids are learning. If these arguments continue, we may see more and more parents following the growing trend of pulling kids out of public school.

Well, it’s back to school time. And after a long period at home on what was called remote learning for most children, the kids by and large are back to school.

The nation’s parents learned a couple of things during all that time of remote learning.

First, that in-person learning is better than learning at home from a computer. 

And the second, for the first time they saw what their kids were actually learning in the public schools, and a lot of them didn’t like what it was.

But let’s tell a little bit of a history on this. It’s long been known that U.S. public schools really don’t deliver value for their money. 

According to the census bureau, the average amount spent on kindergarten through 12th grade in us, public schools is $15,946. 

Think of it this way. If you have a classroom of 20 kids, that’s about $320,000 sitting in that classroom 

Teacher may be getting a hundred thousand.

Where does all the money go? So public education, 15,946.

In the nation’, 22,000 private schools, K through 12. The average tuition is just $12,350. That’s about 20% less than what they are in public school. And the really cost efficient schools are Catholic elementary schools where the average tuition is $4,840, about 70% less than what it costs in public schools. So it can’t be a shortage of money that is the problem, yet the quality of education lags way behind what it does in other countries. 

There’s an organization called the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. It’s the more advanced economies of the world. And there are 34 countries that are members.

Of those 34, the U.S. came in 26th in math. We only beat seven countries out of the 34, and 20th in science, not a good performance considering the amount of money being spent.

Well, what happened during the pandemic when the parents saw what their kids were learning? The problems went beyond mere low quality, low performance.

They went more into ideological problems as well. 

Parents, for example, saw critical race theory now being taught in schools, which hadn’t been there three years ago and critical race theory is quite controversial. 

What it does for example, is that it assumes that if, for example, you were born white, you’re permanently irredeemable. There is no way that you can outgrow the racism, which apparently started when you first were born. It does a number of other things, including the foundation of America being historically racist. 

Most people don’t think that’s true. 

It also involved, but in the old days we called sex education, but now it’s called gender studies. And a lot of parents really didn’t want their kids going into all the details of that. They didn’t want the kids, for example, being told that men can have children. It just didn’t make sense to them. So opposition to what was going on in public schools rose very, very sharply.

The issues involved have become front and center in the governor’s race for Virginia. Virginia is one of two states that votes in the odd year and the Democrat candidate, Terry McAuliffe, who’s been governor before said, quote, “I don’t think parents should be telling schools what to teach,” and, no, he thinks the state bureaucrats should be making up what the curriculum is. 

Well, that’s not exactly what most parents believe or even what most citizens believe. And parents started voting with their feet.

Homeschooling has soared.

Up until a few years ago, only 3.3% of the nation’s kids were in homeschooling. In the 2019- 2020 year, that rose to 5.4%. And the 2020 – 2021 year, it rose to a staggering 11.1%.  It more than tripled once parents got to see what was actually happening in their kids’ schools, they want to teach them at home instead, even though it’s a lot harder on them to do so.

In addition, public opinion is for something called school choice and when the public was asked, should at least some of that $15,946 be able to be used by parents to send their kids elsewhere? 

The approval was 74%, 70%, even among Democrats, 83% among Republicans, every major, uh, ethnic group, uh, supported the idea. It ranged from 69% support among Hispanics to 76% support among whites. 

School choice is one of the few things that almost all Americans agree on. That doesn’t mean it’s going to pass because one of the aspects of American politics is that entrenched special interest groups tend to dominate over more diffuse views of the majority of the people. 

So we now have a key special interests. The teacher’s unions that almost certainly will try and block it. 

Nonetheless, the Virginia race is probably a harbinger of whether or not the American people, especially the parents, are going to continue to put up with public schools teaching where they have no say in what is taught. 

Video Library