Skip to main content

Commentary

Commentary

Unemployment among China’s youth marks beginning of the end

Jul 26, 2023

Share

Young people in China are being shut out of the labor market, causing unemployment rates among people ages 16 to 24 to surge to a record 21.3% in June. China’s powerhouse manufacturing industry is shrinking as businesses continue to leave the country and the highly educated cohort with dreams of securing high-skilled, high-wage work in IT and engineering, cannot find jobs.

Straight Arrow News contributor Peter Zeihan outlines in three parts how China’s broken manufacturing economy is leading to “massive disconnects” in the Chinese employment system.

An excerpt from Peter’s July 26 “Zeihan on Geopolitics” newsletter:

Coming to you from Colorado’s very own Stonehenge out in the Lost Wilderness. Today’s new factoid is that youth unemployment in China is higher than in Italy (in percentage terms).

For context, Italy had the worst economic profile in Europe and has averaged negative economic growth for decades. If China’s unemployment resembles Italy’s, it is a very, very bad sign. Let’s break this down in the context of manufacturing.

Phase 1. Everyone is reshoring and pulling investments from China. Young people are pursuing IT jobs instead of manufacturing jobs. The problem is that China is a closed system that sucks at all things tech.

Phase 2. Xi’s cult of personality has ensured that China’s labor force won’t be able to develop into a value-add or tech-based system. Meaning everything will get significantly worse, and there’s not much hope of it getting better.

Phase 3. Remember the last time something like this happened in the Chinese system? We ended up with the Tiananmen Square protests. While that triggered the change in the political system we see today, Xi’s wiped away any opportunity for such change to happen now.

When a disconnect like this happens in the employment system, it inevitably translates over to the economic system. I’m not suggesting that this is the end, but this is how ends begin…

Hey everybody, Peter Zeihan here coming to you from Colorado’s lost wilderness. You’ve got Colorado’s very own Stonehenge there behind me and the mosquito range of stuff Colorado just behind that. Where I’m going to be the next few days. 

 

Anyway, today we’re going to talk about a new little factoid that boiled up as I was on my way out here: youth unemployment in China is now higher in percentage terms than it is in Italy. Italy, probably the most moribund economy in Europe, and generally, the one with the worst economic profile. Average economic growth out of Italy has averaged over the last 20 years, 25 years to be negative. And have China facing a similar situation with employment is a very, very bad sign. 

 

Let’s break this down from a manufacturing point of view, because that’s really where this all hits. Number one, everyone’s reshoring — investment is flowing out of the country, even Chinese companies are moving. So that is a huge hit to the engineering model, and the manufacturing model, because if you have a huge amount of unemployment, already, that would normally say that you should be pushing down labor costs to make your jobs more competitive, your economy more competitive, that is not happening. Because, number two, young people in China don’t want to work in manufacturing, they want to work in information technology jobs, they want to work in the knowledge economy. 

 

But that brings us to the third problem, is that China sucks at those things. One of the things that allows you to have a meaningful knowledge-based economy is you have to allow your people to think, and when you’ve got a state that specifically cracks down on any sort of independent discourse on anything, and has now reached to the point that foreigners can’t even access economic data like weather data, you cannot possibly train up a mass employment system where everyone is capable of value added knowledge work. 

 

So more and more people don’t want to do the manufacturing work. At the same time, more and more foreigners don’t want to do the manufacturing work in China, at the same time, that the labor force is no longer right skilled for what the Chinese are actually decent at. And I would argue that the Chinese aren’t even all that decent at manufacturing anymore, because the cost of labor keeps going up. Remember, this is a country that is in a demographic bomb. Okay, so that kind of all of that is phase one. 

 

Phase two is that you should expect all of this to get significantly worse, with no chance of getting better. Chairman Xi has created a cult of personality that is one of the strictest in human history. He absolutely has more power into his person than any Chinese leader in history, and arguably, even more than say, the Roman Empire of old. You’ve got a population that doesn’t want to do the work that their economy is designed for another infrastructure is designed for, and Xi is ensuring that the labor force will never be able to evolve in a more productive direction that is more value added and more knowledge based. This is just what the Chinese system happens to look like now. 

 

But Third, and perhaps most importantly, and maybe a little sexy, is the last time the Chinese had this sort of disconnect between labor quality and the economic structure of the economy overall, you had a lot of very young people who thought they were going into the knowledge businesses, who suddenly discovered those jobs were never going to be available, and they got together and they went on a long walk together, and they had some protests. 

 

Now in China, this has been suppressed. But the rest of the world knows this is the Tiananmen Square protests that ultimately led to the massacres around 1989 to 1992, triggering the change in the political system that has proceeded until now. Only this time, instead of having a number of factions within the Chinese system, who can come together with a compromised system to play it forward, led by at the time Deng Xiaoping, this time, anyone who has any independent power has been utterly destroyed by Chairman Xi Jinping. 

 

So if we do get a break because of this, this is it. This is the end. Now, I’ve always believed that this is going to be the last decade of the Chinese system. But the degree of narcissistic myopia that we are seeing out of Beijing really has gotten to just massive levels. And now that we’re having massive disconnects within the employment system, it’s only a matter of time before that translates into massive disconnects in the economic system as a whole, and that cannot happen without a political after effect. I don’t want to suggest that this is the end. But this is how ends begin.

 

Take care.

Video Library

Latest Commentary

We know it is important to hear from a diverse range of observers on the complex topics we face and believe our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions.

The commentaries published in this section are solely those of the contributors and do not reflect the views of Straight Arrow News.


Latest Opinions

In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum. We hope these different voices will help you reach your own conclusions.

The opinions published in this section are solely those of the contributors and do not reflect the views of Straight Arrow News.

Weekly Voices

Left Opinion Right Opinion

Wednesday

Left Opinion Right Opinion

Thursday

Left Opinion Right Opinion

Friday

Left Opinion Right Opinion