Skip to main content

Commentary

What in the World?

A toasty winter? Great for Europe, terrible for Ukraine

Jan 11, 2023

Share

Mother Nature is switching gears and Europeans are breathing a collective sigh of relief, for now at least. Ever since Russia cut off its energy exports to Europe in the face of the Ukrainian war, analysts have been predicting disruptive gas shortages and soaring energy costs. But with record-setting high temperatures across the region, energy demand has plummeted, taking prices down with it. That’s great news — unless your home is Kyiv instead of Paris. As Straight Arrow News contributor Peter Zeihan explains, warmer weather will impact how the war will be fought in Ukraine this winter, and not in a good way.

Excerpted from Peter’s Jan. 11 “Zeihan on Geopolitics” newsletter:

As much as we analysts like to make predictions and forecasts, Mother Nature is always right there to throw all of it into a tailspin. The crazy temps across Europe are no exception to this.

While this abnormally warm winter season has been a godsend for energy prices across Western Europe, its also thrown a wrench into Ukraine’s plans for a winter offensive.

I’m not saying Europeans should get used to shorts and mai-tais all winter long, but this season could hold lasting impacts (good or bad) for the year ahead.

Hey everyone, Peter Zeihan here coming to you from my hometown of Marshalltown, Iowa, where I’m visiting the rents for few days. Today we are going to be talking about winter. It has been a really weird winter, specifically in Europe over the course of the next last few weeks in the second, and first weeks of January. Temperatures have been and are expected to continue to be in the 50s in Paris and the 40s in Berlin and Warsaw, and in the high 30s in places in Ukraine, most notably Kyiv. Now, this is throwing a lot of my forecasts into a bit of a tailspin, but you know, weather does what weather does, temperatures are based on where you are —  somewhere between 20 and 40 degrees above normal and have been relatively consistently for almost a month at this point.

In the case of Western Europe and Central Europe, this means that energy demand has plummeted. Because normally these guys would be approaching zero degrees Fahrenheit and and those sorts of environments, they simply need to use a lot of energy in order to keep the lights on and especially the heat going. But there have been times that Berlin is broken 50 in December. And in that sort of environment, keeping everybody warm is really easy. And that means that energy demand has plummeted. And the need to cope with the cut offs that have come from the Russian space, because of the Ukraine war, simply are very manageable. And in that sort of environment, you have to play it forward, because it’s not just about electricity and heating. In the European Space, they use a lot of natural gas for a lot of industrial needs. And when the war began, and the Europeans began weaning themselves off of Russian energy, they discovered they had to shut down a whole lot of industry in order to keep people alive. Well, now with the weather warmer and energy freed up for other uses, we’re seeing everything from industry to specifically fertilizer production, nitrogen fertilizer production coming back at scale, this is something that is wildly unexpected. This is the warmest winter on record by a very large margin, we shouldn’t expect it to last we shouldn’t expect it to be repeated. But at least for this moment, Europe is having a great time of it. And considering the obstacles in front of them. And the situation with energy supply in general, you know, enjoy it while it lasts. The problem, of course, is its weather it could change tomorrow, probably will change within a couple of weeks. And then we’re going to be back in the same place. The issue is that energy demand is tends to be inelastic. And so if you only remove five to 10% of energy inputs, and with the Europeans, I’m sorry, with the Russian stuff going offline, we’re talking 40%, you can easily see a doubling, tripling quadrupling, six toppling of energy prices, like we saw consistently last year. But it also means that it goes the other direction as well. So you reduced demand by 10%. And prices absolutely plummeted. And that’s where we are today won’t last. This is not the new normal, all the forecasts are still in place. But if we can hold warm weather throughout, say January, then you can see the end of the winter on the other side. And we might get to a better position for the Europeans and for global food supplies this calendar year and that would be unexpected, but very, very welcome. The other big weather thing is further east and Kyiv, where temperatures are in the 30s. Now normally, you have certain seasons that you can and cannot do things in Ukraine. You have your deep freeze in the winter, which is normally mid November through late February, when temperatures have been so far below freezing for so long that the ground freezes solid, and tanks can move around and fields just fine. But then you’ve got the shoulder seasons in October and early November. And then in March and into April that are kind of mud seasons and in those sorts of environments. You can really only drive on roads. Well my standing forecast for Ukraine is that the Ukrainians were going to try to do a broad spectrum, offensive south in the Aberdeen sub province, aiming roughly for the Sea of Azov. It’s not that they needed to reach the sea itself. They just needed to get close enough that their artillery can target the trucks that are the primary supply line for equipment being shipped from shifted from Russia proper to the southern front and KEARSON. Remember that the Kerch Strait bridge was blown up a couple of months ago, and because of that the Russians can no longer use rail connections from Russia across the Kerch Strait and into the Crimean peninsula. That option is gone so everything has to be supplied by truck. The Russians don’t have a lot of tactical military support trucks left so their only option is to use basically city vans and Scooby Doo vans and city buses in order to ferry artillery shells and you know every time you hit a speed bump everyone’s like and when those things go up, wow, they really go up. But if we are in the 30s in Ukraine for temperatures mud season has a getting a second lease on life here. And in that sort of environment the Ukrainians can only go

operate on the roads. And that makes it much more difficult to do any sort of artillery or especially mobile warfare based assault and zapper NITSA. Because they can’t put things into the fields and into the dirt, they have to stay on the road so they get stuck in the mud. So this has provided a bit of an operational pause, which is really working against the Ukrainians. The Ukrainians don’t have as much equipment and men as a rule than the Russians do. And if they can’t fight a war of movement, then the Russians with their better Air Force, and especially their better missile forces can just keep pounding Ukrainian cities over and over again, doing a lot of economic and humanitarian damage. And there’s not a lot that Ukrainians can do about it in the short term if they can’t operate. So for the Western Europeans and the central Europeans, this has been a godsend for the Ukrainians. They were probably hoping that they were going to be able to have a big offensive right about now. And that’s just not an option if the ground isn’t solid. All right. That’s it for me. Until next time,

 

Video Library

Latest Commentary

We know it is important to hear from a diverse range of observers on the complex topics we face and believe our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions.

The commentaries published in this section are solely those of the contributors and do not reflect the views of Straight Arrow News.


Latest Opinions

In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum. We hope these different voices will help you reach your own conclusions.

The opinions published in this section are solely those of the contributors and do not reflect the views of Straight Arrow News.

Weekly Voices

Left Opinion Right Opinion

Wednesday

Left Opinion Right Opinion

Thursday

Left Opinion Right Opinion

Friday

Left Opinion Right Opinion

By entering your email, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and acknowledge the Privacy Policy.