When things in life get expensive, government seems to have only one answer: Subsidize Demand!
It never works, but the government keeps trying it. College tuition is too high? Hand out federal grants and subsidized student loans! Housing costs too much? Give tax breaks for mortgages! And nowadays, the Biden administration wants to subsidize child care, promising they will provide safe, reliable day care for $10 a day.
These proposals all ignore history and basic economics. In the end, subsidizing demand doesn’t make anything more affordable—it does the opposite.
Think about it: The price of a thing is determined by supply and demand. This is the most basic fact in economics.
If the government gives people money for the purpose of paying college tuition, then it is increasing those people’s ability to pay for college. Ability to pay is part of demand. So tuition subsidies, mortgage subsidies, and daycare subsidies generally drive up the demand for college, for homes, and for daycare.
College, health care, and housing are three of the most subsidized products in the American economy, and it’s no coincidence that they have seen the greatest price increases over the past couple of generations.
One study of for-profit colleges last decade found, in the words of economist Veronique de Rugy, “institutions that are eligible for federal aid raised tuition by about 78 percent more than institutions that are ineligible.”
Economists generally agree that the mortgage-interest deduction doesn’t make more people into homeowners—it either drives up the purchase price of homes or causes folks to buy bigger homes.
So what about the Biden administration’s plan to subsidize daycare demand?
They are copying Canada, where the Trudeau administration has also promised ten-dollar-a-day child care. Up there, this program has led to shortages and record waitlists.
The Biden folks haven’t given the details on their plan, but you can be sure the subsidies will come with regulations—regulations not mostly about safety but about union labor.
And here you begin to see who benefits from demand subsidies—not only the politicians who claim they are trying to make things more affordable, but the institutions that pocket the subsidies.
That is, the real beneficiaries of mortgage subsidies are lenders and realtors, the real beneficiaries of college subsidies are administrators and contractors, and the real beneficiaries of the Biden daycare plan are the Democrat-aligned labor unions that want a monopoly on caring for kids from birth to age five, just as they have a K-12 monopoly.
This is how to understand subsidies like this: They don’t help customers as much as they help the politically connected providers.
Timothy Carney
Senior Fellow, American Enterprise Institute
Commentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
Is the US looking for a war?
7 hrs ago
Peter Zeihan
How future generations could shift US support for Israel
Yesterday
Peter Zeihan
Why election of European Commission president is so important
Wednesday
Peter Zeihan
‘Both completely corrupt’: What Americans think of Biden, Trump
Tuesday
Dr. Frank Luntz
Subsidizing demand won’t fix real problems
Timothy Carney
Senior Fellow, American Enterprise Institute
By Straight Arrow News
The Biden administration recently announced an initiative to cap child care copay expenses for approximately 100,000 low-income working families in the United States. Instead of paying set fees, those families will pay 7% of whatever their total income is as a copay for the government-subsidized daycare program. The program also hopes to fully cover all homeless or severely disabled children at no cost.
Straight Arrow News contributor Tim Carney says that this is just one more bad idea on an already-long list of demand-side subsidies that have failed the American economy for decades. Carney argues that it is exactly these kinds of subsidy programs which inflate the prices of vital goods and services in the first place, and cautions against this approach.
When things in life get expensive, government seems to have only one answer: Subsidize Demand!
It never works, but the government keeps trying it. College tuition is too high? Hand out federal grants and subsidized student loans! Housing costs too much? Give tax breaks for mortgages! And nowadays, the Biden administration wants to subsidize child care, promising they will provide safe, reliable day care for $10 a day.
These proposals all ignore history and basic economics. In the end, subsidizing demand doesn’t make anything more affordable—it does the opposite. Think about it: The price of a thing is determined by supply and demand. This is the most basic fact in economics.
If the government gives people money for the purpose of paying college tuition, then it is increasing those people’s ability to pay for college. Ability to pay is part of demand. So tuition subsidies, mortgage subsidies, and daycare subsidies generally drive up the demand for college, for homes, and for daycare.
College, healthcare and housing are three of the most subsidized products in the American economy, and it’s no coincidence that they have seen the greatest price increases over the past couple of generations.
When things in life get expensive, government seems to have only one answer: Subsidize Demand!
It never works, but the government keeps trying it. College tuition is too high? Hand out federal grants and subsidized student loans! Housing costs too much? Give tax breaks for mortgages! And nowadays, the Biden administration wants to subsidize child care, promising they will provide safe, reliable day care for $10 a day.
These proposals all ignore history and basic economics. In the end, subsidizing demand doesn’t make anything more affordable—it does the opposite.
Think about it: The price of a thing is determined by supply and demand. This is the most basic fact in economics.
If the government gives people money for the purpose of paying college tuition, then it is increasing those people’s ability to pay for college. Ability to pay is part of demand. So tuition subsidies, mortgage subsidies, and daycare subsidies generally drive up the demand for college, for homes, and for daycare.
College, health care, and housing are three of the most subsidized products in the American economy, and it’s no coincidence that they have seen the greatest price increases over the past couple of generations.
One study of for-profit colleges last decade found, in the words of economist Veronique de Rugy, “institutions that are eligible for federal aid raised tuition by about 78 percent more than institutions that are ineligible.”
Economists generally agree that the mortgage-interest deduction doesn’t make more people into homeowners—it either drives up the purchase price of homes or causes folks to buy bigger homes.
So what about the Biden administration’s plan to subsidize daycare demand?
They are copying Canada, where the Trudeau administration has also promised ten-dollar-a-day child care. Up there, this program has led to shortages and record waitlists.
The Biden folks haven’t given the details on their plan, but you can be sure the subsidies will come with regulations—regulations not mostly about safety but about union labor.
And here you begin to see who benefits from demand subsidies—not only the politicians who claim they are trying to make things more affordable, but the institutions that pocket the subsidies.
That is, the real beneficiaries of mortgage subsidies are lenders and realtors, the real beneficiaries of college subsidies are administrators and contractors, and the real beneficiaries of the Biden daycare plan are the Democrat-aligned labor unions that want a monopoly on caring for kids from birth to age five, just as they have a K-12 monopoly.
This is how to understand subsidies like this: They don’t help customers as much as they help the politically connected providers.
How Biden’s tax on Chinese metal harms Americans
President Joe Biden announced plans to triple tariffs on Chinese steel and aluminum to protect American jobs from “unfair” competition. The White House said China is hurting the U.S. economy by selling steel at very low prices. Watch the video above as Straight Arrow News contributor Timothy Carney argues that while Biden’s new tariffs might…
Jul 18
Democrats use climate change issues to help sell liberal agenda
According to a January survey, only 12% of Republicans say dealing with climate change should be a top priority for the president and Congress, ranking the issue last among the 20 included in the survey. By contrast, 59% of Democrats say climate change should be a top priority for the president and Congress. While Democrats may…
Jun 20
HHS Secretary Becerra’s crusade against Catholicism
When President Joe Biden took office, he nominated Xavier Becerra, a former California congressman and attorney general, to run the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). As California’s attorney general, Becerra was at the forefront of legal efforts on health care. In his current position as HHS secretary, Becerra is a strong proponent…
May 30
Universities must blame themselves for protest hypocrisy
U.S. college protests over the Israel-Hamas war have divided college campuses, often pitting university officials and executives against their own students and faculty. And yet, as Straight Arrow News contributor Timothy Carney points out, many of today’s university officials are actually the anti-Vietnam War protesters of a previous era’s student protest movement. Today, those same…
May 16
Underreported stories from each side
Group accuses Pa. teachers union of illegally using money to back Shapiro’s 2022 campaign
8 sources | 0% from the left
Getty Images
Some House Republicans slam Vance as Trump’s VP pick: ‘The worst choice’
8 sources | 0% from the right
Reuters
Latest Stories
Congress still trying to figure out how to reduce wasteful military spending
Watch 2:29
2 hrs ago
US Navy, Air Force making waves with new weapons at RIMPAC
Watch 6:03
2 hrs ago
Israeli PM Netanyahu meets with Trump at Mar-a-Lago
Watch 2:54
2 hrs ago
Growing US nuclear power resurgence reaches the nation’s heartland
Watch 1:19
2 hrs ago
Beer from the sun, other solar thermal projects get government funding
Watch 2:04
2 hrs ago
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trump has an excellent opportunity with Black voters
8 hrs ago
Star Parker
Don’t fall for GOP’s cheap racist attacks on Kamala Harris
9 hrs ago
Dr. Rashad Richey
Americans must reject Trump to defend our democracy
Yesterday
Jordan Reid
Why all the changes in European parliamentary governments?
Wednesday
Newt Gingrich