When people think about the Eighth Amendment, that is if they ever think about the Eighth Amendment at all, will they generally think of that cruel and unusual punishment clause. Now, that is the provision that bans the government from punishing people in a way that could be deemed to be cruel and unusual. What punishment actually meets that measure is something for the courts to decide. After all, they’re the ones that interpret the law. And this week, our highest court heard oral arguments on deciding whether it’s cruel and unusual to enforce laws punishing unhoused people for camping on public property when there are no shelters that are available, even though the right has a stronghold on the majority of our supreme court right now, the left may indeed take a win on this one. Because if people experiencing homelessness have no constitutional right to housing in this country, they should have a constitutional right to camp on public property when they’re given no other option. Let me be clear, homelessness is a choice, not a choice of the individual on housed person that is but a choice of us policymakers. The United States is among the richest nations in the world. Particularly it’s number three in terms of wealthiest country on a per capita basis. It also boasts more than 15 million vacant homes. That means approximately 10% of the homes in our nation are totally empty inventory. People aren’t living there, all the while 600,000 People live without permanent shelter. Some 30% of those people are unhoused families with children. 6% are veterans. 5% are unaccompanied youth. That’s children alone, and the number of individuals experiencing homelessness is steadily on the rise, and it has been increasing since 2017. People simply cannot afford housing. In California, for example, over the past 20 years, the average rent has increased 35% How much has the average renters income gone up? 6% all said right has increased more than 116% in US dollars for the average renter. We need not even talk about homeownership for that matter. It’s not even an option as a largest demographic in the workplace, that is Millennials like me, are priced out of the real estate market entirely. How are Americans to keep a roof over their heads when their wages remain stagnant? Yet housing prices go up? Where will the people go when they can’t make rent, we’re being forced onto the streets to punish us for that is cruel and unusual. And that’s what the Supreme Court will likely decide in the face of several states effectively criminalizing homelessness without providing adequate housing alternatives. And the cruelty it abounds. Just last month, Ron DeSantis signed a bill banning homelessness in terms of camping and public spaces. The Florida Governor believes somehow that this anti camping penalty will help ensure that individuals have the resources they need to get back on their feet. Come on make it make sense here. If lawmakers and leaders want to keep people from living on the streets, they must step up provide adequate housing ensure opportunities are available to thrive. Guaranteeing basic fundamental rights that include housing isn’t far fetched. France, Scotland, South Africa and many other nations have adopted a right to housing in their constitutions or their law books, improving the housing conditions of their people. There’s no reason the same approach cannot be taken right here in the United States. If our lawmakers and leaders won’t do it for us, I think the Supreme Court may find a way. Until then, it is so incredibly cruel. And disgustingly unusual to punish people who are forced to live on the streets because our lawmakers and leaders aren’t providing alternative housing options.
Adrienne Lawrence
Legal analyst, law professor & award-winning author
Commentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
Is the US looking for a war?
7 hrs ago
Peter Zeihan
How future generations could shift US support for Israel
Yesterday
Peter Zeihan
Why election of European Commission president is so important
Wednesday
Peter Zeihan
‘Both completely corrupt’: What Americans think of Biden, Trump
Tuesday
Dr. Frank Luntz
Supreme Court must end criminalization of homelessness
Adrienne Lawrence
Legal analyst, law professor & award-winning author
By Straight Arrow News
On April 22, the U.S. Supreme Court addressed the nation’s homelessness crisis, considering whether an Oregon city had the right to ban homeless people from camping in public spaces. A majority of justices appeared inclined to support the city’s efforts to regulate homeless encampments on public grounds. This decision carries significant implications for the growing number of individuals residing in tents and cars, as well as the municipalities tasked with managing the issue.
Straight Arrow News contributor Adrienne Lawrence asserts that the Supreme Court should not permit cities and states to penalize the unhoused for sleeping on public property. Lawrence argues that unhoused individuals have a constitutional right to camp on public grounds when alternatives are lacking.
Come on, make it make sense here. If lawmakers and leaders want to keep people from living on the streets, they must step up, provide adequate housing, ensure opportunities are available to thrive. Guaranteeing basic fundamental rights that include housing isn’t far-fetched. France, Scotland, South Africa and many other nations have adopted a right to housing in their constitutions or their law books, improving the housing conditions of their people.
There’s no reason the same approach cannot be taken right here in the United States. If our lawmakers and leaders won’t do it for us, I think the Supreme Court may find a way. Until then, it is so incredibly cruel and disgustingly unusual to punish people who are forced to live on the streets because our lawmakers and leaders aren’t providing alternative housing options.
When people think about the Eighth Amendment, that is if they ever think about the Eighth Amendment at all, will they generally think of that cruel and unusual punishment clause. Now, that is the provision that bans the government from punishing people in a way that could be deemed to be cruel and unusual. What punishment actually meets that measure is something for the courts to decide. After all, they’re the ones that interpret the law. And this week, our highest court heard oral arguments on deciding whether it’s cruel and unusual to enforce laws punishing unhoused people for camping on public property when there are no shelters that are available, even though the right has a stronghold on the majority of our supreme court right now, the left may indeed take a win on this one. Because if people experiencing homelessness have no constitutional right to housing in this country, they should have a constitutional right to camp on public property when they’re given no other option. Let me be clear, homelessness is a choice, not a choice of the individual on housed person that is but a choice of us policymakers. The United States is among the richest nations in the world. Particularly it’s number three in terms of wealthiest country on a per capita basis. It also boasts more than 15 million vacant homes. That means approximately 10% of the homes in our nation are totally empty inventory. People aren’t living there, all the while 600,000 People live without permanent shelter. Some 30% of those people are unhoused families with children. 6% are veterans. 5% are unaccompanied youth. That’s children alone, and the number of individuals experiencing homelessness is steadily on the rise, and it has been increasing since 2017. People simply cannot afford housing. In California, for example, over the past 20 years, the average rent has increased 35% How much has the average renters income gone up? 6% all said right has increased more than 116% in US dollars for the average renter. We need not even talk about homeownership for that matter. It’s not even an option as a largest demographic in the workplace, that is Millennials like me, are priced out of the real estate market entirely. How are Americans to keep a roof over their heads when their wages remain stagnant? Yet housing prices go up? Where will the people go when they can’t make rent, we’re being forced onto the streets to punish us for that is cruel and unusual. And that’s what the Supreme Court will likely decide in the face of several states effectively criminalizing homelessness without providing adequate housing alternatives. And the cruelty it abounds. Just last month, Ron DeSantis signed a bill banning homelessness in terms of camping and public spaces. The Florida Governor believes somehow that this anti camping penalty will help ensure that individuals have the resources they need to get back on their feet. Come on make it make sense here. If lawmakers and leaders want to keep people from living on the streets, they must step up provide adequate housing ensure opportunities are available to thrive. Guaranteeing basic fundamental rights that include housing isn’t far fetched. France, Scotland, South Africa and many other nations have adopted a right to housing in their constitutions or their law books, improving the housing conditions of their people. There’s no reason the same approach cannot be taken right here in the United States. If our lawmakers and leaders won’t do it for us, I think the Supreme Court may find a way. Until then, it is so incredibly cruel. And disgustingly unusual to punish people who are forced to live on the streets because our lawmakers and leaders aren’t providing alternative housing options.
Trump-Vance ticket will implement nationwide abortion ban
Donald Trump recently accepted the Republican nomination for president and named Sen. J.D. Vance, R-Ohio, as his running mate. Vance has previously advocated for strict anti-abortion laws, in sharp contrast to Kamala Harris, the leading Democratic candidate, who went on a nationwide tour to mobilize pro-choice voters. Watch the above video as Straight Arrow News…
Wednesday
End of Chevron is an open invite for corporate corruption
On June 28, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned 40 years of “Chevron deference” in a landmark ruling that experts say will cause a “legal earthquake.” The 6-3 conservative opinion upends a long tradition of relying on neutral expertise to interpret and execute laws and regulations. Broadly speaking, the ruling empowers judges and corporations at the…
Jul 17
American democracy cannot survive if Trump wins
Public alarm over the chances of democracy surviving in America has reached a new high-water mark in the wake of the Supreme Court’s July 1 ruling in Trump v. United States, where the court expanded presidential powers for all current and future U.S. presidents. Among other things, the court may have granted U.S. presidents the…
Jul 10
Talk to your kids about sextortion
The FBI is warning Americans of a growing threat called sextortion, where online predators pose as young, single individuals to lure their victims, primarily single teenage boys, into a blackmail trap. After soliciting sexual photos or videos of the victim, the predator threatens to release the images or videos unless the victim sends money and/or…
Jul 3
Louisiana’s Ten Commandments law proves Gov. Landry is corrupt
On June 20, GOP Gov. Jeff Landry of Louisiana signed into law a new bill that requires all public Louisiana school and university classrooms to display a poster-sized printout of the Bible’s Ten Commandments. The law violates existing legal precedents regarding the First Amendment and is expected to be challenged in the Supreme Court, although…
Jun 26
Underreported stories from each side
Group accuses Pa. teachers union of illegally using money to back Shapiro’s 2022 campaign
8 sources | 0% from the left
Getty Images
Some House Republicans slam Vance as Trump’s VP pick: ‘The worst choice’
8 sources | 0% from the right
Reuters
Latest Stories
Congress still trying to figure out how to reduce wasteful military spending
Watch 2:29
3 hrs ago
US Navy, Air Force making waves with new weapons at RIMPAC
Watch 6:03
3 hrs ago
Israeli PM Netanyahu meets with Trump at Mar-a-Lago
Watch 2:54
3 hrs ago
Growing US nuclear power resurgence reaches the nation’s heartland
Watch 1:19
3 hrs ago
Beer from the sun, other solar thermal projects get government funding
Watch 2:04
3 hrs ago
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trump has an excellent opportunity with Black voters
8 hrs ago
Star Parker
Don’t fall for GOP’s cheap racist attacks on Kamala Harris
9 hrs ago
Dr. Rashad Richey
Americans must reject Trump to defend our democracy
Yesterday
Jordan Reid
Why all the changes in European parliamentary governments?
Wednesday
Newt Gingrich