Skip to main content
Commentary

China’s Fujian aircraft carrier is nothing to worry about

May 6

Share

A number of U.S. commentators have raised alarms over China’s rapid construction of naval military vessels — and about China’s supposed ability to outproduce the United States in any long, protracted conflict. Recently, China unveiled a new aircraft supercarrier named the Fujian. These developments coincide with increasingly aggressive Chinese naval behavior.

Straight Arrow News contributor Peter Zeihan talks down some of the hype surrounding China’s growing naval power, and reassures Americans that they have nothing to worry about when it comes to these new Chinese vessels.

Below is an edited excerpt from Peter’s May 6 “Zeihan on Geopolitics” newsletter:

The newest Chinese aircraft carrier, the Fujian, has officially hit the seas. This a major development for the Chinese Navy, but still falls short when compared to advanced counterparts (i.e. the U.S.).

The Fujian is intended to be a test bed, meaning the Chinese will throw all of their tech onto it and see what works. Which means we’re still a ways out from seeing an actual combat vessel hit the water.

Despite all the “advancements” we’re seeing on the Fujian, the Chinese still opted out of the nuclear power option. So with a limited range and no intention of ever seeing combat, the Fujian doesn’t drastically alter my forecast for China’s naval capabilities.

Everybody, Peter Zeihan here coming to you from Colorado. For those of you been watching me for a while, you know that every once in a while I do a webinar on a topic of the moment and we’re going to be doing that again, this coming Friday, May 10, at noon, Eastern, which of course, I get the time zones right would be 11am, Central 10am Mountain, and nine a m Pacific to be about 45 minutes of going through all the crazy that we’ve seen in the energy markets going back to the end of COVID. Explaining why we are where we are now, and what to expect over the next 12 to 24 months. I’ll be going for about 45 minutes, and then we’ll have ample time for q&a at the end. So you can sign up via the link that is attached to this email or this Twitter feed. And I hope to see everyone there. Morning, everybody. Peter zine here coming to you from Phoenix, Arizona, taking an entry from the ask Peter series today. Specifically, the Chinese have just floated their third aircraft carrier the Fujian and does this change my general assessment that the Chinese navy is kind of a joke. Maybe a little, let’s give you the backdrop. Okay, so the United States has been engaged in carrier aviation for over a century at this point. And we have 10 ships of the Nimitz class, which are the super carriers which are typically considered the gold standard in terms of their operational capability, their nuclear power, they carry dozens of fighters and fighter bombers each and their capacity to operate around the world is unlimited and unparalleled. In addition, these are now the old ships, United States is in the process of floating a new type of carrier called the Ford class, which is bigger, has more speed has more carrying capacity, and can strike faster and maintain more sorties at the same time and get them out faster. In comparison, most of the world’s other carriers are very limited. The Brits are in the process of trying to get to super carriers. Very, very loosely modeled author of the American Nimitz is in operation right now, the Japanese have converted to things that they call helicopter destroyers into medium sized carriers. And then there’s a huge drop to everybody else. So for example, the French do have the Charles de Gaulle, which is technically a super carrier, but it has a hard time generating enough power to get up to speed to launch fighters, unless the weather is absolutely perfect. And then there’s another huge drop to everybody else like say, the ties with the Indians. The Chinese are kind of in the middle, well below the Japanese well below the Brits, they have three carriers. Now, first one is actually an old Soviet carrier that was built in the 80s. But it was never completed. And then it rusted in Ukrainian port for a decade where the Ukrainians basically stripped it for metals. And then it got towed to China and sold. And eventually a rechristened as the sorry, I can’t remember the name. It was originally the party like, and no one in China, who is in the military, especially is in the Navy will ever consider the bad vessels, anything other than a test of China’s ability to just comprehend what carrier aviation is, it is never never never, never intended to see combat in any form. The second Chinese carrier is a clone of that first one, that’s the Lebanon. And it again, isn’t all that great. It is just a clone of an old Soviet model. And it was the Chinese attempt to see if they could take 1970s technology that did not work very well, and bring it into the modern age a little bit. Most of the parts are the same, but they have put in some things like new avionics, and sensors. And again, no one in the Chinese navy would consider it a combat vessel. It’s a test vessel. The new one that we have the Fuji on is their first domestically designed one. And that means that it’s certainly better and uses more current technology. But again, the Chinese navy is not talking about this thing. As a combat vessel. It is a testbed Think of it like for those of you who will like the Navy stuff, think of it like the enterprise, not the USS Enterprise of the United Federation, planets and Star Trek coming out the American carrier enterprise, which was designed as a testbed for a whole host of new technologies. This is China’s first attempt to build something that actually floats and theoretically down the road could see combat. But this isn’t the one that would do it. This would be in theory, if everything works out perfectly, which will take them years to figure out this would be the model that other carriers would then be built on. So yes, the Chinese have three carriers. Yes, they are taking steps forward in their operations constructions, but they’re coming from a century behind. And they still very honest with themselves here are not claiming that any of these are combat vehicles. One more thing to keep in mind. The Fuji on the new one isn’t nuclear powered. So you’ve got an 80,000 ton vehicle that still has to burn fuel, which means that its range is sharply limited. And it can’t go much further than most of the rest of the Chinese navy, which is largely limited to operating within 1000 miles of the Chinese coast. So is this significant? Sure. And if they keep up their current pace, they will be able to have a carrier that can stand up to an American carrier that’s 50 years old, and the next decade or two, not something that changes my forecast all that much.

Video Library

Latest Commentary

We know it is important to hear from a diverse range of observers on the complex topics we face and believe our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions.

The commentaries published in this section are solely those of the contributors and do not reflect the views of Straight Arrow News.


Latest Opinions

In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum. We hope these different voices will help you reach your own conclusions.

The opinions published in this section are solely those of the contributors and do not reflect the views of Straight Arrow News.

Weekly Voices

Left Opinion Right Opinion

Tuesday

Left Opinion Right Opinion

Wednesday

Left Opinion Right Opinion

Thursday

Left Opinion Right Opinion

Friday

Left Opinion Right Opinion