![Solar energy is often mentioned as a solution to the climate crisis. But solar could be more of a problem than many of us realize.](https://san.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/Solar-energy-may-be-more-of-a-problem-than-we-realize.jpg?w=1920)
Commentary
-
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
Hi everyone, Peter Zeihan here coming to you from Central Yosemite just south of Quartzite Peak. This is a very difficult place to get to, in my opinion, the view makes it worth it. But it’s two days of off trail travel in the most rugged parts of the park.
Let’s talk about something else that we hope is worth it. And that is green tech, solar and wind, particularly. Now, photovoltaic cells are…they’re heralded as a cure-all. The idea is you can put them anywhere, get a little bit of juice from the sun, it’s better than any sort of fossil fuels, and that is total and absolute crap. The process for producing PVs is extraordinarily damaging to the environment, if it’s done wrong. And even if it’s done right, it’s a bit of a question as to whether or not you can put the panels in the right place.
Now, the silicon that goes into the PV panels themselves is not hard to get. Silicon is one of the more common elements and you can mine quartz in a lot of places. Then there are a half a dozen places that can refine it into solar-grade silicon. However, that process basically involves a blast furnace. And if you’re doing this in China, which is where nearly half of it is done, you’re talking about doing it with coal. So already the carbon footprint for the process is extreme.
And then, most of the assembly for the panels is done in China as well, usually in places like Ji-jang, where it’s done by slave labor. So already you got all these things that are kind of stacking up against solar right from the get go. Now, this is all okay, right, if you’re able to get an environmental benefit on the back end. Well, there are a lot of places in the world that are not particularly sunny. And most of those are places where we have our big cities.
So for example, here I am in the highlands of the Sierras. If I was to put panels here, they’d do really well. We’re at high elevation, they have a lot of long sun days, it would be fine. Unfortunately, not a lot of people live here. Take those same panels and you move them to Seattle, or Toronto, or New York, or Boston or London, or Copenhagen, or Stockholm, or Shanghai, or Hong Kong, and they’re going to generate less than 1/5 the amount of electricity.
So whatever, you’re willing to suck up on the front end, you need those panels to run five times as long in order to make good. And in most of those cities that I listed, that means you will never break even on just the carbon debt, to say nothing of the trade issues, or the human rights issues.
Now, does that mean that solar is pointless, you can’t put it anywhere? Of course not. If you’re put in a sunny place, say Albuquerque, New Mexico, where I live in Denver, Durban, South Africa, most places in say, Italy or Greece, there are a lot of places where it makes a lot of sense. But there are far more where it makes none whatsoever. And then of course, there’s a transmission issue.
You don’t put panels in New York, because it’s too densely populated. You have to put them outside of the city. And if you want to put them outside the city far enough away that they actually generate a meaningful trickle of power, you’re talking then about wiring it at least 500 miles. And now you have another issue with transmission and all the things that go with that.
So that’s solar. Wind, much better.
There’s nothing toxic involved in the manufacturing. A lot of the manufacturing is either done in the United States or in Denmark, using some sort of carbon fiber and then some aluminum. There is a carbon footprint to both of those, but it’s nothing compared to what you have to do for silicon. And unlike solar, which seems to have this mystique, wind doesn’t. No one thinks that they should put wind turbines where it’s not windy. But people think that they should put solar panels where it’s not sunny.
And so wind turbines are only going up in places that it makes sense. So American Great Plains are great. For example, there’s some places in California that are good. In the case of Europe, anywhere in the vicinity of the North Sea looks great. The Danes get about half of their power from wind. And then there are a number of places around the world that look good as well.
There’s still the problem of co-locating that production with population centers, but it’s not nearly as messy in the case of wind because we’re now seeing a technological advance with wind.
It used to be that the turbines were only 100 feet tall. And so unless you had wind right there on the ground, it didn’t make much sense. But as our engineering has improved, it’s under 200, 300 to now almost 800 feet. And that means there’s larger parts of the planet. We’ve seen like a quadrupling of zones of the planet where wind now makes sense. And as you reach higher, something else happens. You tap wind currents that are not just stronger, that are more reliable. I’m gonna rotate a little bit here so you can see more of the view. That’s where I went like four years ago. Anyway.
Because of that, for per dollar invested in wind versus solar, you’re going to generate about three to four times as much electricity. In addition, those stronger, more reliable currents can now start to be used for baseload capacity, which is really important. One of the problems we have with wind versus solar and wind versus solar versus everything else is intermittency. Obviously, the wind doesn’t always blow and there has never been one iota of solar energy generated after sunset. And yet, prime demand in most cities in the world is after 6pm for electricity. And that means solar can never be part of peak demand. But now wind can.
So not only you’re getting that three or four to one price difference in terms of solar versus wind, wind is actually more useful overall, because the wind can burn…I’m sorry, the wind can blow at times when we need the power the most.
Now, the problem we have is that everyone is believing this mystique on solar and so in most populated zones in most of the planet, solar has become part of the environmental problem rather than part of the solution. And until we can get past that until we can actually match technologies to locations, the Green Movement is actually in many cases, causing more damage than help. Except for wind. Wind is great. Okay, that’s it for me. Until next time.
-
Is the US looking for a war?
With conflicts, skirmishes and tensions simmering around the globe, and with the United States playing supporting roles in several of them, the question of whether the country getting involved directly is legitimate. The war in Ukraine, for example, has forced several European countries to reintroduce mandatory military service to confront the growing threat from Moscow.…
-
How future generations could shift US support for Israel
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu addressed a joint meeting of Congress on July 24, calling for increased bipartisan support for Israel amid its 10-month war with Hamas. He praised President Biden’s “half century of friendship to Israel” and referred to Hamas as “sheer evil.” In the video above, Straight Arrow News contributor Peter Zeihan analyzes…
-
Why election of European Commission president is so important
Ursula von der Leyen has been reelected to another five-year term as president of the European Commission after a vote by EU lawmakers. Von der Leyen will now preside over a coalition that shifted to the right after recent European elections, where ultra-conservative parties won a record number of seats. In July, von der Leyen…
-
Protests in Bangladesh signal more trouble ahead
Public protests in Bangladesh against government hiring practices — and against the government’s military response to those protests — have left at least 174 dead and 2,500 jailed. Bangladesh’s people face an acute jobs and unemployment crisis, so public disagreements over hiring practices carry significant weight. The regime recently enforced a nationwide internet blackout as…
-
In US election, early polling doesn’t tell us anything yet
From President Joe Biden’s declining health to the attempted assassination of Donald Trump, there’s been a series of major political developments in the United States that might impact the results of the November election. These developments have led to renewed confusion, concern and debate regarding which candidate might win, and in the Democrats’ case, which…
Latest Stories
-
U.S. Department of Defense
Congress still trying to figure out how to reduce wasteful military spending
-
DVIDS
US Navy, Air Force making waves with new weapons at RIMPAC
-
Getty Images
Israeli PM Netanyahu meets with Trump at Mar-a-Lago
-
Getty Images
Growing US nuclear power resurgence reaches the nation’s heartland
-
Getty Images
Beer from the sun, other solar thermal projects get government funding
Popular Opinions
-
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Latest Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum. We hope these different voices will help you reach your own conclusions.
The opinions published in this section are solely those of the contributors and do not reflect the views of Straight Arrow News.
Latest Commentary
We know it is important to hear from a diverse range of observers on the complex topics we face and believe our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions.
The commentaries published in this section are solely those of the contributors and do not reflect the views of Straight Arrow News.
Peter Zeihan
Geopolitical StrategistHow future generations could shift US support for Israel
Why election of European Commission president is so important
Protests in Bangladesh signal more trouble ahead
Dr. Frank Luntz
Pollster and Political Analyst‘I don’t know’: Swing voters debate who best to replace Biden
‘Mad as hell’: Americans vent anger, frustration over politics
‘On death’s door’: Undecided voters react to first debate